Software
Houzz Logo Print
shootingstar2_gw

J. Cartier/M. Boccella cold zone ?

19 years ago

A while back I posted a question about strange behaviour in KvD. The good folks here were kind enough to identify it properly as JC/MB.

That got me reading searching for info on JC. Unfortunately it seems like alot of places rate it at zone 5.

It is starting to look like I probably have a 25.00 annual and I'm pretty ticked. If it had to be a mis-label it would have been nice if it had been at least of the same class.

So back to the good folks here, anyone growing him in zone 3 ?

cathy

He will get protected well, but if it is too much of a stretch maybe I should think about digging him up and potting him.

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    That's not what you have. The buds on Jacques Cartier are extremely distinctive and unmistakable.

  • 19 years ago

    I won't weigh in on the JC/MB question because I don't have one at hand to compare your pictures to... but I will say that if your rose IS 'Marchesa Boccella' or a similar rose you shouldn't necessarily fret over winter hardiness. I have one in northern zone 4 that took a few years to stop mysteriously dying back to near the ground level, but I think that might have been a case of extreme sensitivity to canker brought on by even small amounts of winter protection. It no longer gets protected by anything but snow, and last winter it finally came through like a champ and has been blooming all year. In other words, your zone 3/4 plant should be fine even with some dieback - just let up on the mulch if you find it causes any problems for you (although I would probably mulch it well this first winter to get the roots settled properly).

    In the case of an OGR like this, it would be a rare instance where zone 5 is okay, but anything colder means death. Usually a large amount of dieback would be the worst you could expect from going out of zone, and that's assuming that the people who made up the zone designation had a good reason to do so. Normally it's the result of someone in zone 5 (for example) growing it and saying, "Gee, I can't imagine anyone colder getting this to grow - so let's call it a zone 5 rose." The problem is that a lot more people live in warmer zones and this is how myths get perpetuated - and hence a lot of plants start out in catalogs and books being rated to zone 7 or 8 on someone's edumacated guesstimate when they really survive just fine up north. The person to listen to is the one who has grown it and killed it (perhaps several times) and understands why it died!

    Stefan

  • 19 years ago

    I don't think it's JC/MB either.

    Here's a picture of JC/MB. Notice the sepals on this bud:

    {{gwi:302435}}

    Here is the picture of the bud from your original post:

    {{gwi:302436}}

    Notice the foliated sepals.

    But, on the other hand, whatever it is looks cold hardy to me. It has the look of a zone 4 rose; more so than JC/MB.

    So you got a beautiful rose whatever it is and if it makes it through the winter then you will have a real winner whatever the name.

  • 19 years ago

    Here is the "KvD not" rose commonly sold in Canada mislabeled as KvD by the giant Pan Am bulk rose supplier to mom and pop nurseries. They being doing it for years, though one year I actually saw it labeled correctly - on Dr. Huey.

    You will see the buds are the same as yours on the picture above if you look in the background. It is a very prolific bloomer in spring plus continues to put out the odd bloom throughout the season.

    The above "KvD not" has been growing in my garden for the last 3 years. It is a Portland that I have called "Jacques Cartier" because it's identical to the Pickering Jacques Cartier also growing in my garden. It has the same elongated leaves relative to more common portlands that tend to be more rounded and short and also the "cat tuffed" bud sepals.

    Knowing of Pan Am's mistake I sought out more of there "KvD not" to fill in my Portland bed. I protect it by covering and it is reliable so far through 3 winters - reaches about 1 to 1.5 feet in my garden. It's a good mistake except if you had your heart set on KvD.

    The Americans may have another version of Jacques Cartier the famous "finder and namer of Canada" from glorious France. However I am pretty sure Pan Am gets lots of it stock from the state side growers of huey rootstock roses.

    {{gwi:300838}}

  • 19 years ago

    Subtle differences in the flowers and foliage lead me to wonder whether this plant of Riku's "KvD not" is the elusive "true" 'Jacques Cartier', the short version, of which I've heard many rumors but never seen a plant. Maybe this is what Pickering sells, as well? My 'Marchesa Boccella' would certainly not content itself to remain at 1 to 1.5 feet in a growing season even after freezing to the ground (which it has proven on several occasions)!

    I must admit that I don't see a meaningful difference in the buds pictured above - both sets of sepals appear foliaceous to some degree, but the degree often varies widely from bud to bud and season to season anyway.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your thoughts and comments.

    Stefanb8
    I agree with your comments on how hardiness is determined in many cases. That coupled with HMF that seems so overly cautious vs the sellers that overrate the hardiness. I try to check half a dozen sources and settle on the middle of the range. That is one of the great things about this site is you can get first hand reports from people in similar conditions which I think is far more reliable.

    Where I am winter dieback is expected and not a problem, provided the plant is vigorous enough to put out a respectable show on re-growth. Of course the "blooms on old wood" thing has to be avoided.

    Palustris
    Thanks for the pics, the bloom seems paler and with perhaps less petals than mine but of course the camera, time of day and age of bloom can all affect how a photo looks. It does seem however that the leaves are far more glossy than the ones on my plant. I see what you mean about the sepals mine do seem quite different from yours.

    I would suspect that identification by photo only is going to be very difficult with these roses that appear to have been mislabeled for years in commerce. When you look at the HMF photo's of both KvD & JC/MB I would suspect that both roses are represented in each listing.

    Riku
    Thank you so much for your thoughts and photo. Your photo does closely resemble my plant. The leaves look very similar to mine except that on mine they seem smaller and perhaps a bit more oval. In the background of your photo, by the bud, there are smaller more oval leaves so I am hopeful. As far as stock supplied locally PanAm is very prevalant with a smattering of Select Roses as well. I will check when I get home from work as to the supplier of this plant but it would probably be one of them. Yikes! I did not realize they were importing &/or growing on Huey. I will try to curb those impulse buys and stick to the multiflora I get from Pickering.

    It's not that I had my heart set on KvD, but did have it set on starting an OGR collection. Placement will probably be an issue as I thought KvD was a fairly beasty Alba so I planted this fellow at the back of the bed right in front of the fence.....lol. Not a great place for a 1-1.5' tall rose.

    I found your reference to Northern Ontario interesting in the article you posted previously. On occasion I ship Persian's to my brother's in Edmonton, FtMac and Victoria. Let me know if you want some.

    Cathy