Software
Houzz Logo Print
carmen_grower_2007

Different method of seed starting

18 years ago

I thought this was very interesting but haven't done it myself. I prefer to just plant my seeds in the ground and let them grow. Still many of you might get a kick out of trying it.

Here is a link that might be useful: On the Rocks

Comments (87)

  • 18 years ago

    Oh Bambi!!!!!!!! The seed fairy came today, and she was VERY generous!!!! Oh my goodness... I better make these work, because they seem like beautiful crosses.

    Thank you so much!!!!!!!!!

  • 18 years ago

    For those who don't want to use high powered chemicals to stop the mold and white flies - the hydrogen peroxide you use to soak the seeds in would accomplish the same function as the NO-Damp - it has mild antiseptic properties and if diluted (as in a few drops in the water) will not hurt anything.
    And I love the experiments!
    Renee

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Renee,

    You seen to know a little something about hydrogen peroxide. I hope you don't mind if I pick your brain a little here?

    Would you happen to know why the sprout growth that occurred while in a 1:9 peroxide to water appears to be a yellowish beige versus the clean white appearance on the growth that has occurred subsequently? It almost gives them a scorched look. So far it seems no harm done, just a 'looks' thing, but I know that leaving them in the peroxide too long will eventually kill them.

    I used the 1:9 ratio because it has been proven the most effective. Higher, lower or no peroxide has been proven less effective. Just a little concerning when you see the results on the sprouts.

    Thanks, Marianne

  • 18 years ago

    I might offer this bit of info...roots need oxygen to survive and if they stay submersed in the hydrogen peroxide...it is the equivalent of drowning them. Just my 2 cents worth!

    I too am enjoying this thread...I am a newbie to DL and have about 200 seeds coming from Lily Auction in about 2 weeks. I really want to get it right the first time...ha ha if that is possible!! I will be trying the Captan as I have used it in my rose propagation.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi I was going to keep out of this one but found it amusing
    .like carmen I have been doing this for many years ,have never reg. any or sold any as its a hobby to me,I have given a lot of seeds and plants away. The two best methods that I use is one the soak method ,1 teaspoon of bleach to 1 gal of water soak seeds in water for 1 to 5 days as most of my seeds will sprout by then my ger. rate is generly about 90 to 95%this way ( bleach will only stay in water about 24 to 48 hours I found this out by raising trop. fish)The other like carmen says plant them in the ground or in pots or outside when the weather gets mild enough to plant.Up here sometimes in May.I tried many other methods but these two work the best, remember what one person likes another may not.

  • 18 years ago

    Lady Bug 2 U 2, What is the Captan?

  • 18 years ago

    Hello:

    That might have been a bit too much peroxide. I usually use a capfull (probably about 1/2 a teaspoon) in a cup of water, soak the seeds until I see the white root begin to emerge in a couple or 3 of the seeds which is usually 4 or 5 days, then plant all of them in a seed starting potting soil mix. I completely soak the potting soil with water first, and then use the rest of the seed soaking water w/peroxide over the seeds. I've had no problem with that amount of peroxide harming the seeds or the baby roots and I never have any problem with mold or white flies in my seedlings.

    Hope this helps,
    Renee

  • 18 years ago

    Hi beaufort-2006

    I think there are pros and cons to every method available. Each of us ends up with the method that suits us. Our available time, our access to seeds, our climate and even our personality all become considerations.

    Both you and carmen have been at this for a while and you have already found what works for you given the above considerations. However, as a beginner I am still working that out for myself - rather publicly perhaps, but I want to try a variety of things before I settle down into something that I can define as 'my method'. At risk is my public embarrassment for any failures but it may help someone if for no other reason than to show them what NOT to do. :)

    Based on what I know about myself and my climate, I know that poking the seeds into the ground is something that I can't do right now. First, I'm much to curious about what's happening; and second, I have a very short growing season, about 140 frost free days - which I'm sure is enough to give a daylily seed enough time for some decent growth but we have very fast weeds here (because of the short grow season) and they would soon overwhelm any seedling.

    Right now this method satisfies my curiosity, it fills the bleary winter months with some green and something to look forward to, it gives my seedlings a jump on the weeds, it allows me to containerize small groups of seeds in a small amount of space, and gosh-darnit! its FUN! :)

    Renee - I selected the 9 water to 1 peroxide ratio based on testing experiments that I believe were done by Sue Bergeron, Scientist & Horticulturalist. You can see her tests at the bottom of this message. While I find the discoloration unappealing, so far it does not seem to have harmed the seeds and they were only soaked for 24 hours.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Sue's seed germination experiments

  • 18 years ago

    Another consideration should be the cross itself. On Jan 5, 2008 an auction closed (on the Lily Auction) for $259 for 6 seeds. Believe it or not, this was the cross of two unregistered seedlings. As it happens they were two of Bob Faulkner's seedlings so they were no ordinary seedlings.

    I wouldn't give a second thought to planting Stella X Frans Hals (because I could always make more, assuming I'd want to) outside in the dirt at the mercy of the weeds, the varmints and the weather BUT (and this won't change no matter how 'experienced' I get) if I were ever lucky enough to end up with seeds from a Bob Faulkner cross they would get my very best effort and attention to assure their success. That would also be true for any small amount of a premium cross that I couldn't duplicate in my own garden at will.

  • 18 years ago

    A thought about damping off. With this method, I think you wouldn't have a problem since the seeds are not actually in the water. I have never had a damping off problem in the plants (tomatoes/peppers/other perennials) I start indoors, but I also make sure they are never soggy.

    I have nothing against anyone trying this method -- in fact, I first called your attention to the creative link. My personal new and exciting project this year is Winter Sowing, so we all like to experiment.

    BTW, I sure would love to see what $259 for 6 seeds brings the purchaser in 2-3 years!

  • 18 years ago

    Yippee!! Can you see it? Can you see it?

    Day 10 - First sprout is on Fairy Tale Pink x Unk:
    {{gwi:673844}}

    The Seedfairy came to my house and went crazy dropping off seeds!

    {{gwi:673846}}

    So I tried a few of them with this new method, and some the other. The crosses are so nice I am afraid to loose any. Ack! How do you people do it for things like 'Blue Hippo'? I feel like a mother hen. I already go to bed thinking of them....

    {{gwi:673848}}

    {{gwi:673850}}

  • 18 years ago

    Wow Fairysoapgirl! I would not have thought it possible that you would get a sprout from those seeds. I even had to scroll back up to look at your original photos again. They didn't look any better to me tonight than they did earlier this week. I really thought it was hopeless.

    Fantastic seeds you've received! Somebody sure likes you a lot. Those are as good as most and better than lots of seeds that are sold on the Lily Auction.

    I have added today's pictures to my webpage but I am also going to try to include one picture here;

    {{gwi:673852}}

    These are 3 seeds on Day 5 of my third test run.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Third test

  • 18 years ago

    I have a question. This is my first time growing DL from seed and I was so happy (I posted a few times) and now I have about 65 out of 90 seed that have germinated but they are not greening up like the seeds you have pictured or sprouting at all. Am I doing something wrong? I did through two seeds out that were brown inside and squishy. Icky. My seed buds are not turning black like the ones in the other picture but some have been germinated 8 days and they are not greening up. Now I will tell you what I am doing so hopefully you can tell me what to stop or change. I have them all together in a glass bowl with glass lid, on a heating pad, and under grow lights. The mix was water, peroxide, dish soap, and a Neem oil fungicide. Maybe the missing ingredient is patience. Please tell me that nothing is wrong and I just need to wait.

  • 18 years ago

    I think you need to get rid of the peroxide. It can damage the embryo.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi moongardengirl,

    I agree with okbt, I think the peroxide is the problem.

    The first seeds I ever received from the Lily Auction came with instructions (she must have realized that I was a beginner because I didn't have any feedback score at the time). She told me to use water, peroxide, soap and bleach. Then I was supposed to wait for something that looked like a dorsal fin before planting. I followed her formula to the letter and I did get some initial root buds. Then I waited and waited for that dorsal fin (which it turns out was the green mini-fan) but after 2 weeks, nothing. So I potted them into soil. Then I waited and waiting another 2 weeks (give or take) until I couldn't stand it anymore. I dug around in the dirt and they had rotted.

    If you followed the link I posted for Sue's germination test results I think she recommends that you remove the seeds from the peroxide immediately when you see the root bud. In fact, I think that's what blackened my seed roots, not the No Damp. I went back through my photos and the blackened root seeds came from container 'KLTB' which was the same container that had the root discoloration from the peroxide soak. These seeds had sprouted in the peroxide and they were only in there for 24 hours. The seeds that have sprouted 'since' the peroxide soak (yes, they soaked but did not sprout until after removal) are beautiful, clean, white roots and exactly what I want to see. I'm not even sure the peroxide soak is worthwhile to be honest but I thought I'd give it another try. So far I've lost more than I've gained from it.

    Can you drain or suction your solution off and replace it with plain water? How much growth do you have?

  • 18 years ago

    I have 60+ seeds with root buds. No green. No dorsal fin. Upon closer observation I think I do see a little brown tint. Some have been like this for a week or better. I did rinse the rocks till the water ran clean and then rinsed the seed. So we will see if that helps. So, how many days after the root bud shows will you see the dorsal fin? What is the soonest and what is the latest?

  • 18 years ago

    I never understood the whole peroxide or bleach thing to begin with. Why are you using it? In nature, the seeds go right into the ground with all of its pathogens and nasties.

    At first, I thought maybe people were using peroxide to hurry the process of getting the shell off the seeds. Maybe that is it, but still, not natural.

  • 18 years ago

    There does not appear to be a specific time line as each cross, and even seeds within the same cross, seem to decide themselves when they will germinate and how fast or slow they will grow. Each is an individual. I could ballpark it about 4-7 days but that would only be a guess.

    You've seen the container (BCSI) where 3 of 8 seeds have sprouted and already have fans within 7 days. Meanwhile a 4th seed has just budded and the remaining 4 seeds haven't sprouted at all yet. And they are the same cross so there's no way to tell for sure.

    I think you've done the best you can at this point. Are all 90 seeds the same cross? Your slow sprouters should be fine when they do sprout, and some of the younger sprouts may not have been affected. Where the buds above the water line? Again, I'm just guessing but I would think that any above the water line would only have been exposed to humidity rather than direct contact. I'm not sure how peroxide, neem oil or soap travel in humidity or even if they do.

  • 18 years ago

    Something else, I find this hard to do but you're going to have to get cutthroat with these seeds. I tend to take an optimistic 'wait and see' approach when I see things going bad but that has put my healthy sprouts at risk to the point where they couldn't be salvaged. With the KLTB container I should have removed all of the peroxide scorched seeds immediately and I could have saved about 50% of that cross. I waited too long.

    If you find it hard to immediately remove 'iffy' looking sprouts, start a second container to hold anything that's borderline. The very first time you see any browning (or mold, etc) REMOVE THE SEED and place into the second container. Don't let it/them contaminate the rest of your cross.

    While there are pros to this method during this third trial I've learned that the one HUGE con is cross-contamination (literally). Monitoring is key - get a magnifying glass if you have to.

  • 18 years ago

    carmen_grower,

    My understanding of the intent of additives (in tiny amounts) is as follows;

    peroxide - provides oxygen, speeds germination
    soap - emmoluant, seed coat softener
    bleach/neem oil - fungicide, retards mold growth

    I hope someone corrects me if I'm wrong.

    I've used dish soap & hot water on Iris seeds with some success. I think I've been totally scared off of peroxide.

  • 18 years ago

    Great thread. I started some in 2006 and got flowers last summer. Planted more winter of 2007, putting them in wet coffee filters inside baggies. Once they germinated, I potted them up in little cups and transplanted in my holding bed last summer. Some were from a generous Gardenbuddy, and other from the Daylily Auction. These are the ones I planted:
    Bat Masterson X Meet Joe Black Meet
    Joe Black X Border Music
    Meet Joe Black X Carribean Midnight Vespers
    Border Heritage X Montana Sky
    Big Kiss dbl Samantha Clair X Red Eyed Fantasy
    Dbl Apricot - cream bee
    Potion for Passion X Pure Indulgence
    Sanford Show Girl X Big Kiss
    Ed Brown X Classic Edge
    Classic Edge X John Peat
    Breaking with Tradition

    Hoping for some pretty flowers this summer.

  • 18 years ago

    Ok, from those shirveled little Fairy Tale Pink Seeds, I have gotten two to sprout out of six (1/3), one still looking possible(fat and firm)...

    Day 21
    {{gwi:673854}}

    {{gwi:673857}}

    I also put 1/2 the Tigger x Forestlake Ragamuffin seeds in the Rocks Method and 1 of 2 is sprouting. I can't see any sprouts through the planting medium from the other two seeds yet:

    {{gwi:673859}}

    I used the Rocks Method for Inchon x Unk, and have three out of 5 sprouting, two today and one I think day before yesterday (I was in NY):

    {{gwi:673860}}

    {{gwi:673862}}

    And three sprouts came up in the soiless medium. One is WAY ahead of the others, strangely. This is day 12 for these seedlings:

    {{gwi:673864}}

    {{gwi:673866}}

    {{gwi:673868}}

  • 18 years ago

    12 days?! That one took off! I may be wrong, but I'm looking at pictures of seedlings that were planted normaly, and seeing more green than on the ones that are "on the rocks"

  • 18 years ago

    Why you have the name you do, THANK YOU! We will enjoy!

  • 18 years ago

    I am impressed that she got those seeds to grow at all. The seeds planted 'normally' were beautiful plump seeds. Her 'rocks' seeds were some of the saddest looking things I ever saw. Scroll to the beginning and have a look at what she started with. Great photo of the crown skirting too. I am amazed! Good job Fairysoapgirl!

    One observation - your rocks are very tight, as in no gaps. If you look at my photo you will see the roots taking advantage of the gaps in the rocks to drop their roots down. You have one long root running across the surface because it couldn't find a way down. Make sure it doesn't dry out by keeping your container covered. As soon as the fan won't fit under the cover anymore, pot it up or plant it outside if the conditions allow.

  • 18 years ago

    I realize that but the INCHON X UNKNOWN seeds were fresh.

  • 18 years ago

    In fairness, this was never meant to be a race of the 'rocks' method against any and all other methods. It's just a different way of germination. It was never intended to satisfy everyone's preferences.

    But since you mentioned the timing, I now feel some need to defend it. We don't see any pictures of Inchon X Unknown other than the rocks photo so we don't really know (a) if there were seeds of the same cross planted normally, or (b) if so, are they showing green?

    The only cross she mentions splitting was the Tigger X Forestlake Ragamuffin - 2 seeds on the rocks and 2 seeds planted. One of two seeds on the rocks has sprouted. However, its possible that she's 2 for 2 on the planted seeds but there's no way to know that until they actually break the surface.

    That said, even within the same cross they do not all germinate at the same rate. Each seed is an individual. I have some seeds from the same pod sprout 10 days apart. I don't think it would have mattered to them what method was used they still would have germinated at different rates.

  • 18 years ago

    Oh yeah... sorry for the confusion.

    The FTP seedlings were very dry and shriveled... and they are on their 21st day.

    SOMEONE here gave me some great fresh seeds, and of those I tried (2 of 4)Tigger x Forestlake Ragamuffin and (5 of 5)Inchon x Unk on the Rocks. The traditionally planted seedlings are on the same schedule as the two crosses listed above (Day 12).

    I think the only cross I can compare is the Tigger cross, because I put two of the seeds on the rocks and two of them in the traditional planting medium. So far (because I can see into the cups for the rocks method), I can see the sprouts starting on one of the two Tigger x Forestlake Ragamuffin seeds. For the other two, I can't see below the planting medium, so I don't know what's going on in there! I think that is part of why I was drawn to this new method. I can SEE things growing! I guess it appeals to my instant gratification need. :o)

    It might be an unfair comparison to say that the other crosses did better due to the traditional soiless medium vs. rocks, because maybe those seeds/seedlings are just more vigorous? I didn't put any of the super-sprouted(Old King Cole x Ed Brown Sdlg) x Tet George Jets On)cross seeds on the Rocks, nor did I try any of the (Inchon x Unk) seeds the traditional way. So, I guess we'll have to rely on ol' Tigger!

    TTFN!

    I'll keep posting my findings on Rocks vs. Traditional, especially on the T x FR cross.

  • 18 years ago

    Sorry, 6 of 6 Inchon x Unk seeds (geesh, I can count)!

  • 18 years ago

    Oh no don't get me wrong, I find this topic really interesting, there is nothing to defend. In all honessty, I have seen some really extremes in germination and growth rates. I've seen seed germinate in 7 days, and it might have been less and I wasn't paying attention, and 60 plus days. That (OKC X EB) sdlg X TET GEORGE JETS ON really doesn't surprise me, both the parents are very vigorous.

    I have a bunch of Clivia seed on the way, and this technique looks like it will be a good one for that.

    I will be starting some Daylily seed this was as well, not for the experiance, I really want to photograph the germanating seeds. BTW all the photos have been very nice.

    Here is a photo of some Clivia seeds I started between damp paper towels.

    {{gwi:673870}}

  • 18 years ago

    GREAT photo!! Love the fuzzy root below the crown. Big variation in seed sizes at the top of the photo. I priced some Clivia seeds recently on eBay and they are very expensive. Someday I'll spend some time looking for a cheaper source and give them a shot too. The flowers are gorgeous.

  • 18 years ago

    There were some inexpensive Clivia seeds on Ebay, just keep watching. The seller named Cycads, offers some nice seed at reasonable prices. I purchased some Monk Clivia seeds from a Chinese seller for 60 cents to $1.00 a seed recently, and have ad no problems receiving seed from them in the past.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks bambi_too for the lead on the Clivia seeds. His(her?) auction says (s)he just ships to the US but I've emailed to see if (s)he will ship to Canada. Fingers crossed...

  • 18 years ago

    Speaking of Clivia - Bambi_too have you seen the ENORMOUS potted clivias at Gale's? Not on the table in the greenhouse section but on the floor. In tree sized pots.

  • 18 years ago

    Which Gales?I have never seen any at the one in Maple Heights.

  • 18 years ago

    The one on the corner of Chardon Road and SOM in Willoughby.

  • 18 years ago

    I went out there yesterday, and 2 of them followed me home, They are yellow too! I also got a smaller orange/red with a green throat, and green stripes on the sepals, the flowers are just opening now. I may go back out and get a couple more!

    Can_mj,

    Did Doug sell you any seeds? I just set some up like you are doing with the Daylily seeds.

    John

  • 18 years ago

    John congrats on snagging those Clivias! Weren't they just enormous? I loved the saturated yellow color. So rich. I didn't see the orange/red with green throat. We're so lucky to have Gale's and Bluestone so close.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi John,

    Yes, he did reply to me that he can ship to Canada. He also had some deep root tree pots listed at the time that I asked about and he answered my questions about them. Then, when I got back to his auctions the tree pots were gone but he had a lot of new seed auctions in their place.

    I've been waiting to see if the tree pots go back up but I think I may source them out locally. We have a Forestry School in the city and they have greenhouses for their silviculture work. I'm pretty sure I can get something from them and save some shipping costs.

    So, back to the clivia seeds. He has a gorgeous one with a big white throat but you only get 2 seeds and have to wait until next December... I went with Doug's Big Red - 10 seeds for $9. If I screw this up I don't want to lose too much money. :)

    I'm getting some great roots on my 'rocks' daylilies.

    {{gwi:673872}}

    But I've also gotten some real crappy roots. Actually, no roots at all and what I thought was crown rot, though I've never actually seen crown rot and just assumed that this must be it. Some of the others were actually worse than this. You've seen the pictures if you've been following my updates.

    {{gwi:673874}}

    I planted them anyway, and watered them thinking death would eventually take them but they didn't die. They continue to grow and thrive. I have no idea why they are doing so well (5 in total)and they've been in soil for about a week.

    {{gwi:673876}}

    Do you know what crown rot looks like? Shouldn't these seedlings be dead by now?

  • 18 years ago

    Those seeds from Dougs Best Red, grow into really robust seedlings, I may buy another group of them. I did e-mail him and let him now that it was not a problem to ship to anywhere but Austrailia.

    It looks like their feet were too wet too long, but the crown is still there and looks fine, it will grow new roots, do not over water them.

  • 18 years ago

    Some years ago, I still had some seed that had not been planted. Winter was on the way (mild here), but I was finding that some of the seed that I planted out was rotting before it germinated due to the colder conditions and probably too much water!
    I developed a similar method to "on-the-rocks" except that I used sterilized sphagnum moss (microwaved) and set out the containers under a flouro "Grow Light" covering them with cling wrap. I was getting about 95 per cent germination from memory. When they reached about 4 inches high I planted them on into little pots and when they had developed further, I planted them out into a seedling bed where they stayed until they flowered. I only used the method for a few years as I found it was too time consuming. Never-the-less there remains an advantage for anyone wanting to get a head start where there are serious winters
    These days IÂm still setting far too much seed!!!!! I plant them in batches of about 6/8 in small pots and later plant them on through black plastic that IÂve cut (on a 5 inch each way spacing) thus + (that is vertical and horizontal intersecting cuts which allow enough space for the developing fan/s. The beds are prepared with added pulverised cow manure and blood and bone fertilizer. The main reason for the plastic is weed control and it does a great job  love daylilies but cannot stand weeding!

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you can mj for keeping your progress public. I have found it very inspiring and would like to try this myself. I went to my local pizza shop today and bought a bag of those little containers and tomorrow I plan to go pick up some rocks.
    Just a few questions, where would the best place to purchase beginner seeds online. I have read of the auction and googled it. Is there certain buyers that anyone likes to purchase off of from that site?
    I am also going to go to a few places locally to see if I can pick some up but I did not find any at my local home depot, lowes and the nearest nursery to my home, so I will have to wander to the city.
    I realize that most seeds can get rather expensive, but I am looking for something that I can start out with incase I fail. I have lots to learn, I know, and I look forward to any advise that I can receive.
    Happy Gardening!
    Christie

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Christie,

    Glad to see that you're going to give it a shot. As for seeds, what would you like to grow? If its daylilies I would be very surprised if you were able to find any in your local stores. I have never seen them sold commercially. You would have to buy them on the Lily Auction or on eBay.

    I will post a link to one seller's store where you can go through the listings and see pictures of the two parents that he crossed to create the seeds.

    If you don't care about the parents your other option is to go for a mixed seed lot. Search '50 mixed daylily seeds' and you'll see a couple auctions that are still at $.99

    If you don't care what you're growing but just want to put something on the rocks to watch grow (this would make a great Grade 1 or 2 science project) I would be tempted to buy beans, peas, watermelon, pumpkin and/or corn. One of each would be fun to watch. :)

    Here is a link that might be useful: Lotsalilies on eBay

  • 18 years ago

    Hey bambi_too!

    Look what followed me home from a local nursery last night...

    {{gwi:673878}}

    It's my first Clivia and the first one I have ever seen locally. I don't know if its considered bad manners or not but I took pollen from other plants in the group and did a little dabbing before I left the greenhouse and paid at the cash. I wanted to make sure it goes to seed.

    {{gwi:673880}}

    I have no idea what kind it is - the tag only said African Clivia. Is it a good one? Any info you could provide would be greatly appreciated. If you need specs (height, width, etc) I can measure it when I get home.

  • 18 years ago

    Alright you two... you got my interest up, since I had no idea what you guys were talking about... I did some on-line research to find the plant AND I found one at a local nursery, but it was priced at $50! Is that normal?

  • 18 years ago

    It is a little high, I bought two like that (I went back yesterday), for $30.00, they are from Belgium. Is that from Idflor? There is a clivia forum here, lets take this over there. I will post photos of the yellows and orange ones I purchased there.

  • 18 years ago

    For those who may be interested...I called the company that distributes "Captan" fungicide and the rep told me the dilution rate for small amounts is: 1 Teaspoon to 1 Qt. water
    This can be used as a spray or drench. Hope this helps.

  • 18 years ago

    I am now just using plain water from my tap. I am on a well so no chlorine and my water does have a lot of iron. I am not pre-soaking. My last batch of 7 cups all had a minimum of one sprout per cup within 6 days. So far, no mold.

    {{gwi:673882}}

    One cup is 8 for 8 seeds sprouted. Every seed in this cup had sprouts by Day 4 and this photo is Day 7

    {{gwi:673884}}

    In another cup, one seed blew out through both ends of the seed. I don't think that's a good thing though. I don't like seeing the end turning brown and I don't know how this seed is able to nourish itself.

    {{gwi:673886}}

    In the same cup this seed shows the seed case skin that sometimes gets stuck on the end of a sprout. It seems to have affected how quickly the sprout is produced. Its much slower than the others

    {{gwi:673888}}

    This is a third cup. These two seeds split like others I had in Test 3. At the time I blamed it on the peroxide soak, thinking my water was too warm, but these seeds were not pre-soaked at all. These two seeds sprouted on Day 2 and they are the most robust sprouts I've had so far.

    {{gwi:673890}}

    I am running out of room indoors and there is still about 12" of snow on my gardens so I have to dial it back a little. I will continue to use this method over the summer and I will plant directly to outdoors. I've found that I can maintain the seedlings to 3-4" while still on the rocks and that's large enough to go directly outside under a shade cloth in June.

    {{gwi:673892}}

    {{gwi:673894}}

    I am looking at getting a new camera as well. It will have time lapse photography so I'm hoping to create one of those documentary-type films that show a seed sprout and grow over a period of a few seconds of film. Being able to document and share the progress has been the greatest reward of this method.

    I am delighted with the photos submitted by others. Please keep them coming. It's fascinating to watch!

    Marianne

    Here is a link that might be useful: On The Rocks Germination

  • 18 years ago

    I do not know what I did wrong but my seeds have mold on them after attempting this method :(

    Any suggestions as to what I should do?
    I bought the seeds off ebay and waited to leave feedback in case something wrong happened. Is it something that I did or are there such things as bad seeds?

    {{gwi:673896}}

    {{gwi:673896}}

    {{gwi:673898}}

  • 18 years ago

    First of all, they can get mould on them and still be good, clean them off. This is one of the possible problems with this method, if there are mould spores in the air you amy be providing them with the perfect place to grow.

    They may be bad infertile seeds. I would wait before contacting the seller. Did they all get mouldy?

    Did you get them from the person Marianne put the link up for?

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting