Software
Houzz Logo Print
centre82

Maple Tree Choice

15 years ago

Hello,

I recently had to remove two shade trees from my front yard. I need to replace them and will do so in the fall. I was originally going to go with a Red Sunset Maple but have heard that the Autumn Blaze Maple will grow faster so now I'm leaning that way.

I live in Northern Kentucky and was wondering if anyone had any experience with either of these trees or advice. I really want the shade as soon as possible.

Thanks.

Comments (19)

  • 15 years ago

    Autumn Blaze Maple is a silver-red hybrid maple. It gets its fast growing genetic from silver while retaining its red fall color from red maple.

  • 15 years ago

    I don't have experience with the Red Sunset Maple in particular, but I do have experience with a couple of other red maple varieties (October Glory, Burgundy Belle). I've also planted a couple of Autumn Blaze Maples.

    My experience is that while the Autumn Blaze Maples may grow a little faster, it's not guaranteed. Any of the standard red maple varieties will grow fairly quickly if watered correctly.

    That said, the Autumn Blaze did give me reliable blazing red color. I personally prefer the red maple varieties, but I'm not sure you'll go wrong with either.

    Sorry for the somewhat ambiguous answer.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the response. At this point I'm pretty set on the Autumn Blaze maple for a choice. Now I have to decide which caliper to go with.

    I am replacing two trees one of which was very large. I'm thinking of going with a bigger caliper tree (3 inch)there since the hole is alrady pretty big. I'm hoping with my large hole I can minimize some of the transplant shock. My other site doesn't have as much room for a big hole so I'm going with a smaller caliper (1.5 to 2 inches).

    Anyone have any ideas on what is the best size to plant in the fall and also which time is best, I'm thinking end of Sept/early Oct.

    Thanks.

  • 15 years ago

    I had 5 large 2.5" caliper AB maples planted when we first moved to our new house (before I knew a sweetgum leaf from a maple leaf) and they have grown very slowly, probably 1.5-2' on some branches each year. I believe this slow growth is directly linked to the the roots of such a large tree having to establish before top growth can proceed as expected. All I am saying is that if you go smaller, they will need less babying sooner, be healthier sooner, and might catch the larger caliper in a few years.

    I LOVE my AB maples though some here do not. They colored a pretty red last year for about 1.5 weeks and turned a vivid red/pink for 3 days before a frost got them. I also have 7 October Glory's that colored later than the AB and were also very pretty.

    John

  • 15 years ago

    We have a Autumn Blaze Maple and Autumn Fantasy Maple. Both are Red-Silver hybrids. Our neighbors have Autumn Flame and Red Sunset Maples, and there are October Glory nearby, and at my work. Our AB and AF are far outpacing the pure Red Maples in our area. That seems to be the case for most of the other AB planted in the area. Personally, I don't think you will go wrong with any of these choices, though I do suggest you look into Autumn Fantasy. It originates from a parent tree in your part of the country (Illinois or Indiana, can't remember which off the top of my head), and has proved to be snow and ice resistant. It also is a bit more open, and is more spreading than AB, and ours is growing faster than the AB. It has grown as much as 4'/year, and ours added 1.33" caliper to the trunk last year, so you can see they get with the growth program when conditions are good. Fall color is a long last DEEP blood red.

    For a fast growing tree, then you are better off going 1"-2" caliper at most. They simply make up the ground so fast, that after 5 years you would not be able to tell a meaningful difference. If your talking slow growing (i.e. 1'/yr), then bigger does make sense, as the small one will not catch the larger one during the establishment period. Just make sure that whatever you choose to come back here for planting help so that you get to keep your trees for a long time. Otherwise you could easily make very common planting errors, that either kill the trees in a year or sooner, or possibly in 5-10 years. And the trees mentioned are among the worst to have these problems due to their fast growth rate of shoots and roots.

    Arktrees

  • 15 years ago

    Larger caliper means longer recovery period. Best to go with a smaller caliper. Lots of discussion on this board why.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    Yeap I agree, I want quick shade cause you see, I got none. And if you haven't been keeping up, it's freaking god awful hot! 110 here last week equaling the all time high. 115 in Ft. Smith to the south setting an all time high, with 113 on either side of the 115 equaling the previous all time high. J0nd03 is really taking it on the chin down near Ft. Smith. And ABM/AFM lives 40-60 years like a silver maple, or the 100 like a Red Maple, or in between say 80 years, yeap not my problem, so what. Good chance the house will be torn down at some point anyway. White Oak, 100-150 years in a yard, same story, not my problem. They all will eventually hit the ground and be someone's problem. Be it in 40 years or 150. They all hit the ground eventually and will be someone's problem. Irrelevant. Plus, while I may love the White Oak, the next person in the house just may well hate it and cut it down anyway, and then nobody benefits from it. Not to mention if they don't like my tree selection, then don't buy the house. ABM is tougher than silver Maple, and AFM is tougher still than either. Lots of local ABM had relatively little ice storm damage in our worst ever ice storm on record in 2009, and the 15" heavy wet snow storm of 2010, an the 18-22" snowstorm of last Feb. I'm sure it can handle the run of the mill ice/snow storm. In fact many October Glory Maples that locally that had really nice size got distroyed by the 2009 ice storm, but then again almost everything did. I plant the trees I plant because they are what "I" want, and what I want to see, and not for some hypothetical idealized person who will thank me to their grave for some slow growing tree I planted 150 years before. As you can see if you look around, that almost never happens because nearly everyone wants the "new" house. And in case there is any confusion, Autumn Blaze Maple and Autumn Fantasy Maple are not one and the same tree, and have differing characteristics. Also in the interest of disclosure, I have Ginkgo, ABM, AFM, two Sugar Maples, Chalk Maple, Scarlet Oak, White Oak (in pots ready for planting), dogwood, Blackgum (can live to 400 years), Tulip Tree, and Redbud. In short a mix of longer and shorter lived trees. I will not pass judgement on those that need inexpensive and/or fast growing trees as long as they are not invasive, and they know what they are getting and what to expect.

  • 15 years ago

    I believe 'Sienna' is one of the better freeman maples out there. Their branching structure is superior to any others I've seen.

    I can't really knock 'Autumn Blaze' as a lawn tree, with the exception of their frost cracking issues.

  • 15 years ago

    I have found very differing opinions on the Autumn Blaze maples. There are some serious haters out there. I am trying to look at this as objectively as possible.

    My thinking is that if the tree is carefully selected, planted properly and cared for properly the Autumn Blaze Maple should be great in my yard as both a shade tree and something that looks good. I understand the concerns about the strength of the branches due to the fast growing nature of the tree, but it's not like every silver maple tree has died in ice storms or high winds. They survive all the time.

    I'm still going with an Autumn Blaze but am thinking about maybe going with a Red Sunset as well (I am planting two trees) only because there are enough people hating on the Autumn Blaze to make me a bit nervous.

  • 15 years ago

    Red Sunset does not color as well nor have a form as attractive as October Glory around here (in my yard).

    I'm glad whaas chimed in. I do have some pretty nasty frost cracks on my 3 of my trees. They MUST have their trunks wrapped in winter. I have learned my lesson believ. I didn't water e me. I can show you pics if you want.

    Ditto what Ark said. It's not like you are planting Paulownia or poplars. Not every tree must be a legacy tree. Plant something you can enjoy and watch grow in your lifetime. There are other trees a little better regarding having similar qualities to the AB. Ask Arktrees about his experience with quercus coccinea scarlet oak. IF I had to do it over again. I would have replaced 2-3 of the 5 AB maples with these. I also have no existing shade and still would have gone AB in the backyard for shade.

    John

  • 15 years ago

    Centre82,
    Get whatever you like best, and don't worry about. There will always be someone that doesn't like YOUR choice. I HATE Crape Myrtles, but when someone asks me for helping in selecting or taking care of them, I do my best to do just that to the best of my ability, and I don't criticize them on their choice. Some people will not like your choice because it is "so common" (much as Slim's qoutes come down to), others will not like your choice if it is slower or more uncommon because they don't see longer lived or less common as a good reason to plant anything else. In their minds "it's JUST a freak'in tree, what's the big freak'in deal". I suspect many growers won't like the more common because there is more price competition, and then there are other professionals that won't like the more common because it lessens the demand for their services.

    I like the unusual, but I also like the common stuff that it nice. Hence I have ABM/AFM, but I also have Triflorium Maple, and an extremely rare form of Korean Maple. Point being, go with what you like, and neither, nor the AFM or "Sienna" as mentioned by whaas are bad choices. Just know what you are getting.

    BTW, other selections of Red Maple are Burgundy Belle, Brandywine, Redpointe, Autumn Spire, Sun Valley, Autumn Radiance, Somerset, Bohall, Embers, Red Super Sonic, Polara, Red Rocket, Summer Red among many others. Each has their own differences. This does not cover selections of the hybrid maples.

    Whatever you choose, come back for help with planting as I stated before. Plenty of people will be willing to help you for the long term health of your trees.

    Arktrees

  • 15 years ago

    "I have learned my lesson believ. I didn't water e me"

    My 2 year old felt compelled to help me construct that sentence while he was watching Toy Story lol sorry

    Just pretend that isn't in my reply ;-)

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks everyone for you advice/comments. I have a professional arborist planting my trees so I'm not too worried about the planting. I need to make sure I take care of them properly. My concern is getting them enough water without overwatering. I am going to shoot for planting in late Sept/early Oct and hope fot the best.

    Thanks again everyone.

  • 15 years ago

    ABM trees are pretty easy to grow here in Dallas area compared to regular maple. Silver maples don't do very well here in the long run. Grows fast but I haven't seen a large mature ABM though. Grow it if you need shade fast and like it's fall color. I agree with Arktree, kinda pointless to worry about growing trees that would outlive you but not provide much needed shade in your lifetime. Just have to be smart about which tree to plant. ABM isn't a bad tree. Go for it.

  • 15 years ago

    Centre82,
    Not trying to change your mind on anything, just following up for completeness since John mentioned my experience with Scarlet Oak. I believe John was referring to two things.

    1. I had a 2" caliper ~15' tall B&B Scarlet Oak planted last November, and to my great surprise it produced shoots in the spring of up to ~18"-24" and large leaves. I had expected 3"-5" shoots, and half size leaves. Also the best I can tell it was growing ~3'-4+' per year at the tree farm. It has far exceeded my expectations. My best explanation is that it had been extensively and repeatedly root pruned by the grower. When I selected it, it also had retina burning Neon Scarlet fall color as well.

    2. I collected 6 acorns from a Scarlet Oak last fall, and cold stratified them. In spring I planted those in a high draining media, in pots made for hydroponics to encourage root pruning (which is exactly what they did). From acorns planted in April, I got 6 seedlings, and they currently range from 18"-32" in height after 4 flushes of growth. Obviously I don't yet know how they will color in the fall.

    The take home message to me is that given good conditions, Scarlet Oaks will very nearly keep up with all but the very fastest growing maples, while giving you longer life, more storm resistance, great fall color, not the same tree that so many people already have. I lucked into the 2" caliper tree when I happened to be looking, that is the only time I have seen them available. Largely because the industry is just now figuring out how to grow them for success. Same with many other Oaks with a tap root system.

    Arktrees

  • 15 years ago

    Arktrees,

    I've actually been considering a Scarlet Oak to replace the large tree I had to take out and going with an Autumn Blaze Maple in my other location. I'm just really concerned about the growth rate of the oak. If I were planting a "legacy tree" then I would definitely go with the oak. However, I'm in dire need of shade as soon as I can possibly get some. I can't even sit on my front porch anymore in the evenings because the house faces west and the sun is right in your face.

  • 15 years ago

    I have every compassion for facing west into the sun, that is exactly our patio. I had pretty much the same concern about Oak, and I have always loved maples, so that is what I have more than any other. However from being on here, and then having a B-I-L that LOVES Oaks, I ended up educating myself much more on Oaks, and have come to learn that there are some I very much like. Not all Oaks grow slowly, and if you get right down to it, there is probable just a large of a proportion of maples that grow slowly as Oaks. Scarlet Oaks aren't slow, and I don't consider them to be "legacy" trees, as they can get quiet large quickly. Northern Red Oaks are probable about the fastest growing Oak and one of the easiest to transplant. But Pin's, Shumards and Nuttall's grow quickly as well. The key as always seems to be suitable conditions. Good soil that isn't compacted, that drains reasonable well. Also nothing says you could not have one of each. As stated our 2" caliper is about 15' tall, and well branched. Once established, and growing normally again, those branches will quickly extend (the largest were pruned back for shipping from the farm), and I will have a very nice sized full tree in a couple years. Besides as John suggested above, you could have one of each if you choose. There are lots of people on here that LOVE Oaks, and can give you better advice than I for your area. If you truely would like to consider a Scarlet, or some other Oak, then start a new thread with them in the title so that you can attract the attention of the Oak people, as I doubt most of them are reading this thread on Maples.

    Lastly, forgot to include in my previous posts. Red Sunset is a great Red Maple, but here at least grows about 18"/yr, while our ABM and AFM grows 36+"/yr. My climate is probable very similar to yours. I'm Zone 6 in far Northwest Arkansas.

    Arktrees

  • 13 years ago

    As I research all the maple choices, it seems that the "pure" rubrum cultivars grow fastest in notably acid soils, like below a pH of 6. Between 6 and 7.3 or so, they'll grow more slowly, and above that, they'll be chlorotic.

    the "freeman" maples (AF, AB, Sienna, the silver-red hybrids) can go a bit higher in pH and still grow quickly. So if you see that rubrums outgrow Freemans, I bet you have acid soil, and if it's the other way around, your soil is probably closer to a neutral or slightly alkaline pH.

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio