Software
Houzz Logo Print
tanyag_gw

Soil not draining

20 years ago

I am a 'newbie' so to speak and am having great difficulty with my soil not draining but also not absorbing any water at all. I have potted up about 30 or so S&C. Here is my method. Clay pots, window screen cut to size of bottom of pot to keep soil from running out, 1 inch pea gravel to help with drainage, commercially purchased cactus soil with added perlite and gravel, pea gravel on top for aesthetics. I waited a week or better to water them after repotting per instructions in many different post. I went to water them the other day and had to do it VERY SLOWLY as water was just not going into the plant but rather draining over the sides. I would put a little, wait, put a little, wait, etc. I did this at least 10 times or more thinking that they were sufficiently wet. I used my water meter the next day to check them and it is registering completely dry. What the heck? I am confused. I have heard about using coir and would love to use it if I could find a retailer near me (south part of Houston) who sold it. Should I be watering from the bottom? What is the deal?

Thanks,

Tanya

Comments (29)

  • 20 years ago

    Remove the window screen. It is not helping drainage. Do not use a layer of gravel at the bottom of the pot either. Just mix gravel/perlite/and soil together. Only minimal amount will be lost through the holes in the bottom. Top dressing is unecessary and you can't see the soil, so don't use it until you are comfortable with your watering regime.

    I think you have created a situation that is not allowing free drainage when top watering. Bottom watering is the best way to water any succulent. Place the pot in a larger container 1/3 to 2/3 the depth of your pot for 10-20 minutes. Capillary action will draw water throughout the root ball. Sometimes top watering of very dry soil is ineffective because the soil becomes hydrophobic and doesn't absorb water easily.

    Try bottom watering first and compare the weight of the pot before and after. You should notice a big difference. When lifting the pot out of the water you should see free drainage of excess water. If you do not, repot to get rid of the window screen and gravel layer at the bottom of the pots.

  • 20 years ago

    I would have to respectfully disagree about not using window screen to cover drainage holes. I have about 2000 plants in pots and all of the ones in clay or bonsai pots have the wire screen used on doors to keep soil from coming out of the large drainage holes.

    I grow some pretty nice stuff and my soil is very fast draining. I don't add layers of stone though. As hot as it gets here, I want every square inch of pot for soil to keep roots happy.

    Watering from the bottom would be silly for me and most people who have large collections of container plants. I'm also hard pressed to come up with plants in nature that are watered that way.

    randy

  • 20 years ago

    Could I have the soil too packed in? When I repotted the plants, I wasn't sure how much I should pack in the soil and for some, if I didn't pack it pretty well around the main plant, it would flop over. I may just need to redo all of it and not pack in so much and rely in the pea gravel to hold it in place. They are all indoors so I don't really have to worry about wind. Any thoughts?

  • 20 years ago

    I can't really tell you what the problem is, but you do seem to have one if the water pools on top of the soil. It is possible for a soil to be dense enough to hold water on top for a while but still suitable for succulents, but this isn't very likely by accident.

    Does the water run out of the bottom of the pot? If so, your window screen sounds fine. Seems like you have an inch of pea gravel in the bottom? That achieves nothing except to effectively give you pot one inch less deep. It does not improve drainage, it actually makes it slightly worse, just like a shallow pot.

    Commercial cactus soil is likely to be peat based. Your additives of perlite and gravel sound fine. Very dry peat repels water and is incredibly hard to get wet. You can wet it by standing it for a long time in water, then it is very hard to get dry again. It is horrible stuff for succulents except in small quantities where it can help to hold a little water and nutrients. My mixes include up to 25% peat, any more is just not good.

    Use a loam-based soil if you possibly can, that's the same stuff you find in a garden (or in the desert) but much sandier than most garden soils, not very much clay. Coir is very free-draining and doesn't hold nutrients. Some people use it, I don't. It is better than peat.

    I don't compress the soil around my succulents, just drop it in around the plant and tap the pot to settle it down. It tends to settle a little more over time so I pot quite high in the pot. I use a top dressing, it keeps the perlite down and I like the look. I also water from the top (usually) and a dressing stops dry soil from washing around. The water drains through quickly, it would take some effort to pour on water fast enough to overflow the pot.

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks to all. Shrubs n Bulbs, would something like Scotts garden soil be okay. If I dump everything into a big container, what should I mix with the peat based soil that I have? Course grain sand? Decomposing granite? There are so many choices. I wish Al would read this. He always has the scientific solution when it comes to soils. It sounds like your soil works so what exactly do you do?
    Thanks again,
    Tanya

  • 20 years ago

    And then I have a friend growing her 1st place show plants in nothing but pumice, she waters in the summer once a week and follows up with liquid fertilizer. The screen at the bottom keeps the bugs out. The top dressing helps hold down the weeds, and stops seedlings from popping up in that pot. I need to water about 25 thousand plants a week, we use small 4" pots , no screen but there are 4 hold round the sides of the pots. We use gravel on top, and it drains rather rapidly. Don't use cactus mix, because it has peat moss, and far too much of it. Once it dries out you must put the pot into a large flat cake pan and fill with water, let it stand for at least 1/2 hour or until you can see that the top is wet. I don't have time to do with each plant. Use a label for a water meter to check and see how damp your soil is. Chops sticks or a pencil will work as well. Take the plant out and check the root ball and see if it's soaked through if not get rid of the peat moss mix. These suggestions are not a fix all, just some suggestions that perhaps may help you. Norma

  • 20 years ago

    Another thing. A good top dressing keeps your soil from being washed out of the pot in a gully washer. A Texican should be able to relate to that :-).

    Almost all soil mixes made for public use are crap and need to be amended. Norma is right, peat sucks. Packed and bone dry, peat will repeal water for long periods of time. You have to submerse it to hydrate it again once it's that dry.

    randy

  • 20 years ago

    Peat is around 20% of my mix. I use a high fired clay called haydite and composted soil conditioner as main ingredients.

    Sand may work well for others, but I don't care for it no matter how course it is. I never had Adeniums rot over the winter until I added it to a mix as an experiment one year. I probably lost 40 plants.

    randy

  • 20 years ago

    Everyone talks about Haydite, but I don't know where to get it locally. I have also looked for the coir since it doesn't become so hydrophobic like peat. I don't have a problem with peat for my fruits, veggies, and herbs because I keep those watered, but with letting the c&s dry out completely between waterings, it's horrible. Anyone know where or how to get the haydite and coir locally?

  • 20 years ago

    I buy it locally from the manufacturer by the pickup load. If it's a problem finding a local distributor, you might check out a product called turface. It can be ordered from most local feed and seed. It's used on baseball fields for good drainage and sold in 50# bags (I think :-)).

    randy

  • 20 years ago

    As I recently had the same problem, I would say that the issue is purely a matter of the soil being too packed. The method I came up with is this:

    1) a pebble to cover the drain hole
    2) a couple inches of store bought cactus mix (do not pack)
    3) set the plant in and spoon more cactus mix around to desired level(do not pack)
    4) Prop the plant up (I was doing a couple dozen jade plants) and wait a couple days for the roots to heal
    5) hold the plant with one hand and water with the other. Keep watering until all of the soil is wet. If it is very dry this could take a while.

    The soil will settle and hold the plant up. And I don't know what store bought cactus mix you are all talking about, the cactus mix I bye doesn't have any peat in it at all: composed bark, sand, vermiculite and/or pereilite. If it is really, really dry out of the bag I mix in a small about of water a while before I use it--but very little.

  • 20 years ago

    Composted bark is also not ideal for cacti, although you'll probably like it to start with. Longterm, it decomposes becoming more acidic and clogging the soil. Coir is more stable and decomposes only very slowly. I would recommend repotting at least every couple of years in this type of mix.

  • 20 years ago

    What you say is very true. I tend to underpot and repot on a regular basis, so it's never been an issue for me. The plant gets bumped up before any compacting becomes a problem.

    I tend to grow some pretty nice plants in spite of using that nasty ole bark:-).

    randy

  • 20 years ago

    Randy,
    What ratio do you use with the haydite and soil conditioner? I have purchased soil conditioner and some stuff called Oildri from Sam's Club. Searching the web for Haydite and Turface brought me to a Bonsai site that was discussing the fact that this is the same stuff - high fired clay. It is only $3.58 for a 40# bag. I will have to sift out the dust, but for that price, you can't beat it. It even says on the bag that it is used by gardeners to improve the drainage and porosity of the soil. It is marketed to be used to absorb oil and other things from garage floors. SO back to the original question - 20% peat and equal parts of the soil conditioner and non-organic material? or is it a different ratio? Thanks again.
    Tanya

  • 20 years ago

    Why make your own when you can buy a GREAT soil off ebay. Thats what I did. Ever since I used the sellers soil I have not lost a single plant. It is super fast draining but also keeps moist.Here is a link to the sellers auction for his soil. I absolutely recommend it.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cactus soil

  • 20 years ago

    Hi Tanya

    It's 2 parts haydite, 2 parts soil conditioner, and 1 part 702 Metro mix (commercial mix for succulents).

    randy

  • 20 years ago

    I want to make my own because for the $18 that you pay to fill up six 6" pots, I can make enough to fill up 30-40! Probably good stuff but outrageously priced. =0(

  • 20 years ago

    gizynski1533

    To each his own. It costs me about me about $16.00 to fill up 2 33 gallon trash cans full of soil.

    randy

  • 20 years ago

    Humm I guess you guys are right. The amount he sent me has lasted me for a long time. Maybe thats because i have small cactus and only about 40 of them.

  • 20 years ago

    There is nothing wrong in paying $18.00 for soil if it lasts for a long time and you are happy with it.

    randy

  • 20 years ago

    Compared to this typical commercial cactus soil, the eBay soil is great. How can anybody call a cactus soil made from peat and vermiculte "just right"??? Anyway, compared to the stuff I mix myself for about a dollar a gallon, the eBay soil is outrageously priced and I don't even know what's in it, what the pH is, whether it includes fertiliser, etc., etc. In other words, useless to me. Trust me, after a few years of growing you will develop your own particular mix(es) and will tell everyone who asks how it is the best soil mix in the world ;)

  • 20 years ago

    I mixed up my soil today. Used 2 parts soil conditioner (pine bark fines with compost), 2 parts of the OilDri, and 1 part C&S mix. It is draining beautifully. I checked in a pot before I planted up some. I am changing out the rest tomorrow. The OilDri looks very much like the haydite and other high fired clay that I have seen on web so I hope the article I read in the Bonsai site was true. Only time will tell.

  • 20 years ago

    hello,

    you have had a lot of advice.

    But as an after thought, I was wondering if you had enough holes in the bottom of your pot.

    I drill more around the ubiquitus one in the middle.

    I am told holes around the side at the bottom are even better.You may have noticed plastic pots from the nursary have holes on the bottom edge and in fact have none on the bottom.

    Just a lateral thought.

    I use a ceramic drill bit . it quickly and cleanly cuts through any clay pot i have used.

  • 20 years ago

    Hey Baldric,
    I thought about that, but the pots themselves are so small. The one big pot that I do have I put more holes in it. The soil mix I made is draining perfectly now through just the one little hole. Thanks for the advice though!

  • 20 years ago

    At the end of the day, any hole at the lowest level of the pot will allow water out if the soil drains well. Multiple holes are just a good idea so that one hole doesn't become blocked and so that a tilted pot still has an outlet at the lowest level.

    I hate those big pots that have a single hole in the middle big enough to put my fist through. What are they thinking? Big pot, big soil, big hole?

  • 19 years ago

    Just to update an old message. The soil mix still drains very well. We were worried about the OilDri not really being the high fired clay and that it would break down over time. It hasn't. It is still just as hard as it ever was and SOOO much cheaper than the brand Turface.

  • 19 years ago

    Tanya: Before I found a place that sold coir in bulk by the 2 sq. ft. bag, I tried something called "Bed-a-Beast" that comes in "bricks" to be used as bedding for reptiles, I think it was . Pet Smart had it. This was several years ago, so my memory may be faulty, but as I recall, I had to pour boiling water over the brick, which rapidly swelled up into about a bucketful of nice fluffy coir. I mix coir with about an equal amount of pumice in the form of "Dry Stall," something used in horses' stalls, also putting in some fertilizer granules. You might try Bed-a-Beast, just to see how you like it.

  • 19 years ago

    I had looked for coir when I started this obsession last year. Never had any luck finding it in bulk. I think my succulents are completely underwatered. I hope they're not dead. We had such a time with cold temperatures and I went too long without watering. The leaves are shriveled. I have read some who sit them in a flat container overnight and they plump right up. Is this true?

  • 19 years ago

    Many succulents may shrivel during dry periods. This is OK, especially if it's during their dormant period. Don't soak the pots overnight; that's too much water after such a long period. I would do some light watering (just enough to come out of the bottom of the pot). Wait a few days, and see how they respond. I gradually increase watering this time of year, as light levels lengthen and intensify.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio