Software
Houzz Logo Print
amccour

Soft-feeling Astrophytum.

17 years ago

A while back I made a post about scales/mealines on some pachypodiums and an astrophytum I have. I managed to take care of the pachypodiums (I think. I don't see any bugs, though the leaves don't look great. Would that just be winter dormancy?) but the astrophytum was being more problematic.

Last Friday, I removed it from the soil and noticed a TON of mealies on the underside of it. Since then, it's been depotted as I've been working on getting them removed. We'll see if that worked. Now that I know where they were coming from, I think I might have gotten them.

Anyway, though, I noticed that the body of the cactus is feeling rather soft. Not mushy like rot, per se, but sort of... hollow? It still has *tension* too it. It's not *squishy*. But it yields to pressure, although it returns to its original shape when I release pressure and it does take a decent amount of pressure to get it to yield.

I'm tending to think that it's dried out a bit over the weekend and what I'm seeing is water loss. I don't really see anything that looks like rot (the underside of the cactus is yellow, but I'm pretty sure that's normal because every globular cactus I have looks pretty similar in that respect).

Any ideas?

Comments (9)

  • 17 years ago

    My A. asterias shrink at this time of the year, so it could be normal, even if "over the weekend" sounds a little fast.

    Has your plant behaved like this before (or is it a new plant)?

  • 17 years ago

    I got it in April.

    "My A. asterias shrink at this time of the year, so it could be normal"

    That seems plausible. I hadn't really had a chance to squeeze it much till I depotted it so it might've been softer before. It DOES look sort of shrunken.

    Anyway, right now, since I don't have any potting mix or a clean pot for it (not putting it back in the old one for obvious reasons), I wrapped the roots in a damp paper towel. Not sure if this is necessary or a good idea or what.

    I'm trying to keep the actual body of the cactus dry, as there are some spots of damage from where the mealies had congregated really heavily.

  • 17 years ago

    I would leave the roots bare until you find something to pot it in. A. asterias is very sensitive to rot, and it is best to leave them to heal (no water) for at least a week after removing the soil. After potting they should not be watered for a long time, especially now during the resting period. I once lost a plant despite that I waited for a month before watering (lightly). During the growing period (which is when I prefer to repot them, I lose more plants if I do it in autumn/winter) about 14 days seems enough, but there is always a risk with asterias.

  • 17 years ago

    Okay, I think I might have some rot now. I left it sitting for a couple of weeks.

    http://img245.imageshack.us/i/dscf2871q.jpg/
    http://img98.imageshack.us/i/dscf2873.jpg/

    That's the spot where the mealies were the absolute worst. I can't really remember if I'd watered it recently or not, although if I had, the plant would've only been in soil for like a day or two before I noticed the mealies underneath it and depotted. The blackish spot is soft, but... more empty feeling than mushy, I guess?

    http://img204.imageshack.us/i/dscf2869.jpg/

    There's also this weird orange spot that's been on it since I got it, although it's kind of grown. It seems like it's strictly in the skin though.

    http://img255.imageshack.us/i/dscf2874.jpg/

    Picture of the rest of the underside. I don't see anything majorly problematic myself.

    Anyway, is surgery in order, and if so, any advice on how I should make the cuts?

  • 17 years ago

    This plant is almost certainly a goner. The first picture clearly shows an injury at ground level. There is scarring, black rotted areas, discoloration, and shrinkage. Some cacti can rot down completely without showing any signs of obvious distress, leaving only an empty shell.

    The only hope is to transect the plant above the rot in thin slices cutting towards the apex. You have to keep cutting until there is no dark colored fungal infection seen in the cross section. I suspect this will leave you with only a small amount of healthy cactus. Since it will take some time (months) to grow new roots again, I doubt there will be enough healthy tissue and water reserves left to stay alive until roots develop.

    There is nothing lost in trying to save it, but my experience says that is unlikely.

    Brad

  • 17 years ago

    The rot wasn't particularly pervasive; however the rotted section was awkwardly shaped so I had to take off more tissue than I would have liked, as well as the roots which, while looking mostly okay okay, were right next to the rotted area and probably infected anyway. Posting pics of what I got left in a second. I'm estimating I've got about 2/3 of the plant left.

    http://img62.imageshack.us/i/dscf2875.jpg/
    http://img42.imageshack.us/i/dscf2876.jpg/

    Should I dust it with rooting compound or something to help prevent against rot while the cut callouses over (cinnamon?)

    Also the cut is sort of lopsided, as I tried to take off less on the side that wasn't rotted. Will this matter?

  • 17 years ago

    There is more of it left than I would have thought, although I am concerned that the reddish tissue remaining is fungus in the vascular system. If that is the case, you will need to continue cutting towards to apex.

    Rooting hormone isn't a bad idea. It will have a fungicide in it, and may get roots started earlier. Cinnamon works well as an anti-fungal agent. Dust with either while the cut is still wet. Since the plant would normally go dormant over the winter, rooting may not even start until next year.

    I would probably cut a little more, and straighten up the angle of cut to perpendicular with the direction of growth, and then dust with Rootone. However, that may not help at this point, and may harm the chances of recovery. I'm sorry I can't give more certain advice.

  • 17 years ago

    I went ahead and dusted it with Rootone. I'm not cutting anymore till I can get another opinion. The red stuff you're talking about doesn't go in very far, though, so it should only take a couple of millimeters to get rid of it if I need to.

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, you must remove the red tissue completely, including at least a few mm extra as the outermost part of the infected volume does not need to be discoloured. I could be deeper than you think, believe me ...
    When I have plenty of healthy tissue above the infection I cut until the tissue is completely green (sterilizing the knife between each cut), then I cut away 2 cm more.

Sponsored
Buckeye Basements, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars40 Reviews
Central Ohio's Basement Finishing ExpertsBest Of Houzz '13-'21