Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_8959062

very annoying colour combos

13 years ago

One moment of oversight and I have been paying for this for a decade. I planted 2 Graham Thomas roses (was I insane?) next to my beloved Madame Gregoire.Although I have tried to insert various modifying clems, I loathe the combination of pink and yellow....and with an absolutely minuscule garden and rose replant syndrome, I am sort of stuck with it. At the allotment, where I can dig at plants from all sides, moving is at least a possibility but in my home garden, this is not going to fly. The raised beds are high, small and dense, with high brick walls. To change this combination would literally mean ripping out an entire border....and this is so not going to happen. I can just about manage since both sets of roses are in the pink of health and lushness but really, had I been using my brain instead of my cheapskate tendency to plant what is available......
I know some of you are not remotely concerned with colour schemes...and probably, in a bigger garden, it wouldn't matter too much, but working in 36 square metres, such clashes cannot easily be overlooked. Still, just another reason why my garden will never even begin to attain perfection.

Comments (53)

  • 13 years ago

    and to make it even worse (and why there is no photo) there is a whopping great Rozanne underneath....which hates this southern wall and wilts during the middle 3 hours of the day. Every year, I curse myself for failing to move it while it was little, whereas by this point in the year it is a 5foot monster. I am wilfully avoiding eyes right and concentrating hard on the shady (if boring) north side of the garden.
    I am using my new camera in a desperate attempt to remind myself that the empty space in March will have vanished totally in less than 2 months.....

  • 13 years ago

    I also don't like pink and yellow together. I don't understand how 'Peace' rose pulls it off--that's pink and yellow for you, but it looks good on 'Peace'--just because there's only a touch of pink, maybe?

    {{gwi:276077}}

  • 13 years ago

    I have Crocosmia 'Lucifer' coming up next to a dark red rose. Shudder. You know Crocosmia. Dig it up. But wait! There's more. (It's left over from a previous arrangement.) Lately I've taken to pretending that what's needed is a soft companion. I've been attempting to tame the clash by sandwiching tall white and pastel fluff between the two. Still not so good.... What's the visual equivalent of sticking one's fingers in one's ears and singing "La, la, la. I don't hear you"?

    Carol

  • 13 years ago

    Two or three plantings ago, my most visible to our sitting area rose bed needed to be an opulent mass of fragrant deep red roses.

    Well, at least, that was my thought at the time.

    I accumulated and planted sixteen dr roses. I did all the right things to get them going well. Then they bloomed.

    First the colors were (maybe) dr, but so many different shades of dr and a few that should have been mr (on a good day).

    Then the wonderful wafts of fragrance- nope, didn't happen.

    Reality came with a shovel to my garden, once again.

  • 13 years ago

    Yes! There are certain colors that repel me every time I see them, and then there are certain colors that I can like if they are combined with white. I used to grow Praetoria canna for the striped leaves. I just kept the orange flowers cut off. Some yellows I can enjoy when they're grown with whites. Then they're not annoying to me. I don't care for a yellow that gets any darker than a soft pastel and that doesn't lean toward gold.

    As for color combos, I can handle different reds in the same bed (as long as they aren't orangy), but they do seem (to me) to clash if one has more blue so I prefer them not planted side by side. I prefer a red planted with a pink or white rather than two reds together. The only yellow I love is Stephen F. Austin (Carefree Beauty cross with Graham Thomas) maybe because it fades to a pale, delicate yellow in Texas. Love the yellow-pink petals of Mrs. Dudley Cross, but that yellow-pink blend and that of Tiffany is my limit.

    Just an idea, but do you think it has something to do with the colors that we look good wearing? I can't wear a yellow or an orange, and those are the colors I don't care for in my garden. Lou

  • 13 years ago

    Not trying to pull your chain, campanula (or not too much, anyway), but it does always astonish me how people have such different tastes.

