Software
Houzz Logo Print
whaas_5a

Your first days as a conifer nerd

16 years ago

I'd consider myself a decidious tree nerd and I've really neglected conifers in my current landscape.

I have the chance to start fresh and I want to set a base of tough, durable conifers.

I know most of you here are conifer nerds so hopefully you can think back to the early days and recommend a few basics for a fellow decidious tree nerd.

Helpfull info:

- Most areas are full sun, some are part sun

- Neutral to slightly alkaline soil, lots of field stone (range from 2" to 2').

- Entire lot is on a slight hill, so it will get dry

Plants that are readily available (and cheap) in my area

Pinus strobus

Picea glauca

Pinus nigra

Picea abies

Picea pungens

Are there any from above you'd recommend? Or any others that won't cost an arm and a leg? I plan to plant 4-5 groupings of 3. I have no issues with repeating a grouping if they are superior.

The bigger the better...disease resistance, wind tolerance, drought tolerance, fast growth would be a bonus...wait did I just describe the perfect plant?

Pinus strobus is the most attractive IMO. Not a big fan of Picea abies mature, droppy branches.

Comments (16)

  • 16 years ago

    Pinus strobus does have a beautiful sound as it shuffles in the wind. You have a million options whaas... I wouldn't even know where to begin.

    Forget nigra... it's a disease tree in your area. They're dying everywhere in the Mid-west. Heldreichii/lecucodermis is the best substitute.

    Canaan fir. That grows fast. Nice blue cones. It's a hybrid of fraseri and balsamea.

    Abies balsamea is an excellent conifer for your area.

    Picea's: pungens will provide you with many years of healthy plants - but is more-suited to dry/non-humid climates.

    Green Giant arbs and Thuja occidentalis Hetz Wintergreen are the fast ones. Don't mess with Thuja plicata...

    There's a start.

    Dax

  • 16 years ago

    aren't you moving ..???

    where to???

    if you really want to get the bug .... total nerd-dom ...

    you will need to find a supplier other than bigboxstore .... or the local nursery ... perhaps we can refer you to arb's or peeps worth a drive to go see ...

    i would say.. that 100 of mine came mail order ... small one gals .....

    and in MI i have access to a lot of grafters/specialty sellers ...

    as a collector.. i recommend every single one on your list ... go figure on that ...

    and unless you have over 20 acres.. i would stay away from most species... as they grow 1 to 3 feet per year.. and will quickly fill up a small space ....

    have i referred you to the general conifer intro ??? .. no time to waste.. check the link .. and learn about ANNUAL GROWTH RATES .... its my prime way of knowing when a plant is fully established.. that first year.. it grows to or beyond expectation ...

    ken

    Here is a link that might be useful: link

  • 16 years ago

    If you're a nerd you better start spelling it deciduous. Delectable or stunning grafted conifers offered at outlets here still get looked over but as these are often quite apparently grafted on deformed roots I usually pass them by.

    Still don't like to buy "expensive" plants either. Last grafted conifer I bought, for 35 dollars plus tax in the gallon pot had roots that looked like a braided ponytail being held up on the end to form a u shape.

    Where there is room plant seedlings of conifer species instead.

    Where there is room.

  • 16 years ago

    I would also throw a couple of deciduous confers into the mix as well: Taxodium distichum (Baldcypress), Metasequoia glyptostroboides (Dawn Redwood), Larix laricina (Tamarack), Larix kaempferi (Japanese larch) or Larix decidua (European larch). There are some very nice cultivars of these plants, as well.

    Larix kaempferi 'Diana' is one of my favorites, with its twisted/contorted branches. It is especially nice during the winter when the needles have fallen.

  • 16 years ago

    bboy- I'll never forget the day you said to me, 'Abies bornmuelleriana is sometimes used as scionwood by grafters when they run out of wood...' I guess that'll never leave my mind.

    My thoughts ealier today are on Mike's lines:
    Taxodium distichum Shawnee Brave/'Michelson' (3) of them.
    and a few golden Larches (3) for fall color... species of Larix I'd used are:
    principis-rupprechtii
    mastersiana (I don't think anybody sells these...) maybe they do.
    kaempferi

    Dax

  • 16 years ago

    Hmmm...I should probably narrow this down by priority.

    For the back lot line I'm looking to screen out a house. I'm up on a hill with a full walk-out basement so I'd need something that gets a min. 40' tall. I plan to stay in this home for a long time, so I want something thats durable, I just don't want to wait 20 years to get a 20' plant.

    As a few of you mentioned I plan to add deciduous trees later down the road...in fact in front of the evergreens.

    In the end if someone held a gun to your head and said "look here you tree nerd, tell me about three evergreen types you'd plant to block out that ugly house over there?" "They need to be durable, drought tolerant, fast to moderate growth rate and they shouldn't exceed 25' in width, unless they don't mind a little shade." "Did I mention its dry and there is alot of field stone?"

    I've seen Pinus strobus planted in a grove like application and it looks nice, even though I don't think they like partial shade where they touch.

  • 16 years ago

    I would offer my neighbour a few boxloads of fast_growing evergreen Ivy-cuttings ,for him to plant against his ugly house. I would also advise him to water regularly with concentrated lawn-fertiliser. T.

  • 16 years ago

    strobus in mi ... grows like a weed ... and has terrible problems at this time ...

    i bought one gal wallyworld plants.. and in 2 years.. they were growing 3 to 5 feet per year ... one got ice storm damage.. and one got borers ... and the 2 left were removed ... as i didnt know then.. what i knew when they got cut down ... misplaced ...

    regardless ... diversify ...

    picea pungens also have problems in the very long run ...

    larch.. though deciduous ... grow 3 to 5 to 7 feet per year ... the specie versions

    do you have a pic of the new house area we are speculating about... or are you not there yet???

    still Milwaukee???

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    I think the Abies bornmuelleriana observation must have come from somebody else.

  • 16 years ago

    Nope it was you Ron. Ron_B. Probably 7-8-9 years ago.

    Dax

  • 16 years ago

    I'll tell you one thing, I'm struggling a bit here with selecting some plants. To be honest the only nice looking "mature" evergreens I see around here are Scotts Pine and Eastern White Pine.

    I was looking to get at least the back lot line plants in within 2 weeks.

    I'm going to be about 25 miles NW of Milwaukee.

    This pic might help, as you can see (hopefully) the entire lot is on a slight hill.

    {{gwi:836786}}

  • 16 years ago

    Scots Pine, Pinus sylvestris, will suffer just like Pinus nigra around here. Pinus cembra do well as do Pinus koraiensis. Talk to the folks at Johnson's Nursery about cembra, I beleive they introduced a few cultivars. Other pines to look at are Pinus parviflora, flexilis and peuce but all the pines I've mentioned here will not really be speed growers. I'd certainly look into Picea omorica as it will take sun (for now) or some shade (for later). The variable catch-all cultivar 'Pendula' is available locally and reasonably priced and may suite your needs. Picea abies are tough as nails and that droopiness you mention does vary from plant to plant. Personally, I like strobus in the wild but not in the landscape in southern WI. The nice ones you see here happened to be the few that lived and look good. Many more were cut down when folks tired of them. Even if you get one that stays nice, odds are the bottom branches will be gone eventually and you'd lose the screening. The main thing, as Ken mentioned, is to diversify.

    As for places to look, you know the Milwaukee area nurseries but also check out Garden of Eder near Franksville or take a trip to the Janesville Rotary Gardens or to Rich's Foxwillow Pines in Woodstock, Illinois. All are good for hatching ideas and being strong enablers.

    tj

  • 16 years ago

    Good suggestions! Looks like your a big fan of Pinus.
    I should be able to track down a couple from that list.

    Any other Picea I should go after?
    If not should I focus on, lets say two from the lsit below?
    Picea orientalis, glauca, abies or pungens

    Its looking like I should eliminate Pinus sylvestris, strobus and nigra?

  • 16 years ago

    A big fan of pines? No more than spruces or chamaecyparis or firs or... Mind you, my personal experience is with dwarf and miniature conifers (other than my declining 60 year old nigras). The declining specie Scots and, to a lesser degree, White Pines are ones I see around the metro area. You may be able to do ok with strobus if they suit your fancy. Looks like you'll have the room for them. BTW, I've focused on the screening, specimen plants are another story and I'd go with 3 varieties for the screen. What kind of space are you allowing for the screen and have you thought of smaller plants closer to the house to use as screening?

    tj

  • 16 years ago

    For the evergreens, I want to mix in multiple varieties for the back lot line. Its about 150' wide and I don't want the evergreens to take more than 25-30' in depth...around here that could mean 20-40 years. Sure I want to plant for the future generations but I need some value as well.

    I plan on looking into more speciman type plants, and screening near the deck at a later date but I want to focus on setting the "foundation" at the back lot line.

    The tough, basic plants is what I'm after.

    Looks like Picea abies is one...not sure where to go beyond that.

  • 16 years ago

    I've not had trouble with Picea omorika and P. glauca are native to northern WI. The non-Alberta type cultivars of glauca I have ('Cecilia', 'Pendula' and 'Burning Well') have been no trouble. I wouldn't rule out Thuja occ. or Tsuga can. either as they are native even further south than glauca.

    tj