I bought a plant of "Peaches and Cream" last year, and when I posted my fabulous "Peaches and Cream" bloom on another site, I was told and shown that it was more likely "Seattle" therefore, the big box store did mislabel. It does happen, but . . . all 5? I'm a fan of Duet, but wouldn't want an entire garden of it. I don't generally buy big box store dahlias, I buy my tubers one at a time from either dahlia club sales or from people that specialize in growing dahlias. But even dahlia growers and clubs make mistakes . . . it happens! When I helped package dahlias for my club this year, I learned just how easy it is to mislabel!