Software
Houzz Logo Print
jacqueline9ca

Does anyone grow Birdie Blye?

15 years ago

This rose is a 1904 Van Fleet multiflora hybrid. I bought it from Suzy Verrier in Maine the other day because she said it thrived in her coastal Maine garden (which I'm sure it does), and I was looking for a rose to give as a gift to my friend who lives near Kennebunkport. My friend has mostly rugosas in her garden near the beach, and of course they do wonderfully.

The other rose she has in her garden that is doing well is Knock Out! Is there nothing that rose can't do? Personally, I think everyone who loves roses should thank Heavens for Knock Out - the fact that that rose was hybridized by an amateur in his garden, and filled a need that had not been filled by all of the fancy, "several generations of rose hybridizing" established companies around the world is amazing. It seems to have finally got the professionals to start seriously trying breed disease free roses, instead of merely having that as a "nice to have", now it is a "got to have". About time!

Anyway, to get back to Birdie Blye - I am just curious. HMF says it is a climber, but it also says it only gets 4-5 feet tall. What kind of climber is that (this is not a mini)? Just wondering how it grows for you, if you grow it.

Jackie

Comments (6)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jackie, we had it at Limberlost many years ago. If given support in a long growing season, it can be used as a climber, easily twice the reported size. If pruned hard and left to be self supporting, you can keep it five to seven feet as a shrub. Length of growing season and heat will help determine the eventual size, as it will with everything. Birdie will make a nice hedge/screen plant. It had a larger spring flush, with light scattered repeat later. It was healthy there, but always impressed me as a whole lot of plant for so little bloom. I liked it, but it would require a lot larger space than I could ever give it due to its size and quantity of bloom. I'd think it would be much better in a shorter season area with harsher winters where its qualities would be more necessary. Kim

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks, Kim - your description makes sense with what Suzy said it did in coastal Maine - she said it was a blooming machine, and survived the harsh winters fine. Of course, the growing season there is very short, and a large Spring flush might almost carry you through it, especially if it didn't start until late June!

    Jackie

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Jackie, I think you'll enjoy it. When it flowered, it was quite pretty, and if I recall correctly, had fragrance. I've usually found Van Fleet roses interesting, with a few exceptions. Kim

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I saw this thread and had to weigh in - I LOVE Birdie Blye! I am in zone 6 NJ. For me she is a real bloom machine. Maybe she needs some cold to rebloom well? (I notice Kim is in SoCal.) Also a very healthy rose. For me, she stays pretty much shrub size - maybe 3.5/4 ft tall, 3 ft wide. In this climate, I don't think she'd climb. Anyway, I have always wondered why she isn't more popular, but maybe its because she's not so good in warmer zones.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Frances, thanks so much for your info! That is what I was hoping - my BB got planted in Maine in a zone 6 garden about 200 feet from the ocean. I was hoping that it would stay just about the size you describe.

    Sounds like this rose is a good example of something that has always bothered me - it is only on places like GW and the HRG and HRF that you are told that not all good roses are good for everywhere, and that there are roses, and classes of roses that gardeners in (fill in the blank....hot....., cold........humid.......) climates should not try to grow. Also not told (I mean by the ARS, most plant catalogues, etc) that there are some roses that are FANTASTIC for certain specific types of climates, that might be just ordinary or unsuccessful elsewhere.

    There seems to be some myth that a good rose has to be good "in all 50 states" - what a stupid idea! I realize that 100 years ago the large commercial nurseries thought they had to market a rose to everybody, but it seems to me that now that we have "target marketing" for everything else, why not roses? Why do all new roses have to be "cold hardy", for instance? The human population of areas, even in the US, that are heat zone 7 or higher is HUGE (think all of CA, most of the SouthWest, most of the rest of the West Coast, all of the South, etc. etc.)! Add in Australia, South Africa, all of Southern Europe, and Asia, and isn't this a big enough market?

    I know that, mostly because it is so obviously needed, roses have been developed for really cold climates, and that there are amazing folks in India developing roses for warm climates. However, these efforts seem to be by just a few isolated people. What about the rose "industry"? When the new HTs and floribundas come out every year, my local ARS association goes crazy and pulls out 30% of the roses from their very nice display garden, and puts in the newest, latest ones, without even mentioning (or apparently thinking about) these issues.

    End of rant -

    Jackie