Software
Houzz Logo Print
greybird_gw

Growing rose bed phenomenon

17 years ago

I am digging in my rose beds this AM, a really nice day other than the wind is picking up. I am laying manure/compost and mulch, noticing the annual "growing flower bed phenomenom". The level of the medium on the flower side is trying to cover the border that hold all this in. This entails digging up the natural rock borders and leveling them up a little higher. I add manure and compost 2-3 times a year, mulch at least once. When I initially establish a bed, I make sure the border is plenty high enough, but inevitably, this phenomenom occurs yearly, or at least every other.

Does anyone else see this in their rose gardens and what do you do? (Re-adjusting the borders can be a very big job!)

Comments (12)

  • 17 years ago

    Maybe your border is sinking, do you have moles?

  • 17 years ago

    greybird, since my garden is fairly new, I've had to add borders/edging this season where there were none. I probably have need for more edging, but funds are in short supply. My assumption (and hope) is that this new organic matter will get used up, and the level of the bed will sink in the process. Either that or my patio will be downhill from the rosebeds by next season. I, too, added voluminous horse manure compost and oak leaves for mulch. It's amazing how much the terrain of my garden has changed!

    And yes, gardening is very labor-intensive every which way you turn.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    We've not had this happen. Borders laid down 20 years back are still where they should be.
    I advise you strongly, however, not to use landscape timbers to border beds.
    Those don't sink, but they do get dry rot, and turn into mulch.

    Jeri

  • 17 years ago

    p_lisette, I totally have moles and voles and gophers. And they love to tunnel-run under rock borders. Likely the rocks are sinking.

    Sherry, my assumption was as yours, but the organic matter just turns into more dirt or something. I have the downhill thing going on.

    Jeri, I envy your borders, you must have clay soil. Everything stays put more it clay.

  • 17 years ago

    I not sure if your border is on a slope or not ... I've had movement occur on a fairly steep terraced slope and the movement is natural for the field stone border I used (I just plopped them down original).

    I have seen 4 foot high concrete retaining walls tumble from the soil pressure due to bad design practices on slopes ... yet my 16 inch high timber tied back yard border on a gentle slope I did myself has not gone off vertical after 8 years ... drove about a bizzilion 4 foot pieces of rebar through the ties into the ground as opposed to using dead men in the ties (needed the border to get the bed depth to bury the grafts for winter).

  • 17 years ago

    Jeri, I envy your borders, you must have clay soil. Everything stays put more it clay.

    *** Oh good Lord no. Our soil for the most part is a sort of decomposed sandstone, with little or no organic elements. Ugly stuff.
    All of the topsoil, I suppose, washed down onto the Oxnard Plain, long, long ago.

    Jeri

  • 17 years ago

    My original HT bed is shown in the picture below: The area enclosed by the scalloped border blocks. Seven years ago there were no border blocks and the bed was level with the brick patio. Its at least 8" higher than the patio level now and I am constantly raking or hoeing material away from the border and back toward the roses.

    No mystery here. I regularly throw any leaves, soil or mulch available around the roses. It spreads out and onto the patio unless I am diligent. Just keeps gettin' higher...


    {{gwi:229056}}

  • 17 years ago

    Well, I don't understand this. What greybird, Harry and I are talking about is beds that increase in height with added compost and mulch and overspill the edging, requiring raising the edging to hold in the new compost & mulch. Nothing is sinking; that's the problem. I didn't know it would keep getting higher and higher. I've read here about sinking beds, and I thought porous soils (sand) were supposed to lose organic matter and settle. This is a different ball game that can't continue indefinitely; my house will be in a hole!! And it begs the question: do I need all this new organic matter every year if it isn't disappearing? I thought the answer was yes, but the physical evidence is contradictory. Help!!

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    My personal experience (and my mom's) is that beds do sink over time. Perhaps it is a matter of how much mulch and compost is added.
    Masha

  • 17 years ago

    I wish somebody had a solution for our rising beds. We're just putting too much stuff in there. I know the once poor "sugar sand" in my beds is now black and full of earthworms. Maybe you're supposed to slow down on the heavy amending once you get it where it needs to be?

  • 17 years ago

    Well, I'm thinkin' once a year will be enough. We don't want to make those earthworms TOO happy.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    Now I get it, yes I have it but it is because of my peat moss I use every year for protection (turn a lot into the soil) and a persistent urge to add "black earth" topping. The result is some of my grafts are over 12" deep on the older ones. I even robbed from the side of the house some landscape blocks to raise the bed further. Yet I keep thinking I see parts of beds are sinking and keep adding until ... it is hard to resist that urge ... not sure what causes it .. I begining to believe I am a hypochrondriac.