    I can't find anything not to like about this definitely pink and yellow picture - my Cl Caroline Testout flopped over to visit the yellow banksia -

    Jackie

  • 13 years ago

    I'm with Jackie on this one: I like pink and yellow together. Cool pink with an acid greenish yellow or yellowish green is actually one of my favorite combinations. I'd have to see your GT and MGS together to form an opinion...'Graham Thomas' might be too golden a yellow to work.
    I think primary red is difficult (impossible) to work with. and is especially unappealing with cool pink or bright white, or any bright unshaded color. The purple-leaning reds are a lot more manageable, while brilliant poppy orange-red goes well with a really surprising range of colors: you wouldn't think it would, but it does. Brightness is fine, but I dislike hard flat colors, and there are some burnt-looking dark oranges that give me indigestion. And as Ann says, it's not colors but shades you need to pay attention to: not all reds are equal, or yellows, or oranges.

  • 13 years ago

    yep, most colours will go together providing the tones or shades are compatible - a bright primary colour can be difficult to pull off next to a muted shade which has been toned down with the addition of white, or brown or grey. And also, a primrose yellow would look perfectly acceptable but definitely not the golden yellow next to the very clear and true pink of Mme Greg.
    I actually had to give a small climbing rose, Laura Ford, away because it did that thing of yellow changing to pink. While this is absolutely OK in Mutabilis (the yellow being a soft chamois tone and the reds darkening through to a crimson, with no hint of scarlet, it was sickly beyond belief in Laura Ford - a pity because it was astoundingly healthy, floriferous and generally good in all ways except one.
    I probably spend far too much time thinking about colour - a paint chart or Pantone card actually makes me start to salivate....and I could never live in a white house (although I know my love of colours has caused several visitors to shudder).
    I fully agree that colours too close together but in the wrong tones can look disastrous (I did the same as you, Ann, with pinks) but a lot of the time in the garden, green proves to be a wonderfully ameliorating colour inbetween (but does nothing when roses are in full flow).
    At the moment, I am still deeply in love with purples and acid greens (especially with a bit of deep red and burnt orange thrown in the mix).
    I had 2 customers who both refused to have ANY yellow in their gardens and have seen a couple of all white gardens sabotaged by failing to differentiate between cool whites and warm whites.

  • 13 years ago

    I just painted a tuteur purple and put an acid green sweet-potato vine to grow upon it. I love it!

  • 13 years ago

    Wow, I bet that looks great under that Californian sunlight. I love your garden, Hoovb, even though I have only seen tantalising glimpses of it.

  • 13 years ago

    I love 'em all! The gaudier, the better, and I like seeing them all mixed together. Having said that, my garden is mostly pinks, soft yellows, whites, and lavenders. My little rose nursery that burned is back in business. Yay!!!! Everything is on Fort but the Drifts, which are own-root. I went there today and it was so hot, I sweated right through my clothes, and sweat was dripping off the end of my nose. The roses that caught my attention were the loud reds, oranges, and bright yellows, they were gorgeous, but what I bought was another Elina, a burgundy Iceberg, and another Belinda's Dream. Burgundy Iceberg does really well here, but not the white or pink. They're going to try to get me Weeping China Doll on a standard.

    There was one red floribunda I can't get out of my mind. I might have to go back and get it.

  • 13 years ago

    I think Jackie's picture is lovely because the yellow is a soft, light color. I've seen Graham Thomas in someone's garden and, frankly, it does not play well with others. I can imagine lavender and white with GH, but not too many other colors.

    Ingrid

  • 13 years ago

    I'd just dig them out camps :-) I don't seem to have the same issues with rose replant as you though. I dig an old one out, mix in loads of organic matter and plant with fungi and they seem to do just fine. I'm not a huge fan of pure pink with bright yellow, but have no problem with something like Jude the Obscure and Jubilee Celebration for instance.

  • 13 years ago

    I made a huge mistake planting Honeysuckle right next to Veilchenblau. Talk about clashing.

  • 13 years ago

    Nooooo, its SHADES of yellow and pink which...er stink.

    I am not going to get in trouble again, pleeeeease.

