Software
Houzz Logo Print
kimhg

cleaning up to help with thrips

17 years ago

I've shoveled up as much mulch as I could from my main bed. I think I will try to compost it in plastic bags until next year.

Hopefully a lot of thrip larva were shoveled up.

I plan to spray with spinosad at least weekly for the next month. Also, maybe some Agroneem, extract of Neem.

I usually use Bayer imidacloprid, but this year I am trying to avoid to help my worms and other beneficials.

And it is not as if it helped that much anyway.

I have so many thrips for several months out of the year.

Does this plan sound good, or does anyone have more suggestions?

Also, I have Avid, should I go ahead and use it also?

My roses are just starting to bloom now, and I have seen some thrips already. I tried beneficial nematodes a few years ago, with no noticeable effect. I may try again, though. I released pirate bugs and pred. mites 2 yrs ago.

Thanks for any input

Kim

Comments (16)

  • 17 years ago

    Flower thrips have many hosts other than roses, so sanitation is not going to get rid of them. They are constantly blowing in from around the neighborhood. The real key is weather patterns that allow the thrips to outbreed their predators or vice versa. In my garden natural controls usually prevent substantial damage, but some years, not.

    Spinosad should work better than imidocloprid. I would recommend only using it when the buds are close to opening.

  • 17 years ago

    I wonder if ladybugs would help control thrips. I've seen some nurseries around here sell them. The trick is not to make them fly away! I think you release them at sunset underneath mature roses where the thrips are and ladybugs do not generally fly away when it's getting dark so that may give them time to find food source and start eating thrips.

    Nematodes work in the soil so I'm not sure how that controls thrips? It apparently help control ants in a big way though.

  • 17 years ago

    Thrips pupate in the mulch or soil where nematodes can get to them. Predatory mites and pirate bugs are two of the main natural controls. Usually it is not necessary to supply them, just to avoid wiping them out.

  • 17 years ago

    I know I still have pirate bugs, they are as large as gnats so I can see them in the blooms. Unfortunately there are alot more thrips than pirate bugs.

    Ladybugs like aphids, I am not sure about thrips.
    I usually only have a few aphids early in the season, they seem much easier to control than thrips.

    Funny thing is, there are much fewer thrips in the front yard than back. Tiffany and Peace out front are barely affected, while I had to give away Memorial Day and a Double Delight in the backyard.
    Still have Gemini, Peace, Sterling Silver, and a new Double Delight in the back I want to help out.
    There are a lot of thrips in the reds and dark pinks, too, just not quite as many and the damage is less obvious.
    I soak my flowers under water after cutting to drown what thrips I can, that is if the blooms look fairly ok.

  • 17 years ago

    Regular make-the-blooms-ugly but recognizable or Chili Thrips kill-the-whole-rose-but make the whole thing ugly first?

    I know both are in Texas, and remedies are different.

  • 17 years ago

    Ladybugs do eat thrips after all when I googled for more info about it. Click on the link...

    Here is a link that might be useful: thrip control

  • 17 years ago

    Maybe I will get some ladybugs, too.

    Ann, I would say regular thrips, though you did make me google some on this question.

    This year I noticed lots of blind shoots and some buds that don't open up and look like the top was chewed off.
    I think it is rose midge damage, not thrips. It is on 4 bushes. 2 were new and might have brought them in.

    I don't see any leaf damage and bronzing like the chili thrips cause.

  • 17 years ago

    I personally think you are wasting your time. Around here if we are close to the winter wheat, rye or oats harvest, thrips are going to be all over the place. We couldn't possibly clean them all out of that habitat. Since they are only here for a very short time, until the harvests are over, we just spray with the anti-thrip stuff and wait for them to die, and they will soon enough.

  • 17 years ago

    Kim, I don't think you have rose midge in Texas.

  • 17 years ago

    I have spent 2 hours trying to figure out how to get pics on here. I settled on a link to flickr.
    Pics are of my chewed on rose bud problem, and blind shoot problem.
    Could it be from aphids, instead of rose midge?
    I once saw what I thought was an adult midge, but I'd be happy not to have it, hope you are right, Michael.
    Kim

    Here is a link that might be useful: rose problems

  • 17 years ago

    Chewed buds-- chewing insect such as a beetle, caterpillar, or katydid. If there is more damage in the same area, look for a lurking worm.

    Blind shoots-- if there is no midge problem in your area, perhaps a weakness of the underlying old cane, such as freeze damage (can occur at 10-12 F), canker of the bark, or cane borer. Also some roses make a few short blind shoots around the base for no reason except rosy indecision.

  • 17 years ago

    Sorry I didn't look before posting.

    They do show the type of damage associated with midge, but it is not necessarily that. Midge damage builds up over the season to the point that plants can hardly grow. If this turns out to me a temporary problem, you can probably stop worrying about midge.

  • 17 years ago

    michael, is that true about weather patterns? The first few years I had roses, I didn't have thrips, but like everyone here the past 2 we've been hit hard. Down here we all blame the hurricanes from 2005 from blowing them up here. I don't know if that's true or not.

    And my opinion or observation is that the predators only show up when they see a food source, so the thrips are always going to have a head start. I'm considering buying some pirate bugs or whatever they are and seeing if they make a difference. Or maybe I'll just get those yellow thrip traps. Go low maintenance on the thrips.

  • 17 years ago

    buford, the prey always has a head start on the predators, but its a question of how much. Two years ago when the thrips plague hit SC, GA, and AL, I saw an extension bulletin that referred to the spring weather, unusually warm and dry if I recall correctly, supposedly accelerating the thrips' reproduction.

    I've been lucky here, in 30 seasons never having them real bad. A couple of years were considerably worse than average. Usually I hardly notice them until around the end of the first flush and it stops there. I always have lots of pirate bugs. I usually don't do anything.

  • 17 years ago

    We lease our hayfields out and ask that our fields be cut as early as possible. At that time of the year, I do see thrips even on my computer moniter. They are very efficient fliers.

    Instead of buying traps, buy yellow dixie cups and white dixie cups. Spray their outsides with stick-um and hang them around your roses. Soon you'll see a fuzz of thrips on the cups. (It is both disgusting and stangely satisfying.) Replace and repeat as needed.
    My own philosophy is not to spray insecticides/miticides/-cides because that just sets back the predator populations.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks mike and ann. I haven't used insecticides in 2 years. And our spring this year seems to be on the cool wet side, so maybe there is hope for this years first flush! I'll try the dixie cups too.