Software
Houzz Logo Print
beckyinrichmond

Slate article today

16 years ago

Thought you all would be interested in reading this article on canning that's in Slate today.

Here is a link that might be useful: Slate article

Comments (12)

  • 16 years ago

    I hardly know what to say. Sort of reduces our efforts to improve our diets and preserve the literal fruits of our labors to nothing more than a passing fancy. Tell that to the people with enough food preserved and put-by to feed their families until the next crop comes in. Or who augment their food budgets with "condiments" they have canned so their grocery budget is more manageable. Or who can't abide the crappy quality of Winter produce, but can turn to their own pantry and enjoy something that not only tastes like real food, but like summer. I am certainly not on the level of some of the people on this forum, but canning and preserving is certainly is not the latest food trend in my house!

    Steve

  • 16 years ago

    Trendy, huh? It sure helps the budget trying to live on ol' Social Security.

    Steve - "Well said."

    Bejay

  • 16 years ago

    I read it a bit differently and didn't take offense at what was said. I'm also allowing for the brevity of the article, which can't possibily do justice to the nuances of home food preservation at its many levels.

    From my perspective, the Slate article acknowledges that there always has been a sub-set of home food preservers who can, pickle, root cellar, etc. for very practical reasons. I particularly appreciated the acknowledgement that there are many women of a previous generation who found canning (for good reason) very hard labor, and while appreciative of the benefits, do not regard it with the enthusiasm of some of those new to canning.

    I think the Slate article clearly differentiates between "boutique" canners and those who come from a different tradition where canning is regarded as an essential (if not always enjoyable) tool of home food management.

    The article is absolutely right that canning is not always economical, especially for those new to the process who are buying canning supplies from scratch and may also be buying rather than growing or gleaning their produce.

    It takes a sustained commitment to this kind of food preservation for it to ink out. There are, of course, other benefits, including the comfort of knowing the chain of production from ground to lips and the sheer satisfaction of a certain self-sufficiency.

    Carol

  • 16 years ago

    Oh, I think I've got the best of both worlds -- "boutique" and practical.

    Hey, I can put up 400 quarts of stuff in a year. That doesn't mean it can't be fancy.
    My anise flavored candied baby figs from last fall sure are good now. Not canned, of course, but packed in extremely heavy syrup in freezer containers. Taste like licorice gumdrops.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for posting the link to the article. I started canning as a subset to my need to cook from scratch. The canning helps me better control what chemicals are or are not in my food.

    Yes, it would be cheaper if I grew or foraged the food for myself, but that is not currently an option. On the other hand, prices are really cheap at peak times and I can buy baskets of in-season produce for a fraction of what I pay even a few weeks later.

    Canning - or I should say food preservation - has really sharpened up my awareness of the seasonality of food too. I've gone from knowing what is seasonal to having a much better idea of when it will be on sale AND in season.

    It's not an activity for everyone, but I do enjoy the end product. Maybe today I'll open up a jar of brandied peaches and enjoy the taste of last summer. Of course, if it's 60 degrees again today, that won't be quite as necessary as when it was snowing out!

  • 16 years ago

    I think it's written for the urban audience, and supposed to be a little tongue-in-cheek. However, I detect a faintly patronising attitude. Not that what she is saying doesn't hold some truth. Food preservation is a popular fad now, as is home gardening. When the public attention gets redirected to another cause many of the novice canners and gardeners shall lose interest after having invested some serious money in jars, canners and other equipment.

    But, I also think she has made the oft-times false assumption that just because this is what canning looks like in her world, that is what it looks like in the much larger rest of the world.

    I used to can fruits years ago, when I had to drive from the capitol city clear back home here, to buy fruit at an orchard. Can we say it was dirt cheap compared to already canned commerical fruits, and even cheaper in comparison to the bagged fruits in markets. It was cost effective for me even then.

    It's cost effective for anyone who has a larger home garden. Period. Wasted food is negative income as far as I'm concerned. Despite all the novice canners and gardeners who do try it and leave, there will be a substantial number who have liked the experience and continue to do it over a life-time.

    I can because my mother canned and I saw the benefit. My children can (both my daughter and my son) because I canned and they saw the benefit. Neither of them are faddish, nor grandparents. One good year in my orchards and gardens of canning not only gives me the obvious benefit of tastier, healthier and cheaper food, by canning in bulk.......I have a full pantry come autumn. It lasts me a year to the next season on top of what we enjoy fresh. It lets me prepare sauces and meal bases I only need to finish off. It saves me time and is a major convenience.

    It's not now, nor ever has been a flash in the pan. In that respect, I find the article misleading.

  • 16 years ago

    In general, anyone trying to be more self sufficient, and self reliant, and competent, is considered a threat by the so-called media elite.

    There are millions of people in the USA alone who can a lot of food. Sure, initial costs can be relatively high - if you must buy a canner and all your jars etc. But subsequent years, it is the cost of your jar lids plus the energy costs to do your canning. (I'm preaching to the choir here :) ).

    What they don't say, is that even if you buy everything a the supermarket, if you use your canner to make convenient meals rather than buying takeout, it is healthier, cheaper, and takes less time.

    In general, these are the people who believe that the throw away society is ideal, and that the entire world lives to serve them. Or such is my observation. Some of us just want to tell them to get the F out of the way ;-)

  • 16 years ago

    OMGosh, I laughed so hard I nearly spit my tea out.

  • 16 years ago

    In general, these are the people who believe that the throw away society is ideal, and that the entire world lives to serve them.

    Conate, I understand and appreciate the thrust of your comment, but I think a global comment like this draws a vast conclusion from a miniscule example. It's tarring everyone with the same brush.

    While the Slate column makes for entertaining reading, I don't take it that seriously. It's too brief and superficial for that.

    Carol

  • 16 years ago

    Well you're quite right, Carol. But, at least 1,000,000 times I've thought that I over generalize :)

    Seriously I do wish that "news reporting" was a bit more in depth. The number of times you read articles about something you know something about and see many, many errors is disturbing. I didn't particularly notice errors in this one - but I also didn't in particular see any effort by the writer really to understand what he or she was writing about. Unfortunately, people who might have an interest in home canning and food preservation could easily be turned off from it.

    Nate

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with both 'readinglady' and 'colate'

    As to the article...Most people only remember the 'first' and last 'parts' of any speech or article( both are ok to get people involved).
    But 'colate' has a valid point, to someone who has not done home canning, that article would be a big 'turn-off'

    Personally, I love growing our own food. And I'm doing my best to improve every year.

    Ain't nothing like opening a jar of beans, or 'maters'......knowing that you did it all.

    Don

  • 16 years ago

    I don't look back on helping my mom and grandmother can with anything except a shudder ... it's hot, messy, dangerous, and strenuous.

    I would rather buy a case of canned peaches than go through the boiling, skinning, cutting, trimming bad spots, packing, filling, pressure cooker, cooling, checking seals ...

    Love the article - it's a bit snarky, but that's Slate's style.