Software
Houzz Logo Print
ewrightb

Cheap trees - how to choose?

19 years ago

I have a fairly wet property (some of the time, not perennially) so after a good rain my front yard is pretty squishy for several weeks, but it gets full sun. It faces north but in the summer it gets full-force sun all afternoon due to the lack of screening from the west.

I've been longing to plant a weeping willow in the low problem spot, as we are new owners and the previous owners were fans of a giant rectangle of bare grass as a front lawn, and it seems like we could do anything we want. I am in the process of building in beds and aim to reduce the lawn ultimately, and an off-center shade tree would fit the bill.

I have come across a super sale of 2-gallon potted trees, most at least 7-9 ft. tall, for $10 per pot. I am sure these are culls and that is why they are so cheap, but aside from the few obvious dog-legs and oddly formed specimens there are what seem to be perfectly good trees if you are willing to dig through what they have. They have several globe Navajo Willow (Salix matsudana), which are appealing to me because they do not get so huge as the weeping willow and will obviously enjoy the wet locale, and as I have a tall three-story house the tall, umbrella-like habit would complement the setting.

They also have river birch, of which most have at least two trunks for a clump, and they have some pretty decent specimens of this as well. I am leaning towards the river birch, since from my research the willow is going to bust any drainage pipes nearby (I know, if the pipes are not leaking already they won't bother them), steal water from my other recently planted trees and shrubs nearby, and be intolerably messy with leaves and limbs, and likely as not will fall over onto my house with the next stiff breeze. For all I know the river birch will do the same thing. I understand that folks tend to exaggerate their experiences on the internet and "results may vary" but it seems like there are fewer complaints about river birch than the willow family of trees.

I have really taxed my budget with the hedge shrubs and specimen trees I have purchased so far, so the bargain price is a siren song for me. I have been able to do well with discount trees in the past at our old property so I am sorely tempted, but want to make an informed decision on species. I have already gotten four red bud trees for the back yard, $10 each and already leafed out, to line the edge of the back woods, and I'd like to take full advantage of this sale, especially since they are offering trees I already had my eye on.

Suggestions and experiences would be helpful!

Comments (6)