Software
Houzz Logo Print
bjmccoy_gw

Problems

20 years ago

Hello,

I live in Lake County California and have been beating my brains out about our soil.

We have tried to grow a vegetable garden, roses, flowers, and nothing seems to grow good.

The vegetable garden seems to grow to a degree but not much produce, it seems stunted and the roots won't go down very far. When we water real good we can take a shovel and dig after a little while and it's wet down just a few inches and then its dry. Water also seems to want to run off easy.

When we till, the soil becomes loose and fine then hits a hardpan, and compacts back up after its watered.

I have heard there is a lot of serpentine soil in this area. I don't know if that's what we have or not.

The dirt has a reddish color to it, in most areas of our property, in some, not many,it has a gray color.

Would gypsum help, and if so how much do we add. Do we till it in or what?

If you know of any amendments or anything we could add or do I would appreciate any help you might have.

Thank you,

B. McCoy

Comments (11)

  • 20 years ago

    You could try gypsum and puhLENTY of compost. I'd put in at least 6 inches of compost every 6 months... then, when it gets half good, start lasagna gardening. The way you are describing your soil, it sounds like it has no organic material in it at all... which also causes the soil to a) compact and b) the water runs right off it. If you don't add organic material, the soil will never get better.

  • 20 years ago

    Well, it might be easier to make raised beds -- you'll improve the drainage, have a better and deeper soil mix, plus you won't have to bend over so much!

  • 20 years ago

    Compost, compost and more compost. Don't ya love California soil :-) I've had the same problem.

    Edna

  • 20 years ago

    You have wonderful red clay, one of the nutrient rich soils that made California famous. Gypsum will not help,compost will but it will take a few years to transform your clay into really good garden soil. Your area with blue or gray clay is without oxygen or vegetative matter and probably also has a sour smell to it. Both of your clays will need very careful timing of your digging to be able to incorporate the compost into the soil. Digging when too wet will make the soil into odd shaped bricks. Digging when too dry will be impossible. If you water during the dry season, about 2 or 3 days later you should be able to dig. Once the rainy season starts you will have to wait until it lets up in the spring to get the right moisture to dig. Don't give up on your soil it just needs help, not hauling away. Al

  • 20 years ago

    Clay has some wonderfull advanteges like it will retain moisture for a long time, I only water a couple of times a year. I do amend with compost and will be adding some manure and topsoil to the front this year dut that is because I will be removing an old lawn. Lots of compost and time is the best thing for clay.

  • 20 years ago

    There is another way to fix clay soil. It is called sand. For some reason, even the mention of this induces hysteria in many people. I've been using sand for 40 years to fix clay soil, and it has always worked for me. And it has been used by gardeners since gardening began. And it is a major ingredient in commercial "topsoil" mixes.

    If you Google "soil triangle", you will find that the difference between clay soil and sandy loam soil is sand. The soil triangle is not some New Age fad; it is part of classic soil science as taught in agriculture schools. However, there are certain types of clay soil that can't be fixed with sand. You should consult your local agricultural extension agent or similar expert to find out more. If you can't find a local expert, I would recommend doing a test on a limited piece of ground, say a few square yards, and see if you like the outcome.

    The great thing about sand is that it is immediate and permanent. If you decide to use sand, you will have to add quite a bit; I would start by adding a couple of inches of sand, and tilling it in deep. A sprinkling of sand won't do a thing for you. And there is no point in trying to till hard clay. You will have to water deeply and wait for the soil to be workable, before you attempt to till the sand in.

    Many crops will grow on clay, but almost everything will grow on sandy loam. People who put up with clay because of this fear of sand are missing out on the wonderful experience of gardening in sandy loam soil. Once you have amended the soil with sand, you can then add lots of compost, and your soil will get even better. There is nothing wrong with compost, but it cannot take the place of sand. Any soil shown on the soil triangle can be made without compost, but that doesn't mean that compost is bad.

    I really hope that readers with clay soil will try adding sand on a small test plot, and find out for themselves whether it will work for them. I wish I could invite everyone to my garden, to show them what a pleasure it is to garden in sandy loam.

    If your water table is too high, or if your soil is salty or toxic, neither sand nor compost is going to help you. You need local advice in this case.

  • 20 years ago

    My friend added sand to his clay soil and got bricks.

    My experience is that organic material really helps. Now's a great time to acquire leaves, leaves break down nicely and wil help your soil a lot. Wood chips can be acquired from some tree services for free (call around) if you're willing to take a whole truckload. Wood chips break down pretty fast and also help make nice soil. I've also added newspapger ala lasagna gardening.

    In the meantime, maybe you could plant things that can grow in clay and plant your veggie garden in a rasied bed.

  • 20 years ago

    We used to add sand to clay when I was a kid... and got sandy cement. Then we started adding compost and things got way better

  • 20 years ago

    Compost, compost, and more compost. And patience. Good soil is not "instant"; it can take years.

  • 20 years ago

    At my Portland place, I amended my heavy clay loam soil with sand in 1988. I can go out in the yard right now and dig a 3" deep hole with my bare hand and plant a tulip bulb. The soil was ready for planting the instant that I had tilled the sand in, and it is still ready for planting. So, you have a choice: either spend years trying to fix the problem with massive amounts of compost, or buy some sand and solve the problem in a few hours. I lived in San Leandro for six years, and sand worked beautifully on that soil. So not all California soils are hopeless. But remember what I said in my first post: sand does not solve all clay problems. It's up to you to find out if it works for you.

    bjmccoy, if you visit the Portland, Oregon area, email me, and I will be glad to show you what I am talking about.

  • 20 years ago

    You need useful local info.

    Try this pdf about the Lake County Serpentine Landscape Demonstration Garden.
    http://ucce.ucdavis.edu/files/filelibrary/1271/17439.pdf

    Here is a link that might be useful: Lake County Serpentine Landscape Demonstration Garden

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting