Software
Houzz Logo Print
treetoronto3

Overplanted vs underplanted trees

12 years ago

In Toronto, whoever was planting trees this last 50 years clearly thought only Norway Maple, Silver Maple, Linden and Ash existed. I'd guess Norway Maple takes up at least 50% of all plantings on street sides. Most have a girdling root. Oh how I hate (most) Norway Maples! Only now after Dutch Elm disease, Asian Longhorned Beetle and Emerald Ash Borer devesataion, did they think to diversify their tree canopy!

Trees that Toronto and surrounding boroughs finally planting are, Tulip trees, Beeches, Oaks(imagine Toronto has barely any Oaks), London Plane trees, Zelkova, Elm, Ginkgo, Hornbeam to name a few.

I have only seen a couple mature Red oaks, London Planes and Elms. Never seen the joy of seeing a mature White oak, Bur oak or Swamp white oak in Toronto. I salivate in cities like Seattle and Chicago with all their massive oaks!

What trees are overused in your city?
What trees are underused?

Comments (10)

  • 12 years ago

    In SoCal it is eucalyptus ad nauseum, to the detriment of our native oaks. Liquid amber is used alot too.

  • 12 years ago

    I dislike gratuitous monocultures. Some environmentalists complain about monocultures in agriculture, but there are real economic reasons related to economics of scale making monoculture easier on a farm...there is no real reason you have to have one in your yard.

    Whatever developer or large land owner used to own all the property on my parent's street planted a lot of black pine. A decade or so back a disease spread and killed off all of them...ALL of them. The yard suddenly looks bare.

    A lot of folks around here complaint about overplanting of Bradford Pear on streets recently, but I've never really minded them.

    I dislike the overplanting of Yew and Arborvitae because they are kind of boring trees.

    I think pawpaw, American Persimmon, Hawthorne, American Holly, crabapple, and beach are underused. The first two are among our few native fruit trees. The last two are just attractive trees.

  • 12 years ago

    Nathaniel Hawthorne is underused?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Hawthorne

    This post was edited by bboy on Tue, Jan 7, 14 at 0:52

  • 12 years ago

    Live oaks and crape myrtles are way overplanted here. Lately other oak species are getting planted - Q. austrina, Q. michauxii etc. and our city has done a good job overall. If i never see another live oak planted in the landscape that will be fine with me.

  • 12 years ago

    As far as city street trees are concerned, I think of diversity as a community-wide issue, not a street-by-street issue. So, in this conception, it is perfectly suitable, aesthetically pleasing, maintenance-freindly, and even mimics mother nature (In N. temperate regions anywyay) to plant all of the same species up and down a given street.

    That being said, it is important to seek out and implement as many suitable species as possible, again on a community basis.

    Another factor to bear in mind-the American elm was a near-perfect urban tree. Imposing in maturity, providing much shade, easy to grow, unfussy, etc.....it got planted all over heck for these and more similar reasons. Then, when Dutch elm disease came through, a huge number of empty planting spaces resulted. I've seen letters and articles from those days within my own city and I can report that very, very often, it was the homeowners themselves who insisted on "all maples" or some such directive. And back then, it was not yet known, the scourge that would be girdling roots on N. maple.

    Add in property owner's dislike for "dirty trees, "messy trees", trees that drop fruit, seedpod, or nut......trees which don't do well on narrow terrace strips, trees lacking in the proper size or growth form characteristcs for such usage..................you start to get the picture. Making tree selections for at least municiple arborists has not been easy over the last thirty or forty years.

    +oM

  • 12 years ago

    I think Golden Raintrees are WAY underused in the North. They may be invasive in the South, but they aren't in the North.

    I love my tree, it's tolerant of EVERYTHING.

    I think Red Maples are over planted...

  • 12 years ago

    There are an awful lot of sycamores around here, many streets lined with them. That can look cool, but if there is ever some sycamore blight, ugh!

  • 12 years ago

    Chinese pistasche (Pistacia chinensis) are nice trees, but more than enough were used in many Dallas area boulevard and park plantings during the 1990s. Before that it was Callery pear (Pyrus calleryana) and Crape myrtle (Lagerstroemia). More recently native Bald cypress (Taxodium distichum) has been "trending" in these locations... though more misplanted than overplanted since many have not been able to survive the drought years trying to get established within a small patch of soil surrounded by concrete.

    Variety is good, but anyone who has strolled, jogged, ridden a bike, or driven with the top down under the live oak canopies over the streets surrounding Rice University in Houston or segments of St. Charles Avenue in New Orleans knows how spectacular well considered "monocultures" can be. Here's hoping they thrive for another century or more as it seems fewer spaces have been planted with that kind of single species density after the lessons of DED and the expanding threats from oak wilt, EAB, etc.

  • 12 years ago

    Very stupid people continue to plant southern magnolias and live oaks in ordinary city lots, they just have to have them of course. In my old neighborhood I drove past a house for at least 10 years thinking it was part of the yard next door. Surprised I was when they cut down the two, probably 60-70 yr old magnolias and there was a big two story and very chi-chi house back there. Of course there wasn't any dwarf selections I don't think then, but it continues today, with even smaller houses. Then there's the big hulking live oaks smothering a little ranch house. It must be very dark.
    They are starting to plant Taxodium more now in commercial areas which is nice but still sometimes they put in Bradfords. We're seeing Little Gem magnolias too and they would be the perfect magnolia for a yard too, although I prefer Teddy Bear, just a nicer shape and nicer leaves I think.
    I have a love/hate with Crepe Myrtles and Knockouts but they are very good for color and pretty much no care. I have some knockouts myself, can't beat them for some color for 9 mos out of the year.
    Unfortunately, if it wasn't for the Bradfords and the Tallow trees we would not have much fall color here. The native hardwood forest is pretty dull.

  • 12 years ago

    Quite right, Bostedo-the monocultures certainly can be aesthetically impressive.

    I tend to view the common trees of any given area as being those which give that area its character. So, after most all the American elms died in the part of the world where I happen to live, it is probably the much-maligned silver maple which does the most to give character to city streets these days. But nobody champions the silver maples. Instead, they go all agog over some fancy-shmancy rarity somewhere, even though this rare tree does nothing for the overall feel of the area.

    Likewise in the forests-it's the most common or typical species which give character to those stands, not the oddball tree which remains all but hidden within the matrix.

    Still, yes, some plants can come to be overused. Right now, I'd say that, once again in my part of the world, it's not a single species which is being overdone, but rather, the trend towards mini-trees under power lines. I know, I know......power company's happy, etc........but there's no majesty, no framing of the streetscape, just a series of little lollipops, each separated by vast distances from the next, which I do not consider "urban forestry" anymore.

    +oM