Software
Houzz Logo Print
rosecorgis

Unhappy bands. Need advice.

17 years ago

I have four bands growing now and two are definitely unhappy. All four have graduated to 1 gal pots --Grandmother's Hat, a mystery band (supposed to be Pretty Jessica, but it's not), Rubens and Archduke Charles. The mystery band and Rubens are both growing and doing fine. The Grandmother's Hat wasn't doing anything -- no new leaves since it first put on leaves this spring. They also looked like they had iron deficiency, so I added some Ironite (diluted). This morning I noticed it lost two 5 leaf sets. I'm pretty worried since it doesn't have too many to start with. The other unhappy child is Archduke Charles. I bought him at the Sacramento Cemetary Sale from the nicest guy who told me all about his and was so exicited that I dropped it! It seemed to recover when I put it back in it's pot and I took it home. At first it was fine, actually made a little bloom, but since then got mildew in the rain and has lost most of it's leaves. I sprayed it with an antifungal spray but it's a sorry little thing.

On the bright side, Rubens has new leaves every time I look at it and the little mystery rose put out a basal break and a bud. Maybe then I'll know what it is -- has mini leaves so it's probably a mini of some kind.

Any advice for my unhappy campers? I really want both Grandmothers Hat and Archduke Charles. We have had strangely cool, foggy weather lately but it should start the summer warmup on Wednesday. I'm hoping that helps considerably.

Thanks.

Debbie

Comments (21)

  • 17 years ago

    That odd spring weather is hanging in down in southern California, as well.

    I would avoid any sort of feeding of these poor baby roses, but place them in FILTERED light. Not direct sun, y'know?
    Check to see that the drainage holes in the pots are not blocked. Keep them watered, but you do want to see the soil start to dry before you water. (Don't keep them constantly soaked.)

    Both are strong-growing cultivars, so they SHOULD be busy growing roots, rather than top-growth.
    As long as the canes are green, they're hanging in.

    Jeri

  • 17 years ago

    We all know that different rose varieties vary radically in their adaptability to what is a broad universe of differing growing conditions.

    The suppliers of bands grow their product under highly artificial conditions. Some varieties adapt quickly to the 'real world' they happen to land in, many don't.

    Upon receipt of a band, the most important thing to do, in my opinion, is to assess root development. I've been astonished time and again by the pathetic root systems on plants that even the more respected suppliers are willing to pawn-off on their customers. It's essential to realize that the vast majority of bands are grown under greenhouse conditions and are potted-up in their shipping containers only hours -- if not moments -- before they begin making their way to our doorsteps.

    I've always been humbled by the number of posters here who report that they receive bands, plant them immediately in their permanent gardens locations, and then blithely watch them grow into magnificent specimens. Experience tells me that I shall never have such luck.

  • 17 years ago

    I don't have experience with how other growers do it, but I do know that Vintage's bands are only in the greenhouse as cuttings to help them get rooted. Once they've successfully rooted, they're taken outdoors and grown on to salable size, and they are not potted up moments or hours before shipping.

    --Ron

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for all the advice. I'll move them to filtered sun, water and leave them alone. Our weather is due to heat up starting today, so that should clear up the mildew we've had. Thanks for the filtered sun warning - I don't want to burn them up when the heat really hits!

    I was looking at Grandmother's Hat yesterday. I think it has rust, which is the first time I've ever had it. The rose leaves look dirty, sort of rusty and sort of brown, but it isn't dirt. Unless I should take action now, I'm going to let them be and water when drying out.

    Thanks again. I think my main problem is that I want to DO SOMETHING to help, and end up doing too much!

    Debbie

  • 17 years ago

    Debbie, if you have rust, it's not a "dirty" look.
    It is bright orange stuff on the UNDERSIDE of the leaf.

    Jeri

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks Jeri. Then it isn't rust because it certainly isn't orange and it's on both the top and bottoms of the leaves. It really looks like the leaves are dirty but it doesn't rub off like dirt.

    I'll have to try to take a picture and post it, but I don't know how to post pictures here. Are there instructions anywhere?

    Debbie

  • 17 years ago

    rosecorgi,

    I bought bands at the Sac Cemetery Sale. My Archduke Charles is a tiny little thing. It just started putting on some new growth. I almost bought Rubens - It is good to hear that it is a hardy healthy rose.(maybe next year).
    All of the bands from this sale were re-potted and are concentrated on root growth, not much in the bloom department. I plan on planting them in the fall.
    One of the bands has had constant powdery mildew and has just produced some new leaves for the first time. That is the Plymouth #5 rose. It was my one mystery buy.
    All of them are in filtered sun - 3-4 hrs of direct morning light. I am thinking I need to put them in a more sunny spot.
    How much sun does your bands get?

