Software
Houzz Logo Print
ken_adrian

why is a copper beach purple????

so i went to longwood gardens.. saw their magnificent 'copper' beeches ... as they called them ...

so i go to my tree guy ... and he sells me a purple beech ... riversii ...

can anyone enlighten me to why a purple leaf is copper ...

perhaps its a timing thing.. and in ten years.. i just haven't walked by to see a copper effect... maybe sundown...

any ideas??

ken

Comments (10)

  • 15 years ago

    Copper beeches are inferior forms that are not as deeply colored. You see the same thing with other purple-leaved trees and shrubs, over time inferior less purple seedlings have become supplemented or replaced in general commerce by grafted named forms with superior attributes. If your 'Riversii' was never a good deep purple throughout the whole growing season its being true-to-name becomes suspect.

  • 15 years ago

    Copper Beeches are purple because of the higher amounts of anthocyanins they produce compared to normal green plants. The quantity of anthocyanins produced, and thus the intensity of the purple, varies a lot from clone to clone; 'Riversii' is one of the more intensely purple Copper Beeches.

    As for a copper beach . . . that would depend on the colour of the sand ;-)

    Resin

  • 15 years ago

    mine is very deep purple ... a true riversii ...

    and most likely.. that is why it never looked copper ..

    go figure.. that common name BS again ... lol ..

    so my tree guy knew i was asking for an inferior plant.. and led me to a good selected variety ... perhaps he told me that 10 years ago .. but that brain cell is long gone .... most likely he didnt have a bad seedling on the property ....

    ken

    ps: the bigger mystery is why longwood gardens had its common name on the sign ... hmmmmm .. i was not into the latin name thingee way back when ... so if it was there i paid no attention ...

  • 15 years ago

    Yes, it's inapt to call a purple one copper.

  • 15 years ago

    As an aside over ten years ago I had the privilege to live close to Harting West Sussex in the South Downs of England. They had a mile of fantastic Copper Beeches leading to the Beacon Hill School (the area is also called Telegraph house) which the logician/philosopher Bertrand Russell created BEACON HILL SCHOOL in the late 20's. Amazing trees especialy in such a long row (if you are in the are worth a visit!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 15 years ago

    "Yes, it's inapt to call a purple one copper"

    An immeasurably vast lot less inapt, than calling juniper or cypresses 'cedars', or maples 'elders', or rowans 'ashes' . . . if we're going to complain about bad common names, deal with the really bad ones first!

    Resin

  • 15 years ago

    Not all copper beeches ARE purple :-) Fagus sylvatica is an extremely variable species and some selections, often seedling grown, can be much more coppery in leaf color than purple. And I'd not necessarily consider them "inferior".....just different from the real purple colored forms.

    There are several mature, 50+ y.o. specimens in the Seattle area that are truly copper - not purple - in color and are rather stunning, especially when backlit by the sun or when taking on fall tones. I actually prefer this coloring to that of the "purple" beeches, which can be rather overwhelmingly dark and oppressive in color when fully mature.

    As to common names, let's not get into that pointless argument again. They are what they are, neither correct nor incorrect but simply a common, vernacular reference.

  • 15 years ago

    >As to common names, let's not get into that pointless argument again. They are what they are, neither correct nor incorrect but simply a common, vernacular referenceYep.

  • 15 years ago

    no i dont want you to regurgitate that argument..

    my point.. if there are any newbies left reading these posts .. is that you really do need the Latin name .. to get what you really want.. rather than a common name.. which might lead you to an inferior plant ...

    i said i looked at the arbs tag.. and only read the common name.. but my tree guy lined me up with the proper Latin named cultivar ....

    thank god for that.. or i would be doing a post called... why is my purple beech a dull brown all the time.. lol ...

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    The 'Riversii' the city planted in front of my house had copper colored leaves in the fall. ;-)

    tj