Software
Houzz Logo Print
annedee_gw

Help with new dying succulents

18 years ago

5 days ago I was at Home Depot and saw that they finally got in a nice stock of cacti/succulents. I've been looking and waiting, hoping to make a potted collection someday. It took a few days to find the perfect pot for them, so they've been sitting in their original pots. I haven't watered them yet, and already some of the new growth and longer branches are falling off. My apartment has very low humidity right now, but I have a SE facing sky light that brings in some bright light for a few hours.

I've tried keeping jade before with no luck, but my desert rose is fine (though doesn't flower). I love the plants I just bought, but don't know what's already wrong. I have been researching for hours and can only conclude that maybe they are just that thirsty. I know usually they are killed from overwatering, but the soil is dry. Surely they are getting more light than on the bottom shelp at HD, but they are getting only very indirect light right now.

I'd like to replant them in their new home asap, but I know I shouldn't water for a few weeks after I do so. Should I water them and wait a few days? Or not water them and hope they get better.

Thanks!

ps - don't know what kind they are, but none are spiny, a few are "furry", and they are all more silver/grey rather than dark green with a few having some pink/purple edges.

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    If you are serious about being successful at growing plants, you'll also need to be serious about providing adequate conditions for them.

    Skylights in my opinion are only good for not needing to turn on a light to see where I'm going during the day. I have 4 of them in our house and they are nice, but they are not a light source for plants. I think more of my plants than that. :-)

    Very few plants will receive enough light to grow and stay healthy under those kinds of conditions. At best they will just survive in a slow state of decline.

    Keep in mind those plants you bought were probably getting "sun" and growing under very nice conditions in a greenhouse before they went through the stress of shipment and then the torture of being kept at a box store.

    I'm personally not an impulse buyer. I look, ask questions, research, and then find a good place to buy what I'm interested in. That usually doesn't happen at a box store. But I've been known to spot something worth taking home there on occasion, but they are things I'm familiar with and know their needs.

    Do you have windows that face south or west? Are they unobstructed to the point direct sunlight shines through them? Have you considered supplemental light to get them through the winter? And then move them outdoors where they can thrive under much better growing conditions during the growing season?

    randy

  • 18 years ago

    I noticed I left east windows out of my question. I'm not biased about them. :-) Our living room faces east and has a wall of floor to ceiling windows and then French doors. That's where I keep all my big plants over the winter to save space in the greenhouse for smaller things.

    randy

  • 18 years ago

    As mentioned, I was planning on this purchase for a while and have done some research previously about succulent health, though I know each species is somewhat different. All my windows face ESE, but I get very little direct light during winter. I have a grow light system already for other plants, thank you. Also, from my research, my silvery plants would burn from direct light. So I was hoping the bright morning light would suffice during winter until they can go on my balcony. So thank you for your critical input - I never claimed to be an expert. However, some advice on what my next step is would be most helpful.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm not sure though why you thought it was critical. I thought it was informative since it sounded like you are fairly new to plants. I even asked questions hoping to help you even more.

    Since you obviously think little of my advice, why don't I be a little critical to fit the mold you have made for me?

    You said in your first message you "don't know what kind they are." But the silvery ones that you "don't know what they are" will burn from direct light. I'm confused. You don't know what they are, but they will burn. Hmm. :-)

    I'm by no means an expert, but I'm not familiar with succulents that can't handle some form of direct light.

    I wish you luck with your plants and hope someone will find the time to offer you the advice you want to hear. I have better things to do.

    your overly critical friend :-)

  • 18 years ago

    Any plant potted in Home Depot is destined for failure. immediately take them out of the pot, make sure there are no pests/ mealies in the roots, trim off the dead roots, and give them a fresh new soil mix and leave the plants warm, dry and bright for 2 weeks before they are watered.

    rjj1 is absolutely right, and I will be even more critical: there is no way your plants will be healthy in the conditions you describe. They will survive for a long time, but without adequate light, good air circulation, and proper seasonal temperature ranges, your plants will slowly decline.

    And unless your grow lights are HID, they will not be of much benefit other than to supplement the lower winter light levels. But being @ room temperature in the winter is already a difficult situation since most likely most of your plants will benefit from a cool dormancy.

    You may not like our advice but we're here to offer some help. We have already made the mistakes and learned from them.

  • 18 years ago

    I've been keeping plants for over 15 years, but with varying luck. Part of the problem is that I move a lot, so a happy plant in one place becomes unhappy in another. Winter in this home is hard on my plants I know. However, they love the summer and recover very well on my balcony. With the days getting longer and spring being near, better light, better circulation, and changing temps. are soon to come. My windows aren't the best, so the temp. near them is definitely cooler than the rest of the house.

    I've tried to figure out what kind my new succulents are, but it's not been easy. 1 aeonium (maybe nobile), 1 cotyledon, 1 crassula nudacaulis, 1 echeveria lola, 1 graproveria amethorum, 1 sedum clavatum and 5 others I can't identify. None of them are dark green or even really green, if anything they are a "mint" color. I've read that these types need less light than the darker varieties, which is why I chose them.

    I didn't mean to be rude, but I was feeling attacked in your first response given that you know nothing about me. I would not be on these boards if I knew nothing and did not care. I know the signs of over and under watering, when I've been in the plants care for a while. Not knowing if these plants are dormant or growing yet doesn't help either (coming from a greenhouse their cycles can be random). I have repotted them and one that was still very moist is drying out first. Though you seem skeptical, hopefully they will do fine inside for another month or two until they can go outside.

  • 18 years ago

    The species you mention are all rather straightforward and not as finicky as many other C&S, but the aeonium and cotyledon do not like warm (60-65F+) nights for growth.

  • 18 years ago

    If you don't trust the knowledgable people here I suggest that you get some books. I have assumed that you needed help, yet you shut out the help that was given, it would be nice to even thank these people for their time. My response would not be welcomed here.