  • 17 years ago

    Debbie, the way to post pix here is to use Photobucket.
    (See link below.)
    Once you get set up with it, we can tell you how to post pix.

    Daun -- You bought BANDS at the Sacramento Cemetery sale?
    Weren't they in 1-G?
    I am myself tempted by Rubens.
    And just to make you feel a little better, "Pulich Children" is sitting out in the pot ghetto rusting a bit.
    I don't worry about a little fungus when they're teeny babies like that.

    Jeri

    Here is a link that might be useful: Photobucket

  • 17 years ago

    Jeri,

    I did get Coulterville Red - Awesome rose, new growth and vigorous
    Forest Ranch Pom-Pom- Band
    Maman Cochet - Band
    Baron Prevost - Gallon - Already planted and a happy camper.
    I know once they put on some growth and are in permanent homes most of the issues I have will go away.
    It is all a matter of waiting and giving them time to do their thing...

  • 17 years ago

    Oh boy, I wish I lived where you did, I would have that Coulterville Red in a heartbeat.

    Jeri

  • 17 years ago

    Jeri, you didn't get Rubens? I was so excited to meet you at Sac Cemetary that I introduced myself and asked you what I should buy. I especially wanted your recommendation. You turned around, smiled a big grin and pointed at Rubens, which was overwhelmingly spectacular. You were standing right in front of it. I grabbed the tallest one right then! You should have bought one. It's pretty happy at my house. I think of you when I water the Rubens and Grandmother's Hat (also your recommendation on the forum).

    Daun, mine get about 5 hours sun from around 10am to 3pm. I put them in a place where they are protected from the corgi madhouse in my backyard (never underestimate a corgi 3 ring circus) and where they won't get the full brunt of Livermore afternoon sun. So far this June has been gray, but it will heat up and then I may move them to a more filtered spot. I'll have to watch. I have other pots on the patio and water every morning once the heat really hits. July and August are commonly 90 degrees and dry as a bone with days here and there at 100. I bought teas because I heard they like heat.

    I wouldn't worry so much about my little Archduke Charles if he didn't keep dropping leaves. He still has some, but not too many.

    One question I forgot to ask -- do you mulch your pots? I put about an inch of bark chips on the top of mine to save water and protect from the heat. Is that right or should I use something else?

    Thanks for the help.

    Debbie

  • 17 years ago

    I also have a Corgi - I have all of my pots on a potting bench so she cant get to them. She loves to eat labels and chew on the plants. I call her the destroyer!

    No, I do not have any mulch on them. My problem with pots is providing enough drainage. You should check the drainage on your Archduke Charles. If you have healthy white roots your good, if they are yellow and have a stink, they are drowning. The loss of leaves might be from overwatering.

  • 17 years ago

    Debbie, it was interesting hearing about how your little band roses are doing. I hope they all four make it.
    I received bands for the first time this spring, so it's a new experience for me.
    I've had varying results so far, but they all are doing pretty well.

    'White Pearl in Red Dragon's Mouth' - hanging in there, growing a little, have had several blooms and buds. But he's still not completely happy yet, still getting acclimated to the new surroundings, etc. It'll be fine.

    'Marie Pavie' - new growth coming out from the get-go. Lots of blooms that last a nano-second & then are gone. Has been blackspot prone so far, but certainly doesn't slow the plant down. Excellent fragrance eminating from it.

    'Pretty Jessica' - doing well. Not much new growth, but still looks happy and perky. My older PJ was received last year as a larger 1-gallon, so was quicker to put forth growth. But PJ as a tiny band is holding its own.

    'Comtesse du Cayla' - IMPRESSIVE plant, even as a band. Strong growth, nice buds, & beautiful new leaves. This rose appears to absolutely love it here. Have had one, large bloom (for a band). It was beautiful. Yes, the bloom fried in the hot afternoon sun, but sure was fine in the AM and was memorable.

    Randy

  • 17 years ago

    Randy, do you know, I have tried three times to grow Comtesse du Cayla.
    It will not grow here.
    :-(

    Jeri

  • 17 years ago

    Jeri, I guess the comtesse must enjoy a brutal climate, because the hotter it gets, the happier that rose gets :-)

    Randy

  • 17 years ago

    Well, there's good news and bad news. The good news is that Grandmother's Hat has very tiny new growth showing in multiple places,which is very encouraging. The bad news is poor Archduke Charles. The few remaining leaves looked very crisp and dead. As it turns out, the whole top of the plant is dead and broke off. Now the Archduke is a 3 inch tall green twig. The twig is alive (I scratched it and it was a healthy green underneath) so I guess I keep taking care of the twig and hope for a basal break!!

