Software
Houzz Logo Print
scotjute

Eastern Trees Growing Out West?

19 years ago

Have seen some topics concerning growing western trees back east, but have never seen the opposite. So for those that have seen them or grown them, what eastern trees have you seen planted out west? And where and what elevation?

Last month in valley of California I saw quite a few sweet-gum trees planted in the city of Visalia, and doing fine. Elevation was around 2,000'. Probably 30-40' hgt. Couldn't imagine anyone carting those things across country to plant, but there they were! Expected to see possibly oaks, pines, bald cypress, etc. from back east growing out there, but recognized nothing but sweet gum.

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    The west is a big place, and there are a fair number of eastern trees planted in one place or another. Red gum is the major one in low-elevation California, for its fall color and architectural form. Red maple works well in much of northern California. Black walnut does well in the northwest; pin oak too. Black locust and honeylocust are good in the Rockies and in California. I'm sure others will lengthen this list.

  • 19 years ago

    Especially in the mild PNW, pretty much any type of tree grown on the east coast is grown here. And they are not "carted across the country" but grown by some of the dozens (perhaps hundreds) of wholesale growers and tree vendors located in this area. In fact, it may be a good bet that many east coast trees have been grown west of the Rockies and transported back in that direction :-) Sweet gums, various oaks, redbud, eastern dogwood, elms, chestnuts, Pennyslvania ash, Magnolia grandiflora, and a huge range of maples are all very commonly grown in this area. Except for some warmer climate (zone 9+), semi-tropical or very arid selections, if it grows anywhere in the US, it can and often is, grown in the PNW.

    But not all perform as well in this climate. Cercis canadensis tends to be rather short lived in many western gardens and Cornus florida is plagued by anthracnose, as is our native dogwood. For some reason, sweet gums are frequently planted as street trees locally - a very inappropriate choice IMO, as they are butchered regularly to fit under power lines and have an amazing ability to lift sidewalks after only a couple of years.

  • 19 years ago

    "In fact, it may be a good bet that many east coast trees have been grown west of the Rockies and transported back in that direction :-)"

    That may be a good thing for the WA & OR economies, but it is a very bad thing for the species concerned - all the local and regional diversity within the species is being lost, with single origins being planted throughout the area.

    Resin

  • 19 years ago

    Yes: Named, clonal cultivars are commonly used. However, seedlings also continue to be raised and sold as well.

  • 19 years ago

    "However, seedlings also continue to be raised and sold as well"

    But do they take care to send Ohio-origin Red Maple seedlings to Ohio addresses, Delaware-origin Red Maple seedlings to Delaware addresses, Alabama-origin Red Maple seedlings to Alabama, etc., etc. . . I don't think so!!

    Resin

  • 19 years ago

    Some shoppers interested in natives do ask for local-origin stock, there is awareness of the issue.

  • 19 years ago

    Many national "champions" of eastern species now occur in Oregon and WA state.

  • 19 years ago

    Lots of true facts posted here already though I think the OP was talking about the species of trees in general such as where stuff is shipped. It all may originate in OR and shipped out to tree farms but for example does sugar maple grow in L.A.? What about E. White pine?
    I know S. Ca has quite a bit of sweetgums and sycamores but I don't know about other popular species like cherries and birches and pines and things like that. Does anybody know?

  • 19 years ago

    "But do they take care to send Ohio-origin Red Maple seedlings to Ohio addresses, Delaware-origin Red Maple seedlings to Delaware addresses, Alabama-origin Red Maple seedlings to Alabama, etc., etc. . . I don't think so!!"

    Resin,
    You are correct, they do not. But they are very aware of their seed origin and concentrate more on getting seed from Northern extremes versus Southern extremes in N.America. Not the best, but has been working well for the past decades in the nursery trade here. Native and forestry nurseries VERY specific on seed origin:-)...........

  • 19 years ago

    Yes, the Pacific Northwest is an area that is incredibly rich in horticultural diversity, represented by a large and vibrant nursery industry.

    As is Tennessee. As is Michigan.

    Specifically, there are a number of different types of nurseries. If your primary purpose are those objectives aligned with horticulture, you are selecting a tree from a source grown for different purposes than those with objectives aligned with conservation.

    Nurseries, especially wholesale nurseries are incredibly specialized businesses requiring considerable overhead to produce their product. Expecting a nursery to be a small, localized business in an increasing global world is stupid beyond calculation.

    In any given locality, individual nurseries are THE BEST source of information as to what grows there, how it does, and in what conditions it best there. As such, local retail nurseies tend to take great care in selecting where their merchandise comes from (as opposed to large box store outlets).

    As we develop increasingly detailed stragems as to what constitutes a native plant, we may find the ability of a nursery to sell a plant native to a different part of the country severely limited. Improperly so, if the truth be known.

    Yes, there are those plants that have created problems. Yet in our exceeding logical way of creating solutions, boiled down to make a three second sound clip, we'll gladly paint maackia, magnolia and rhododendron with the same brush as maple, ailanthus, and buckthorn.

    And somewhere we forget the fact that while some bemoan norway maple, we also have quaking aspen. While some rue siberian elm, we also have boxelder.

    If the only plants that are best adapted for a specific region are those that are native, by that argument, we would have no discussion about the problem of plants from other places.

    The history of our world is a history of change, of movement, of plants, of people, of ideas. Some have been good, some have been bad, some, a verdict has yet to be rendered.

    Personally, I think I'm gonna start recommending that you only plant those plants that come from a local nursery (as if that has a chance of succeeding in a box store world) and have a provenance of not greater than a fifty mile radius from the planting site.

    As a general matter of information, how many people on these forums a) know how many true grower operations there are with in a 50 mile radius, b) have travelled greater than 50 miles to visit a nursery and/or c) order from mail order nurseries across the country, much less with in a local area?

  • 19 years ago

    Well written Heptacodium. I often laugh at the fact of the quantity of Genus & cultivars grown in the PNW and shipped out of state...rarely to be seen in local landscapes (a lot of it is people do not want to pay the price to keep commercial operations in buisness....stick a small plant in the ground and it grows really well here...why pay for a larger plant???)
    I started in the plant buisness/love affair years ago in North Carolina, it was amazing 20+ years ago you really had to go to the west coast to get east coast natives(Fothergilla,Franklinia,Nyssa,Stewartia,etc.....drove me nuts!!!!) some things have changed and there are incredible nurseries on the east coast. But I do still see a lot of east coast plants grown in the NW to be shipped back to where they are native or introduced. The demand is there for certain plants, thats why they are grown...I have a in-grown dislike for Liquidamber because of where I was raised....but still a beautiful tree in the right spot..........