Software
Houzz Logo Print
frank_l

Intermittent pruning

17 years ago

What is the adviseability of pruning beyond deadheading between spring and fall. For example - removing bad or diseased canes, eliminating crisscrossing, reducing excessive bushiness, etc.? (I'm not sure how much of this question is due to the fact that I get frustrated looking at photos of plants with 2 or 3 canes, 5 to 10 leaves each, and blooms the size of soccer balls - while most of my plants are bushier with peanut size blooms. Admittedly it's 105 degrees in my garden.)

Comments (15)

  • 17 years ago

    Hi, Frank... I grew my first rose/first garden in March 2009 so I'll be interested to hear what everyone says about the actual pruning processes as well the timing of it.

    I don't have valuable advice, just passed on advice from others and my incredible luck with Gardenville sea tea saving my roses and creating full fat blossoms and bushy foliage. I always read that the strength is in the soil... I have very poor quality, heavy formerly poison-laden soil (one year of herbicides to clean out an empty, weed-infested lot) that I have not had the chance to amend yet; so I have to rely on "gentle" organic fertilizers to give my roses a boost... Someone once wrote that something in her lemon orchard was making her roses bloom like crazy...so I'm still awaiting her soil analysis.

    People use alfalfa tea and fish emulsion I hear, which really encourages basal breaks and blooming? My Gardenville tea has the fish emulsion, seaweed and compost tea (probably alfalfa compost) because I always get multiple basal breaks and the prolific blossoms... But then there are other good organic fertilizers such as Rosetone, Alaska Fish Emulsion, etc.and tons of experts do their own homemade recipes...

    Without these organics, I'm sure my roses would have been non-blooming duds...or dead for that matter. Problems I'm sure you would never have...

    Yes, I do think blooms can roast with the heat, but I find for me it's just a color change and form change (huge grapefruit/cabbage roses instead of classical hybrid tea form)and dramatic shifts in the colors. But in Kansas we only get 97 degree heat, not! 105 degrees...and I think it only sometimes gets to 103 at the very maximum (or at least I hope! for this year). And our heat occasionally will plummet to a pleasant 80 degrees when the rains come unlike Arizona summers.

    The best thing is for a fellow Arizona rosie person to help you to isolate the issue...Is it the heat or is it the soil...In my situation, bushy foliage has never limited the amount and size of blooms... The other issue is, perhaps is it the age of the rose? Some hybrid teas can take longer to establish...Maybe you can tell us what roses you have?

  • 17 years ago

    Your blooms SHOULD be smaller in hot weather -- and if you're anwhere South of Flagstaff, you've got pretty hot weather right now.
    Shading them some in the hottest weather might help (but maybe you already do that).
    Exhibitors here in California commonly "summer prune," but if my garden was trying to survive 116-degree temperatures right now, I'd pump the water to the roses, lay off the fertilizers, and pray that they keep all that foliage until the weather cools down.

    Jeri

  • 17 years ago

    Good question! I had asked Paul Zimmerman of Ashdown Roses on YouTube about summer pruning. (They have wonderful videos about roses and care. But their wasn't one for mid rose season.) He said he would make a video. We ought to remind Paul. He did just make a few new ones so I don't know if he/they are ready to make more?

    I have been cutting dead canes and kind of shaping lightly. I didn't feel I had a choice because I didn't want the deadness :0) to get to the bud union. And spindly canes with drooping blooms on the ground I didn't think was good either, so I have trimmed those back when removing blooms.

    Frank, I am getting sick of looking at pics with blooms of any size! lol (My roses are mostly this last spring planted. So I believe patience is needed on my end.) A lot of people will think you are lucky having a bushy plant!

    Allison

  • 17 years ago

    My dark pink Queen Elizabeth is smaller but bushier than my deep red/black and my light pink. My Elizabeth's get as big as soccer balls -LOL, my reds are the most fragrant and also get rather large. My light pink gives me the most problems as it gets to be quite larger than my others and I get smaller branches growing off of the canes producing smaller roses (mini size) that are almost a pink white. 2 shades lighter than what it normally produces. While I prune in the Winter, I have just Googled, that regular pruning will not hurt it, which is what I did today. I pruned it lightly, only to encourage the regular size roses and not the laughable itty bitty ones that were barely blooming. Kinda like one's hair. If you cut it regularly it will look better from scalp to tip, than if it were not cut and cared for properly!

    Unfortunately living in an oceanic CA mild and windy climate, I tend to lose a cane or two when the wind speed reaches over 20 mph.

    Take Lavender for instance. If it is not pruned regularly it looks so ugly. I prune mine and get beautiful purple spikes!

  • 17 years ago

    I'm on the case! I just did some summer clean up on my roses at home and am working on the structure for a video of the same.

  • 17 years ago

    Admittedly it's 105 degrees in my garden.

    Perhaps winter is your growing season and summer is your dormant season...are you growing under shade cloth to reduce stress? I thought I read most AZ people do that...

  • 17 years ago

    Yay Paul!
    Much appreciated! How cool is that! (Our wheel was barely squeakin'!)

    Allison

  • 17 years ago

    You can remove bad wood at any time. Why not? Doesn't everybody do that?

    It's certain that reducing the leaf area reduces water loss, so I'd think summer pruning would be a good thing in Arizona. However, I have no experience there, just speculating.

  • 17 years ago

    In my limited experience, obviously most of the nurseries around here keep their potted plants under shade cloth, but most of the private gardens - and the big public ones - have them out in the open. I get afternoon shade from some trees. Growing Queen Elizabeth (best performer in growth and blooms), Pascali, Legend, Mr Lincoln, Intrigue, Honor, Chrysler Imperial, Daybreaker, Liebeszauber (worst performer), to name a few.

  • 17 years ago

    Video on summer clean up is done. I might do a follow up on some other summer tips but this one ended up focusing on a bush that had some pretty good die back in it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Summer Rose Cleanup Video

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks, Paul, love the music.

  • 17 years ago

    I prune constantly. My soil is good and the roses grow big. A rose such as Folklore will easily reach 10' if not pruned after each flush.

  • 17 years ago

    Frank, every exhibitor's garden I've seen in AZ provided some sort of shade, for summer in particular.
    They do that so that they can produce the biggest and best blooms.

    And, having just yesterday driven across Southern Arizona, I can tell you that if I was a rose, and had to stand out in that heat, I'd just up and die out of self-defense.

    :-)
    Jeri
    On the Road, now in West Texas

  • 17 years ago

    OK, I'll chime on pruning in an AZ summer. Removing a dead cane is neither beneficial nor a detriment. It's dead. Removing crossing canes or any live cane with foliage is a bad idea... even a dead leaf casts shade. Cutting into rose canes while it's over 100F puts additional stress on roses already trying to keep hydrated. While I have seen some roses pruned that lived, they were under shade structures at the time, including side and top curtains. The roses were being pruned back for house painters.

    Heat causes blooms to be smaller, scent nil, leaves turn yellow/brown and fall off. The winds just exacerbate the whole problem. Lay off fertilizers, increase water and keep the chemicals away from the bushes until mid-September or early October. A little organic rose food, like Mills Magic, Berridge, Dr Earth or Grow-Mor can be used but no more than a cup every six weeks or so until the temps go down.

    Frank, if you're in the Valley, the Phoenix Rose Society is having a meeting this Tuesday night at the Valley Garden Center, between McDowell and Thomas Rd on 15th Ave. We love having visitors. Program topic is 'Water in the Desert Rose Garden'. Starts at 7:30pm.

  • 17 years ago

    Frank, if you want to grow roses, GO TO THAT MEETING.
    Join the Society -- Even if only for a year or two. You'll learn enough to make it worth your while.
    REALLY!

    Jeri
    On the Road in Abilene, TX