    Daun, glad to hear you have a corgi too. I'll just tell you that where one is wonderful and two is fun, three is bedlam! Mine don't eat plants unless I fertilize with something yummy like manure, but the boys charge around the yard at light speed and whack into things. I like your potting bench idea. I'm probably the only person on the forum who likes thorns -- thorns = corgi respect!

    Randy, glad you joined in on the thread since you've been quite the enabler for me. I have my mismarked mystery rose as an attempt to get Pretty Jessica (another's on order), Valentine and a just ordered Reine des Violettes. I figure if it can survive your Dallas summers it can handle my Livermore summers. Your suggestions of must haves are always welcome.

    Debbie

  • 17 years ago

    Jeri, I guess the comtesse must enjoy a brutal climate, because the hotter it gets, the happier that rose gets :-)

    *** Well, that would certainly explain why she is so unhappy here in "my-feet-are-cold-in-july-land." :-)

    Jeri

  • 17 years ago

    Debbie, don't give up on Archduke Charles. I have an area of my yard I call the ICU. It's my back porch and only gets morning sun until about 12:30.

    This Spring, I dug up a Dr Grill which was mostly dead, repotted it, and stuck it in the ICU. I talked to it daily, watered it faithfully, and don't you know? It came roaring back about four weeks later.

    Your little twig might need some extra time to grow more roots.

    Elaine

  • 17 years ago

    Oh, dear, I hope that Archduke Charles recovers, Daun! Most likely, it's from my plant that I propagated from my friend Vivian's childhood home. It was built in the late 1850s, burned in the 1960s, but there are still a few old roses there that we believe were planted in Victorian times. I have both Archduke Charles and Cels Multiflora from that old garden,and they are remarkably vigorous.

    I'm going to go against most advice here. I'd fertilize it with half-strength liquid fertilizer every other week, and see if you can nudge some new growth. Be sure the pot is watered before you add the fertilizer.

    I could have sworn that we had nothing but one-gallon and bigger roses for sale at the cemetery this year.

    I keep my new roses along my driveway, where they get at least half a day of strong sun. I think that sun and air circulation are essential to growth and disease reduction. In Sacramento, where it's usually so darned hot, I worry about cooking the roots in black nursery pots. I have some long plastic planters, and put four one-gallons in each, with some mulch at the bottom and around the pots, to keep them cooler. I also mulch the top of all of my babies. I fertilize them all, twice a month. Daily watering can lead to quite a wet zone in the bottom few inches of the pot, although setting them on the mulch acts as a wick (roots often grow through).

    Elaine, we have one very gifted propagator among our volunteers who is wonderful at nursing plants back to life. We call her yard the "neonatal nursery!"

    We had a lot of problem with mildew and rust this year. Jeri, the rust is on the bottom AND top of the leaves. Yuck. We think it's due to the cool weather.

    And a word about Comtesse du Cayla - mine at home is much bigger than the Perle d'Or that I planted next to it at the same time. It is huge, and does indeed respond to heat. Blooms in the spring and fall hold up, but the flowers crisp up in the summer sun. The one in the cemetery is in a low spot that tends to flood when we water it once a week. Its flowers hold up better than mine at home, where I water sparingly. I'm not willing to give it more water, so am thinking about replacing it.
    Anita

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the encouragement and advice, Anita. I hope it was one of yours! It was a gallon when I bought it, but the very first thing I did in my excitement was drop it, so it didn't get the best start. That broke some roots off right there. I won't give up on it and I'll find a good place to baby it and hope. I checked the roots, they're white and not rotten, so we just need to let it recover and pray. I also liked your suggestion about the gallon pots in a planter box. How big is your planter box? I just mulched my entire front yard and have one wheelbarrow full left over - this would be a good use of it. When I potted mine up I put them in the blue pots that my Endless Summer Hydrangeas came in, a feeble attempt to avoid the black pots in summer sun.

    Debbie

  • 17 years ago

    Anita,

    Yes, you had them in one gallon pots. Archduke Charles was a tiny little thing in the pot. All of the roses from the sale are in larger pots.Each one is now putting on some new leaves. We have had such a strange weather pattern this spring. This weekend is supposed to be down in the 60s again.

    The stars of the bunch are Coulterville Red and Dr. Kelly. The plan is to plant this fall. I am using the Miracle Grow Continuous release.
    Your propagators did a great job this year on the volume and quality of roses for the rose sale!

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals