Software
Houzz Logo Print
ispahan

Help me choose a small tree for pollinators

I am removing a large, decrepit old elm tree from my back garden and would like to replace it with a smaller, late summer blooming specimen tree. Here are my specifications:

-Zone 6a urban Chicago with sandy, very well-drained, alkaline soil
-8-12 hours of full direct sun per day, depending on time of year
-Preferably no more than 25-30 feet tall (think mature Cornus florida size)
-August/September blooms that attract a wide variety of pollinators
-No unpleasant odors (like nasty Ailanthus, for example)
-Root system and shade canopy that would be suitable for underplanting with appropriate bulbs, perennials, etc.
-Attractive growth habit and good fall foliage colors would be a nice bonus

Here are a few of the trees I am wondering about:

1. Rhus chinensis. I read that it would need to be trained into tree form and would need periodic suckering control (neither one is a problem). Does it need separate male and female plants for fruiting?
2. Heptacodium miconioides. Someone in my neighborhood has a mature specimen growing. I admire its late bloom season, fragrance and growth habit, but I am not sure I love it enough yet for my own small garden.
3. Tetradium daniellii. I have read conflicting reports about its cold hardiness and ultimate size, but it sounds intriguing.
4. Oxydendrum arboreum. I love the look of this tree, but I am afraid it would struggle in my alkaline soil. Does anyone grow it in alkaline conditions?

Are there any other trees I have overlooked? Thank you all so much for your comments and suggestions.

Ispahan

Comments (21)

  • 13 years ago

    Possibly Koelreuteria, if it's not weedy there etc. Heptacodium will probably want better dirt, sourwood will definitely not succeed in alkaline.

  • 13 years ago

    Franklinia alatamaha
    Hydrangea paniculata
    Hydrangea paniculata Vanilla Strawberry is choice.

    I grow Rhus chinensis as a trained single trunk specimen. I like it a lot.

    Dax

  • 13 years ago

    well have you thought about Crape Myrtles? they can take full harsh sun and can grow to about a good 20 feet they can also take alkaline soil, It has a good orange/red fall color, blooms from early june to about october or late september

  • 13 years ago

    Scratch the Franklinia. I didn't realize it needed acidic conditions.

    Dax

  • 13 years ago

    Carolina Silverbell (Halesia carolina)is very attractive to many pollinators including bees.

  • 13 years ago

    I don't see crape myrtle as being good for pollinators. You definitely want to look into large shrubs; not that many trees bloom in Aug/Sept.

    I think Hydrangea paniculata as suggested earlier is a good bet.

  • 13 years ago

    I have tried Oxydendron in my neutral pH soil and even in that it languishes. They call it sourwood for a reason, I guess!

    If you are looking for a good nectar source, see if you have a local beekeeper's association. Ours here provides a list of good nectar sources by season. You might also step up your plantings of late season blooming perennials or shrubs and take care of your pollinators that way, rather than with the tree.

  • 13 years ago

    As stated, VERY few trees flower that time of year. Not as late flowering as you ask for, but Cotinus obovatus American Smoke Tree fits the other criteria nicely, and will love highly draining alkaline soil. The foilage is a nice Aqua blue-green in summer, so that would add visual appeal. Add that it is rare even in it's native habitat.

    For pollinators that time of year, you will need to look to wildflowers, especially the "composite's" like coneflowers among others.

    Arktrees

  • 13 years ago

    Tetradium daniellii is zone 5 hardy no problem but questionable in zone 4.

    I myself love Heptacodium miconioides but their form can very greatly. If you are patient and can prune and train it to your liking you'll be in business. Otherwise you need to select a specimen in person.

    Tangent alert!

    Dax, as a paniculata nut, Vanilla Strawberry is the second worst cultivar I've run into as its leggy, open and more susepctiable to breakage for this reason. Where have you seen nice specimens? Its rare that I actually discourage certain cultivars based on performance in normal conditions so I'm just curious as to your experience. Some folks in the Hydrangea forum have tagged it as a bust too.

  • 13 years ago

    Kalopanax septemlobus is late-flowering and good for pollinators, but would likely get too large (20 metres plus) for you in the long term.

    Tetradium is definitely worth a try though.

    Resin

  • 13 years ago

    Vitex agnus (Chaste tree) would fit everything except that I am not sure it would do so well if your soil is truly alkaline - neutral would be okay though. Acid probably best. Fall color is also lacking, but blooms last well into September and even October here in VA.

  • 13 years ago

    whaas, a web search let me to H.p. 'Vanilla Strawberry'. It simply appealed to me.

    I lost a Tetradium here but I don't know why. It's one I'd plant again.

    Dax

  • 13 years ago

    Interesting that I never saw honeybees bother w/standard Crape myrtle (maybe an occasional bumblebee). But my white-flowered Nachez crape attracts quite a few honeybees -- strictly for pollen, tho.

  • 13 years ago

    Nobody's mentioned Aralia elata or Aralia spinosa? Hard to beat either for a mid-late summer flowering species for pollinators (bees).

  • 13 years ago

    Part of the issue with the pollinators is whether you are seeking native pollinators (which here would be various wasps, some bees (not honeybees) or wanting to attract hived honeybees, which means that there would have to be hives close enough. Some nectar/pollen attracts both, some not.

    Re: Vitex agnus castus, it is so late to leaf out, so drab in autumn and completely uninteresting in winter (branching awkward) that I would not use it as a specimen planting. The color of the blooms on the blue varieties is stunning, though!

  • 13 years ago

    Indeed, Aralia spinosa would be a great choice - and it is tall too. Incredible magnet for late summer pollinators.

  • 13 years ago

    Heptacodium is hard to beat for attracting pollinators in September. It is truly a bee magnet (honeybees & bumblebees), and hummingbirds & butterflies also visit the flowers. As a bonus the seeds will draw birds in late fall / early winter. I counted 18 cardinals at one time in my Heptacodium early last winter (lots of birds in it this year too). It's quite adaptable to soils, and reasonably drought tolerant once established. On the "con" side, it may need supplemental watering for the first couple years, and as whaas indicated it requires a fair amount of pruning to keep it looking good.

    Speaking of high maintenance, I've seen established Chinese sumacs that were suckering aggressively.

    I've tried planting Tetradium twice, in an open/exposed location, but gave up both times due to susceptibility to late spring frost damage. Probably best to plant this species in a somewhat protected location for our zone.

  • 13 years ago

    Thank you all so much for your input and suggestions! I have now spent many happy hours researching the best small trees to provide the best combination of ease of growth, ornamental value, late summer/fall interest, and attractiveness to insect pollinators.

    I think I have settled on a selection of Koelreuteria paniculata called 'Rose Lantern' as my final selection. It flowers in August/September and is then followed by attractive rose-pink seed pods that provide striking contrast to the yellow fall foliage. I have never heard any reports of this tree being invasive in my area, and have read that the late blooming selections of Koelreuteria often do not have enough time to completely ripen their seeds in northern zones. Although not listed in their current catalogue, I was able to purchase this tree for spring delivery from ForestFarm. They also have the selection 'September' for sale, which is equally late blooming but has brown pods instead of pink (though still ornamental and attractive).

    Heptacodium also looks like a wonderful choice, but because my neighbor already grows one successfully I would feel strange about planting another so close by.

    Thank you all again. I look forward to spring planting! :-)

  • 13 years ago

    Ditto to the comments on Aralia spinosa.

    Be careful about Koelreuteria, it's getting a reputation for being invasive in your area.

    Resin

  • 13 years ago

    I loved reading about the Aralia and I am sure it would be a great choice, but it would be growing in a small back garden so I am worried about the spines.

    Pineresin, where do you see that Koelreuteria is becoming invasive in the Chicago area?

  • 13 years ago

    Shown for Illinois generally here. Invasives don't show any respect for boundaries, so if in your state, best to assume it will also be so at your location within the state.

    Resin