Software
Houzz Logo Print
natural_sens

Pinus not doing well after winter

15 years ago

Planted a gorgeous semi mature dwarf pine tree last year in the fall(cant remember the species) and it is barely surviving this spring. It is in a raised planter with plenty of space for its root ball, shade to part shade location and we have been getting record amounts of rain this spring. The planter was equipped with adequate drainage medium.

It is half dead and I am in need of some last ditch effort advice to save it.

Anyone?

Thank you.

Comments (8)

  • 15 years ago

    Maybe it will live. Maybe not. Pines in planters are difficult. Without pics all you'll get are WAGs.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    More susceptible to root damage and dessication caused by cold in a raised planter.

    A "half dead" pine may never look good again or will take a while to do so.

  • 15 years ago

    The planter was equipped with adequate drainage medium.

    for a tree.. that would mean a media with little or no peat ... or any water retaining stuff ... almost a cactus mix ...

    pines like a drink.. and then near dry ...

    accumulation of water in winter is a possible death knell ... as well as freeze thaw in z5 .... how did you winter it over ...

    and this spring rains are not helping... most likely the roots are rotting ....

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    Part shade to shade is not a light situation most pines prefer or will even tolerate -- full sun is far more desirable. Combine that with issues involved with an elevated planter outlined above and a struggling plant is not an unexpected result.

    And I'd agree that a "half dead" pine is unlikely to recover to any sort of presentable appearance for a very visible planter. May be better to cut your loses now and replace with something more suitable for that type of planting situation.

  • 15 years ago

    I missed the 'shade' part. I agree, replant with a plant suited to that spot. Pines want full sun, which is why you see them growing in full sun in the wild, and the ones getting shaded out look sad.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you for all the input.

    As for drainage medium, it was installed in 2'6" of garden soil over a minimum of 8" of drain rock.

    The 3' high 4"x4" planter was insulated with styrofoam sheets to protect the roots from freeze damage.

    The location is pretty well isolated from winter winds.

    No additional winterization measures were taken.

    Is there a relatively straight forward way to analyze for root rot or just dig and check for saturation?

    Thank you and any additional advice is appreciated.

  • 15 years ago

    garden soil is not POTTING MEDIA ... engineered and predictable in its ability of holding and draining water ...

    if i had done this.. i would have used something like half bark chunks ... and half sand.. and half low peat potting media ... yeah 3 halves!!1... lol ... ok.. thirds ...

    water would basically go in the top.. and straight out the bottom.. and would leave you wondering if the tree would get enough .. but that is all a tree needs in a pot

    check out the link.. and how course the materials are .... i predict it was nothing like the garden soil you used.. and the rocks at the bottom are not the drainage we are talking about ... we are talking about how water moves thru the whole pot.. not just pooling out the bottom ...

    also check out this for general info:

    http://cactiguide.com/article/?article=article8.php

    if you are going to try again.. let us know.. before you start ..

    ken

    ps: here in MI.. i would have pulled it in the polebarn .. or covered the top so that water would be blocked from the soil in winter.. as well as insured the pot was out of winter sun ...

    pps: not many conifers.. which a pine is.. do well in shade ...

    Here is a link that might be useful: link

  • 15 years ago

    Like ken said. They sell potting soil for a reason: to put it in pots. You have a pot. You want potting soil. Garden soil is not for pots. And again, pines are grown in full sun. After the pine is gone, you'll want to re-think what goes in the pot after you take out all the dirt and replace with potting soil (and take out all the rocks as well, which are not needed and indeed can be detrimental). Plenty of good stuff on the container forum, just search for 'Tapla' for his tutorials.

    To recap: the pine is dying because the soil is inappropriate, it has rocks in the bottom, and it is in shade; container forum has many discussions on what to put in such containers.

    Dan