Software
Houzz Logo Print
dorianscale3

Winter Growers

13 years ago

Hi all. As I am fairly new to the succulent world, I was wondering if someone could clarify the concept of winter growers. I've come across several web pages that list Senecio and Aeonium as winter growers, yet both of mine (S. serpens/A. kiwi) seem to be thriving in the Connecticut weather. Any thoughts?

Thanks.
-Nick

Comments (8)

  • 13 years ago

    Some plants are pretty opportunistic winter growers, meaning that they don't go completely dormant during the summer if the conditions are right or more mild, and that they kind of plug along and keep growing through the warmer season. I have a couple Aeoniums that begin to go into dormancy, but have yet to go completely dormant; instead, they produce growth through most of the summer, unless it's horrendously hot, but not nearly as much growth as they do during the winter. I give them regular sips of water, while the dormant Aeoniums that ball up tightly I leave alone until they wake in fall. Something being a winter grower or summer grower I just take as a warning that the plant will probably thrive and have its maximum amount of growth in that season, and that it typically will require less water and go dormant during the opposite season. With each individual plant, based on how it's doing, you'll find a middle ground of watering. If the winter grower seems to keep chugging along, maybe occasional drinks during the summer rather than letting it go completely dry until fall.

    This post was edited by teatree on Wed, Jun 26, 13 at 11:34

  • 13 years ago

    That makes sense. I was pretty happy with the pace at which my plants are growing, but now I'm really excited for the winter months when they begin to thrive. Since I'm only going to have access to an east facing window, would it be worth it to invest in some sort of all-spectrum light bulb to aid my plants and prevent etiolation?

    Thanks.
    -Nick

  • 13 years ago

    Winter grower is code word for "we don't like it hot", so in the heat of the summer they shut down. But heat is relative, so depending on where you are, it may not get hot enough for long enough to stop growth. A few species stop growth in the summer no matter what, but most "winter growers" simply grow best when the weather and moisture are most suitable.

  • 13 years ago

    All mine keep growing all year, even in summer since my summers are very rarely hot long enough..I guess am lucky for these but not for Adeniums!

    X worded it perfectly. That describes my growing conditions to a T

    Mike

  • 13 years ago

    I've never had grow lights, Nick, and I have a greenhouse for the wintertime, so someone else should be able to answer that question. I know at least a couple of us here have grow lights, but I don't know the specifics of setting one up or the hours of light needed, or about the closeness of the bulbs to the plants. Searches of forum posts about grow lights might help you out. Sun-loving plants can really struggle inside during the winter and get etiolated and ugly, so most who have to do that try to cut back on water as much as possible in order to keep growth barely going but at the same time slow it enough that plants don't stretch out horribly and become depressing-looking. It's a balance I'm glad I don't have to deal with. A positive: Aeoniums aren't total sun lovers like, say, Echeveria, and they're not the toughest to overwinter inside and keep chugging along with decent, healthy growth (in my experience, A. 'Kiwi' does like some sun, though, or more in comparison to my other A.s, and prefers spring and early summer in comparison to winter's dwindling sun). There are pros and cons to winter-growers-- I know I look forward to the growth that happens on a lot of my winter-growers, but if I had to have all of them inside the house, getting nice growth would be a struggle.

    This post was edited by teatree on Thu, Jun 27, 13 at 0:12

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks all who chimed in.

    Xerophyte and Meyermike, seems there's a bit of common sense involved with growing succulents, nice that it's not just a science.

    Teatree, thanks for the suggestion. Growlights don't seem to use too much electricity and be difficult to install, so I'll give it a shot this winter and report my findings.

  • 13 years ago

    Re: grow lights - yes, there are lots of excellent lighting options for the winter doldrums. But for good growth, the difficult part is getting the temperatures cool enough especially at night. Indoors at room temperature is not that good. I find it better to try and keep most succulents as cold as possible in the winter so as to stop growth completely. No growth may be better than weak/ poor growth. It's also a heck of a lot easier to keep plants in a cellar or garage for months at a time than finding space in the house!

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for the advice, I'll try it out this winter and make it a learning experience...

    Best, Nick