Software
Houzz Logo Print
saypoint

Acer platanoides 'Emerald Queen'

19 years ago

After much thought and many hundreds spent on remedial pruning and cabling, we finally decided to remove two very large Norway maples and one sad old sugar maple in the front yard before they killed someone or wrecked our house. The deed was done last week, and I was waiting for my landscaper neighbor to get back to me with what his wholesale nursery has in stock to replant in the front of the house, and somewhat laboriously carting the carcasses, in nice 18 inch lengths, to the backyard to await the splitter and woodpile.

Yesterday, a nursery truck pulled up in front, and several guys hopped out and planted two Emerald Queens in the grass strip out by the road. Now, I wasn't really planning on replanting any lawn in the front anyway, but these trees, commissioned by the town, have essentially squelched any hope I had of getting rid of those horrible moisture sucking shallow roots that have been competing with my shrub plantings, and they will definitely clash, in time, both spacewise and visually, with the replacement shade tree I was planning on to shade those shrubs.

Does this cultivar drop those zillions of viable seeds I was hoping I was through with? Maybe I need to buy a couple of different trees and move these during the night, replacing them with a different species? I'm betting no one would know the difference.

Comments (17)

  • 19 years ago

    Maybe you explain that you removed the new trees because you thought that being noxious weeds that they volunteered there. Or you can do what I would do which would be to replace them when nobody was looking.

  • 19 years ago

    ...uh, in the city where I live and work (For the Forestry Dept!), that would be stealing or destruction of city property.

    I'm not nuts about Norway maple and agree with the problems they can cause, but........they should be considered as part of a system, just as the sewer and water pipes that run in the street in front of your house are parts of systems. Even if you didn't wish to be supplied with water and sewer at your house, do you think it reasonable request that these pipes not be buried in front of your property? I didn't think so. The trees are not just for your benefit. They are part of an urban forest, the benefits of which go far beyond their immediate impact to you.

    Another shade tree planted in your yard will be growing up right along with these new boulevard trees and as such, should have an excellent chance of developing properly. Or, since I'm a conifer enthusiast, how about a nice, fast growing, wide spreading white pine or other vigorous conifer?

    +oM

  • 19 years ago

    Girdle them with the weed-eater.

    Oops, did I do that? LOL

  • 19 years ago

    What I don't understand is why they would choose this particular tree, unless they left it up to the nursery owner to choose. Norway maple is on my state's invasive list, and is banned in MA, only an hour away.

    It is planted within feet of a concrete sidewalk that is used by a steady stream of recreational walkers in my community, and I am apparently expected to maintain the walk. When it cracks and heaves, it will be my problem.

    I'm thinking of calling the nursery and asking them if they will replace it with something else, and offering to pay for the cost of the labor. I'll also bring it to the attention of the town. I'm guessing they will argue that it has not been proven that these cultivars are as invasive as the species.

  • 19 years ago

    Norway maple was an extremely common choice for street tree purposes for years. While I agree with you that it's time to move away from them due to their invasiveness and the extreme succeptibility to girdling root problems in mid-age, things sometimes move slowly in the tree world. For another example, many nurseries here STILL offer buckthorn, even though that plants agressiveness is absolutely destroying our woodlands in many areas.

    If you do wish to take this further, do not let anyone tell you the cultivars of N. maple are not invasive like the species. They will do exactly the same thing.

    +oM

  • 19 years ago

    Many industry favorites have gone wild in eastern North America, are still commonly grown by large producers. There's a relationship, of course, the same ability to quickly make a nice thrifty specimen in grower's fields isn't limited to those fields alone.

  • 19 years ago

    Saypoint: If you decide to meet with town officials (and you have nothing to lose but time), you need information from experts to make your case. Assume that the person / people who authorized this decision are (1) not knowledgeable about trees or (2) their knowledge is out-of-date.

    Get reports and information from respected sources (i.e., universities, lists of recommended urban trees, state invasives lists, etc). Find out if you will meet with one person or more than one. Package the documents in binders. Make a table of documents so people can find a report or list easily. Make sure each person has their own personal binder.

    If you are asked how the town policy should change, you need to have an answer - what the town can do differently AND the benefits to the town for changing their policy. Some towns have knowledgeable people who help town officials decide what should be planted where and why (or why not).

    If you use reports from experts and other respected sources to educate and inform, you may cause the present policy to change. Many people will benefit in the future.

    Even if this happens, the town probably won't agree to take down your trees (admitting that they made a mistake). They may allow you to replace them with trees from a list of recommended urban trees.

    If you decide to go forward on this issue, keep us posted. We all have battles with bureacrats from time to time. It's good to know what works and what doesn't work. The strategy I outlined usually works unless the proposed solution is expensive or labor-intensive.

    Pam

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks. I have already bookmarked a dozen websites of universities, municipalities, state agencies, and societies that promote conservation and/or native plants, all of which detail the problems of this tree.

    Only one, if I recall specifically addresses the controversy over whether or not named cultivars have the same problems as the species. It consists of the minutes of a meeting about whether to include cultivars on a list, and there is an argument that they should be included until proven non-invasive, instead of the other way around.

    The nursery owner is not willing to do anything, and states that the cultivar is not invasive. I emailed him this morning offering to pay the labor and difference in material cost to plant something else. I know the town is also planting Kwanzan cherries, so I don't see why they would care.

    My community is very conservation minded, we have a program underway to remove phragmites from the wetlands, there is an active conservation commission, as well as a broader council that tries to protect our river estuary environment. I'm guessing these folks would be surprised to know that the town is planting Norways.

    Funny thing, though, that I just remembered this morning, when the nursery guy first got out of his truck, he told me he was planting red maples. It wasn't until he had them off the truck and the holes dug that I went over and looked at the tags. Hmmm. Maybe the town thinks they're planting the native Acer rubrum?

  • 19 years ago

    They don;t know one from the other.
    I wish you luck saybrook. Your doing the right thing by bringing this to their attention.

    And tom, using your example of the sewer pipes, if the pipes leaked sewage and gases or caused other problems you bet people would complain. It ma not be within their power to remove them from underground. It's a little different than replacing one maple tree for another.

  • 19 years ago

    Oh yeah, +om, is this kudzu government property also since it was the goverment that planted it originally?

  • 19 years ago

    Saypoint: Since your town is conservation minded, the town officials probably do think the contractor is planting Acer rubrum.

    So many people spend energy complaining to people who don't have the power to fix a problem, but don't inform the officials who do have power. I'm glad you decided to go forward on this, evidence in hand. Your story may have a happy ending after all.

    Pam

  • 19 years ago

    Yes, and not only did he tell me he was planting red maples, the woman from the nursery who called back after speaking to him about my problem, to tell me that he was not going to change them, told me that they had planted 'October Glory'. Not hardly.

    How convenient that my next door neighbor is having a "meet and greet" this Wednesday evening for the town First Selectman, so I will be seeing him there. I was actually going for the desserts initially, but this is even better.

  • 19 years ago

    If you can, having leaves, or pictures of leaves, from both trees, to CLEARLY delineate the difference between what is there and what is SUPPOSED to be there, might help your cause. And maybe a strong flashlight so you can drag the Selectman out to SEE for himself - this depends on what the feeling you get from him on the Wed. evening, of course!

    Good luck!!!

  • 19 years ago

    Maples drop seeds. What species it is doesn't really matter, maples drop seeds. If you want to complain about Norway, also complain about red, silver, Manitoba, sugar and Japanese.

    Large trees have moisture sucking roots. Maples are merely a variety of tree that can grow large, but there are many others...if having a large roots system is a problem, may I recommend something that is not a tree?

    I do fully understand why Norways are at the top of a list of hated and despised plants, although if the traits that place Norway upon that list are negatives, then most trees also belong on that list, and to be derided with equal vehemence.

    Decide now if you want to pursue this. As I understand your initial posting, you had a something in your mind your mind you wanted to accomplish and A norway maple was not it, and because you feel your goal is The Most Important Thing, you are looking for reasons to support your way of going about it.

    Of course, the best way may be the most direct. Don't make a fuss, simply buy the trees you want, remove the ones you don't, and do the swap in an afternoon. As long as you match sizes, there should be no problem. If you replace a 2" caliper tree with a 4' whip, you may be opening a can of worms...but if you replace a 2" with a 2", odds are, no one's gonna be the wiser.

    Upon occasion, it's amazing what you can do...when you don't ask.

  • 19 years ago

    Oh that damn government,eh quercks? Screwing everything up.

    Saypoint, I can only reiterate that the immature responses of a few here would have had you performing criminal actions. I'm glad you're well beyond that point and wish you luck in ammending your towns policy.

    And again, there is every reason to believe these cultivars can and will spread viable seed. It absolutely does happen.

    +oM

  • 19 years ago

    Well, Tom, since you don't "know" me, you won't know that my suggestion in my OP that I might replace them during the night was made in jest. I do that a lot. I'm certainly not one of those people who could end up needing the services of a bail bondsman because I took the advice of someone on a public forum, LOL. Plus, I'd rather have someone else do the heavy digging. (Joke) But I certainly appreciate that you cared enough to worry about me.

    I'll let y'all know how it turns out.
    Jo

  • 19 years ago

    Oh I guess that would be my suggestion that was immature?

    Well if you really don't like the trees you can just do what everyone else does. Pile mulch volcanoes on them, plant flowers at the base of the tree, have a sprinkler installed in the root ball and also a floodlight and one of those speakers that looks like a rock. Get a value pack of tree stakes and a bag of miracle grow, tack up a hammock, bird house, a swing and one of those stupid wooden happy-faces-for-trees. Assuming the tree pit was 2-3' wide and dog owners let their dogs pee on it, that official town property has about 6 months before the contractor gets to replace it. Sometimes things just have a way of working themselves out.