Software
Houzz Logo Print
donn_

Question for the experts:

20 years ago

I'm just about finished using a 5' cube bin of finished compost. The ingredients were nothing other than sawdust and shredded leaves for browns, and grass clippings and shredded Eelgrass for greens.

Why is the compost high in sand content? My guess is a ratio of 1/3 sand and 2/3 composted organic matter.

Where did the sand come from? My soil is very high in sand content, but only the grass and some of the dried leaves were grown on that soil. The Eelgrass comes from the bay, and the sawdust comes from a woodshop.

Don't get me wrong. I love the sandy compost, because it drains extremely well. I just wonder how it got into the compost.

Comments (15)

  • 20 years ago

    Some sand always comes up along with eelgrass - that's the only source I can think of - but 1/3 is a lot of sand.
    I'm curious what you mean by 'shredded' green eelgrass. The eelgrass we find shredded is either old stuff stewing at the tide line or the old stuff up from the beach.

    Eelgrass seems different from other plants. My wife and I have an ongoing debate about which breaks down more quickly, green eelgrass or dried?

  • 20 years ago

    Whole Eelgrass takes forever to break down, particularly when used in mats, as mulch. I've had some on a Snow Pea bed for almost three years now, and it's still going strong.

    I use my chipper/shredder to shred it, both fresh from the bay, and dried on my boardwalk. The green stuff goes into compost bins, and the dried stuff goes straight onto beds. When it's been shredded, it breaks down pretty quickly.

    To shred it green, I take the screen off the chipper/shredder, and run it through twice. Otherwise, it clogs the works.

  • 20 years ago

    If you sucked up those leaves with a mower, or used OPL- sand may have been sucked up with it.

    I dunno about eel grass.

  • 20 years ago

    The thought of polluting the air to get the eelgrass broken down faster dismays and disheartens me. This forum frequently dismays and disheartens me.

    Dry eelgrass takes about a year to break down in our compost piles. If we want quicker compost we don't use it in those piles.

    We take advantage of its durability by using it where we want a long-lasting mulch, for instance between the asparagus rows. I'm surprised though (again) that yours lasts three years, esp. in your zone, assuming you get a fair bit of rain. But in this case three years is a good thing, right?

  • 20 years ago

    This is one harvest of Eelgrass, 2-3 cubic yards.

    {{gwi:27088}}

    It took me about an hour to scoop it out of the canal, spread it on the boardwalk, and rinse it. No fuel was burned to get it to this point.

    I can run this thru the chipper/shredder twice, in about 30 minutes, and use less than a pint of fuel. I use it in my compost because of the micro-nutrients and minerals it contains. I figure the good it does my plants more than makes up for the fossil fuel I burn creating it. Healthy plants clean the air.

  • 20 years ago

    Eelgrass is a mainstay in our garden/compost so I find this subject interesting donn.

    About shredding: one person, one pint of fuel, a few times a year, multiplied by thousands of other people doing the same - it adds up...I don't see what the rush is.

    Another question: is the eelgrass choking the canals you get it from? Is there some benefit to taking it green? Taking green eelgrass means harvesting an ecosystem, while collecting the dead stuff that's washed up means moving decomposing OM from one place to another. Same with seaweed - we wouldn't haul living stuff out of the water.

    "Eelgrass forms underwater meadows where young fish can hide from predators and find a wealth of food to eat.

    "The enormous surface area provided by these plants also acts as a highly efficient biological filter that removes harmful pollutants from the water, helping to protect fish health. Whether we live along the coast or inland, we all depend on eelgrass meadows to produce many of the marine fish that we use for food"

    There have been times in the past when there were disastrous and mysterious die-offs of eelgrass.

  • 20 years ago

    "About shredding: one person, one pint of fuel, a few times a year, multiplied by thousands of other people doing the same - it adds up...I don't see what the rush is."

    If there are thousands of other people shredding Eelgrass, I'll start eating it. You aren't required to understand the rush, as it's my composting operation, not yours.

    The Eelgrass I harvest is floating, having been cut free by powerboat activities in the bay. When the wind is from the SW, as it generally is, great masses of it are blown into the canal, and as I am at the inland end of the canal, it definately clogs the canal, until the wind direction shifts. My backyard is directly on the canal, so, in essence, the dying Eelgrass is being delivered to my door. I simply use it. It washes up in other places, but I'd have to drive either my truck or one of my boats to get it. I'll keep on taking it from the canal.

  • 20 years ago

    Well you are lucky, having that bounty right on your doorstep. We get truckloads of eelgrass from a harbour beach a couple of miles from here, but only when we need to visit the nearby post office as well - combining trips.

    I meant shredding in general - the practice is becoming rampant, going by posts on this forum. I think excessive fossil fuel consumption is everybody's business, and will explain why in a thread one of these days.

  • 20 years ago

    That's some nice OM floating towards your door. I'm sure you got some mighty
    happy plants. I wonder how many pints of fuel would be wasted if you had to
    call a landscaping company to deliver compost to your yard.:

  • 20 years ago

    I meant shredding in general - the practice is becoming rampant, going by posts on this forum. I think excessive fossil fuel consumption is everybody's business, and will explain why in a thread one of these days.

    If you base your judgement on "rampant" shredding on the postings on a compost forum, you get what you pay for. I'd bet fewer than 1 in 10,000 Americans shred organic material for their compost heaps.

    When you post your sermon on conserving fossil fuel, be sure to title it OFF TOPIC. That way, I'll be sure to miss it.

  • 20 years ago

    I'd bet not even 1 in 10,000 Americans compost anything. (and might not have ever even heard of compost).

    I live in a large subdivision. Huge. I only know of one other person who composts besides me. But they do spend a fortune on lawn services, landscapers, fertilizers. I believe I'm ahead of the pack.

    Karen

  • 20 years ago

    be sure to title it OFF TOPIC.

    Not a chance - I'll surprise you. :)
    Did you ever figure out where all that sand comes from?

    "fewer than 1 in 10,000 Americans shred organic material for their compost heaps"

    I doubt that the number has ever been ascertained but a survey of SCM forum members would give us a good idea, I would think. Or are we not typical composters?

    "But they do spend a fortune on lawn services, landscapers, fertilizers"

    Does buying a shredder put you ahead of the pack or behind it?

  • 20 years ago

    I've been composting for many years), but only bought a shredder a year or so ago. It's a small shredder and I only use it to shred tree branches.

    I doubt if we're a representative sample of Americans (especially since not all of us are Americans). Actually, I doubt if we're a very accurate sample of composters, either. I think the people who post here are a little more "hard core" in their approach to composting. The fact that we participate in a forum like this says something about us.

  • 20 years ago

    I don't own a shredder, never have. I do use an electric leaf vacuum/mulcher in the fall.

    And when I said that I only know one guy besides myself who composts around here? I have never seen anyone else mulch their planting beds with leaves, either. When I used the phrase "ahead of the pack" I meant composting at all. Same thing for mulching with leaves.

    Karen

  • 20 years ago

    Karen, by 'you' I meant 'one', wasn't making assumptions.
    I know what you mean; composting is a lonely endeavour around here too, though starting to pick up.

    An acquaintance called the other day asking my advice about the best time to use eelgrass as a mulch, which surprised and pleased me.
    (- wow - got back on topic through sheer coincidence!)

    bpgreen you're probably right. We're people who take composting one step further.