  • 13 years ago

    My youngest has shown me what 'macro' is and how to use it on my camera so.........the pink and yellow I do not care for.

  • 13 years ago

    and the rather nicer pinks and yellows also in my garden:

  • 13 years ago

    and then there are the almost pinks and the yellowish yellows - forgive the shaky hands......

  • 13 years ago

    a fave combo - although this is a case of looking through rose-coloured glasses and making the best of things because the lime lily leaves are terribly virus ridden so this will be their last season. Again, not a great picture.....

  • 13 years ago

    and finally, a jaw-dropping shade of blue, yes it really is this colour - a sweet pea from New Zealand - 'Blue Shift'

  • 13 years ago

    In everything else but roses, I hate pink.

  • 13 years ago

    Anita, you like it and I like it, therefore, it's pretty. Leave it be.

    Really nice combos, Camp.

  • 13 years ago

    Having now seen camp's GT and company, I think they look rather well together, to my surprise. Ditto cemetery rose's combination. Anita's yellow is really a soft apricot and that works. GT to me looks fine because there is lots of green surrounding it, its bloom size is different from the pink rose and there are many interesting textures that further unify the whole thing. The second, non-rose picture, I actually find less satisfying in the color combination, but that's strictly a matter of individual taste. Also, camp herself has said numerous times that her vision is not the best!

    Ingrid

  • 13 years ago

    Campanula, thank you for the photos! I absolutely love glimpses of other gardeners' design elements. Color is such an individual and central component. Your post inspires the idea that it would be great fun for me if everyone joined a thread and shared fav rose/perennial color combos. My craving to view color compositions is boundless. This forum prevents me from spending all my free time in the garden sections of second hand bookstores.

    Carol

  • 13 years ago

    Campanula, can you throw a shot of the deepest, darkest purple into the mix with a favorite clematis? (I know, a short lived solution) or maybe even get a tall dark flowering perennial in there?

    I see dark purple or the deepest burgundy breaking up that color combo and making it more palatable.

  • 13 years ago

    love that blue sweet pea!

  • 13 years ago

    Camps,

    Graft the rose of your choice on the Graham Thomas. If you want to keep the Graham Thomas but wish to place him elsewhere, propagate him first. Whether it works or not, It's better than being (passively) irritated.

    Cath

    P.S. I'm not overly in love with the combination either.

  • 13 years ago

    Blimey - what a great idea Cath - I actually have 2 of them so if it turns out a terrible fail, it won't matter.
    I 'made' a family tree while at college with 5 different apples on one stock (although ultimately, it was a bit of a disaster because they tended to have really differing growth habits and the tree looked terrible.....but as a practice thing, it was thrilling. Kim, are you about - is this the sort of thing that's up your alley - what do you think - can a 10 year old rose be treated as a rootstock and have a different scion budded? Cheers, Hoovb - can you grow them where you are? The breeder, Keith Hammet has also bred 'Erewhon' -a hybrid between L.odoratus and L.bellinensis whereby the colours are reversed - pale upper standards and a darker keel - awaiting the first bloom with almost as much anticipation as I have for a new rose.

  • 13 years ago

    I don't mind pink and yellow mingled...but I agree that it's more a question of shading. What really kills me is the combination of bright red and orange/yellow. It's like having my eyes put out with hot coals,and makes me think of McDonald's.

    Hoov, your 'Peace' is gorgeous! My Grandmother grew it (like everybody's grandmother) and I've been feeling sentimental about it lately. You might have enabled me.

    Campanula: I'd love to see more pictures of your Mme G. Staechelin. I've never seen that rose in person.

  • 13 years ago

    Camps,

    A perennial that should go with Graham Thomas is Asclepias tuberosa (Butterfly Weed). It is brilliant, brilliant orange, about 1-1.5' tall. It is native here and grows in waste places where the soil is barren of vegetation. It likes it sunny, hot and dry. Whether or not it would take Ingrid hot and dry, I don't know.

    Cath

  • 13 years ago

    Hi, Campanula.

    I took some liberties with your garden. I hope you will forgive the impertinence. I couldn't prevent myself from revisiting your photo and imagining the changes that Andreajp suggested. I was also struck by your bold chartreuse/purple lime lily combo. So, with a little help from Photoshop, I glued your roses on top of my stone path which is crowded with Geranium 'Ann Folkard,' variegated sage, and other fluff. Then I pasted in patches of my 'Tuscany Superb,' Hydrangea 'Harlequin,' and Achillea 'Moonshine.' It's very a rough sketch, but you get the idea. Fun or awful?

    Carol

  • 13 years ago

    For reference, here's my path.

  • 13 years ago

    And just so you and Anntn know you're not alone in suffering grating front and center arrangements, I'm attaching a photo of my entry garden. First, look at the image. Now, picture a healthy patch of Crocosmia 'Lucifer' surfacing in the middle of this bed. As I said, "Shudder!"

    Carol

    This post was edited by PortlandMysteryRose on Fri, Jun 14, 13 at 4:15

  • 13 years ago

    wow - so clever! I do have a couple of clems but they are later flowering - one is Prince Charles, I think, and the other is rooguchi (sp?), both of which go into the purple ranges. I love that psilostemon geranium - one of my favourites, although I don't have Ann Folkard with the lighter leaves. Have you seen Salome? A much smaller, neater dark-eyed geranium. With the alchemilla, it is just so classic - I have the weedy but lovely toadflax seeding around...and alongside a huge euphorbia (I came very late to those with much resistance), the lime/purple.primrose yellow looks good to me in so many combos - even with greys and clouds. Even weirder, I have your phlox in the same position in my garden.
    I did attempt asclepia from seed but had a dismal time of itv - still have some seeds left though for another go-round.
    zjw - 'fraid I have a bit of a weakness for reds and golds....and with a bit of magenta thrown in, I am in gaudy heaven.
    Usually, Madame Gregoire is my earliest rose and is often almost over before GT wakes up but we are so late this year that there are still a couple of tulip stragglers.

  • 13 years ago

    Carol, I love what you've done with camp's "grating" color scheme, which I personally like. However, with your additions, which includes a bit of added yellow and greenish-yellow in the foreground, it all comes together (for me). I admit that camp's may not be the perfect combination, but GT is so beautiful in her garden that I would be loath to give it up, so fiddling around by adding other plants seems like a fun challenge.

    Carol, why haven't we seen more of your garden? Much more interesting plants than in my garden, which you're always so kind in praising. I have the feeling you have a bit more rain or better soil for everything to look so lovely.

    Ingrid

  • 13 years ago

    I think it is all a matter of proportion. If you added shades of creamier yellows and paler pinks, it might be more harmonious. Then the intense yellow and pinks would be more like an accents on a continuum than the stars of the show.

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:276076}}

  • 13 years ago

    I love all the pictures and colors. Thanks for the sweet pea name also.

    As you say, Camps, the MGS is usually gone by the time GT gets into his blooming stride, so the irritation is only momentary. I have the same kind of irritation when the leaves turn orange and a late blooming hot pink rose doesn't know it's time to go to sleep.

    Anita, I like that combination too!

  • 13 years ago

    Campanula
    I'm glad you got a kick out of my late night collage! Old garden designers never die, we just pester new victims. I, too, like reds and golds. I once toured a neighbor's home which had golden yellow walls and red accent walls and piles of embroidered textiles from all over Asia. It was incredibly bold and lush. Numerous windows in the contemporary design were open invitations for natural light. It was bright and colorful. Keep us posted on 'GT' grafting!

    Ingrid
    Thank you for the compliments! Actually--close your ears, Campanula--I like pink and yellow, too. Graham Thomas is a more challenging shade of yellow, but I've planted him next to soft pinks and enjoyed the effect. Purple companions make for a bold complementary color scheme. At my last house, I just plunked him in a circular bed and grew him as a large, arching specimen with Lavandula stoechas fluffed at his feet. No color competition. Yes, I definitely get more rain, but your garden more closely resembles the south of France! It must be like a travelling to Europe with a cup of morning coffee in your hand.

    I love the diverses tastes and suggestions. Fun thread, Campanula!

    Carol

    This post was edited by PortlandMysteryRose on Fri, Jun 14, 13 at 16:45

  • 13 years ago

    This is bad. I wince at this every year, but the plants are all so large and healthy, I never do anything about it. With 'Fourth Of July' blooming behind it all, it's even worse. Maybe if I just switched the Hemerocallis for a purple one it wouldn't be so bad.

    {{gwi:276078}}

  • 13 years ago

    The daylily would be the easiest to move, so I'd probably go with your idea for putting in a purple daylily there. That might work very nicely.

    Kate

  • 13 years ago

    Hoovb I was just bemoaning a similar color combo. Only the lavender/silver color was the roses (Neptune and Blue Girl) I am looking forward to seeing how the bed changes as you swap out plants. I have a bunch of bearded Iris that only bloom once but tie the colors together. I think I need to find something that blooms more often and am going to fill a hole or two with something white.

  • 13 years ago

    hoov, alternatively you could move the red rose, which may get a bit crowded as it grows more. I think the daylilies are far enough from the climber to not grate. The hydrangea (?) by the way, is simply gorgeous.

    Carol, GT with lavender planted around him is an inspired scheme. I do like complimentary color schemes very much. They're exciting and yet not "in your face". My bete noire is bright roses that are next to each other on the color wheel, such as red and orange, being grown together, especially with no cool-colored companion plants to separate them.

    As you said, it's been fun to hear different opinions. In the past there have been strident voices on this forum that seemed to enjoy turning everything into a confrontation, but thankfully they've moved on, and we now seem blessed with many interesting and articulate members (such as you!) who enjoy discussing everything to do with roses and gardening without desiring to create conflict. It's been very enjoyable here lately.

    Ingrid

  • 13 years ago

    Well, I'm going to display my bad taste and love of color contrast, but I think that's beautiful, Hoov.

  • 13 years ago

    Graham Thomas has a difficult colour, I moved mine three times because I couldn't fit it in anywhere and the third time it died. That was early in my gardening life but now I am sure I could find a place for it in my hot border. It's almost exactly the same brash and brassy yellow as my old daylilies and they would look good together muted by some browns and russets.

  • 13 years ago

    Oooo, Ingrid. I know what you mean about the red/orange rose combo. I try to avoid that situation, too. I do like red and apricot.

    Hoovb, I'd dump something acid under my hydrangea and turn it blue. Then you'd have primary colors--red, blue, and yellow. You could start the procedure in the fall and water well. Continue into spring. The acidifier has to reach the hydrangeas system pre-bloom. Do you like red, blue, and yellow?

    I'd love to see your garden, Floridarosez! I have sections in mine that may resemble yours. Red, purple, yellow, pink,.... It makes me happy. Like birthday party.

    Carol

  • 13 years ago

    Thought of bluing up that 'Ayesha' Hydrangea, yes, I'll do that and also switch out the gold Hem for a purple one. Thanks. That should work better. I did hit that Hydrangea with soil sulphur a couple of times, but it needs more than I gave it obviously.

    Thanks floridaroze, it looks nice in that the plants are all healthy. In person the color combo is somewhat jarring. It actually looks better in the photo.

  • 13 years ago

    Hoovb,

    Isn't that a purple Hemerocallis in the bottom left of your photo? If so, cover the yellow Hemerocallis with your hand. What do you think? Do you like it?

    Cath

  • 13 years ago

    Camps,

    You could, as an alternative, lightly trim your Graham Thomas, once it has fully leafed out, to delay bloom and ensure that the Madame and Mr. Thomas do not bloom simultaneously.

    Cath

  • 13 years ago

    yes Cath, that's a little purple hem, it does look better. there I go, another project for myself. :)

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals