Software
Houzz Logo Print
greenhouser

New gauges

18 years ago

The woman from the extension office called to tell me she does the tests and they're free. I'm going to have the gauge tested brand new to make sure it's accurate. I plan to go by the weight in any case. If the gauge is inaccurate I'll return it to Wally World and get the cheaper canner without the gauge. These gauges seen to be unnecessary anyway.

Comments (22)

  • 18 years ago

    They can be as much as 4 lb off right out of the boxes. We test a lot of new gauges that are bad. If you got the new Presto, most likely all you need to buy is the three piece weight set, not a different canner. You can use it with the dial on, just ignore it, and then use the weight for your elevation. I love using mine that way.
    I just got another set of weights so I can use both my canners at the same time that way.
    I also went and bought my daughter a new dial gauge canner and will get her the weight set for her. She doesn't even know about the surprise !
    I am going to sell her dial gauge canner that cannot be converted over. Not unless someone can get the right fitting to add to the bottom of a new vent pipe that will accomodate the weight set.
    Even if I can test my own gauges, I still like the weights. I can just listen to it instead of babysitting the dial.
    Here we charge $2 per gauge for testing.
    Free is a good price ! Some places I have heard charge a lot more than we do and they have to drop off the gauge, wait several weeks, etc. What a bother ! It only takes a couple minutes to test one. We go to farmers markets, produce stands, and stores, etc. on certain preset days to test.

  • 18 years ago

    To: linda_lou

    I already have a 3 piece weight for a Presto so no problem there. I would return it because those without the gauge are $20 cheaper. I could put that money towards more canning jars. :)

    Since it comes with a booklet it will probably have the times for a 15lb weight. I've also looked for the Ball Book and can't find one anywhere locally. I'll have to check Amazon. My canning books are from the dark ages of the 70s and 80s. Most of my county is still rural so you would think anything to do with canning would be available - but not so.

  • 18 years ago

    Gauges are not accurate as mentioned many times, unless they are very expensive and are electronic and use technology that is not affected by temperature, atmospheric pressure, or any outside conditions. A weighted gauge is the most accurate way to control pressure in a pressure canner. The words 'for reference only' are meant to tell you that yopu can see a needls pointing above zero, someplace, which just tells you that there is some kind or positive pressure inside. A weighted gauge if attached, would IMMEDIATELY vent steam when it simply cannot hold back a pressure that it was designed to hold back. Thats why they have 3 different weights, for the 3 different pressures. Testing a new gauge can be fruitless, if its shipped or brought somewhere or checking. Unless you live right next door to a place where a dial gauge is measured, AND, ADJUSTED, you will never see an accurate reading at any time. It can go out of adjustment or calibration in seconds even after it was checked. Most gauges on canners are not designed to be adjustable or have any way to be calibrated. So your at the mercy of your eyes and ears as Linda Lou has stated many times. In my many jobs, I was a metrologist with a company that did calibration on many things, and cheap dial gauges were unheard of as being sent or brought to someone to have them calbirated, adjusted, or even checked for any kind of accuracy. Returning the canner to the store will only give you more of a chance of buying a 'pig in a poke'..

  • 18 years ago

    I know everyone seems to think the jigglers are the best, but there is no way I would trust a jiggler and only a jiggler.

    I am thinking, however, of seeing if I can find a 3 weight jiggler for my new Presto - it jiggles at 15 lbs. If I had one that jiggled at 10 pounds, it would sort of be a way of testing the accuracy of the gauge, or validation, as it were.

    Since Presto says it will jiggle at 15 lbs, and it does, that must mean my gauge is OK - unless of course, a company that would sell bad gauges would also sell weights that weren't exactly the right weight.

    Good gracious, something else to worry about.

    I'm trying to wrap my mind around so many new gauges being off. That is dangerous. Do you report the company as selling a potentially dangerous - even deadly product?

  • 18 years ago

    If you don't have a new Ball Blue book, not a problem. Use the Univ. of Georgia website. It is free, too. The only thing you won't have are the recipes from Ball. Even they have a website you can use. Not all their recipes are on there, though.
    The link below is the same as So Easy To Preserve.
    We use this link a lot.

    I am canning today, my dial says 11 lb., my weights are for 10 lb., so perfect !! I am just listening to it jiggle away while I am sitting here.

    Here is a link that might be useful: University of Georgia.

  • 18 years ago

    If the canner goes back to the store I would be $20 ahead since a Presto without the gauge is $20 cheaper. :)

  • 18 years ago

    To: ladytexan

    Since so many things are pressure canned at 10pp how do you do that with a 15 lb weight?

  • 18 years ago

    To: linda_lou

    Thanks for the site. I'm eager for my canner to get here but haven't heard from Wally World yet.....

  • 18 years ago

    To: Greenhouser.

    Before I used the pressure canner, I put water in it and brought the pressure up and let it get to 15. The jiggler began when the gauge read 15.

    It only jiggles at 15, that's why I'm wondering if the 3 pressure jigglers would fit on this canner. I just couldn't use a jiggler only - but I wouldn't mind having it, as I said, to validate the gauge.

  • 18 years ago

    My new Presto has a single 15 pound weight. But as posted elsewhere in a very recent thread, you can purchase the 3 weight set direct from Presto. They 'stack' on each other giving you 5-10-15 or pounds, depending on how many you stack. Pressure gauges that are included with most home canners can be brand new, and still not show any accurate readings. Presto, I doubt, will even test theirs, as they are made by another company and are fitted to work with the Presto. The gauge is packed in a small cardboard box, wedged into the packing foam packing with the canner. If it were just sitting inside the canner itself and rattled around, it would be a very questionable device. I think that buying a pressure canner without buying the very necessary weights for the 3 different pressures pounds pressure would require the use of a dial gauge just to see if it starts to reach an 'approximate' 10 pounds. After that, the standard 15 pound weight they come with would be pushing the pressure beyond some recommended amounts.
    Did you know that all home water heaters have pressure relief valves that are spring loaded. If the water starts to boil inside and reaches dangerous pressures, the relief will open automaticlly and spew out hot water and steam. Trust me its happened!! No gauges there, as none would be accurate or necessary.

  • 18 years ago

    To: ladytexan

    You can buy the 3-piece weight which costs about $10. I believe Ace Hardware carries them. Someone here also posted an URL to get them online. I suppose you can can at 15 psi and just so them with less time.

  • 18 years ago

    I wouldn't can with less time. You have no way of knowing how much to reduce the time and the quality will be compromised.

    If you get your gauge tested, it doesn't matter that much if it's 4 pounds or so off, you just adjust for the amount. But realistically, it's far easier to buy the three-piece weight. Then you know that your canner is performing at the proper pressure.

    Here's the link to the Presto Pressure Canner Three-Piece Weight. You can check the Presto site to be sure it fits your canner. (It fits nearly all.)

    Carol

    Here is a link that might be useful: Presto Three-Piece Regulator

  • 18 years ago

    to: readinglady

    The booklet that comes with the canner gives you the correct times for 15 psi canning. The times are less than for 19 psi.

  • 18 years ago

    My Presto only came with the 15 pound, so the day it arrived, I ordered the 5-1-15 combo weight from the link provided. IT should arrive any day now.

  • 18 years ago

    Greenhouser, thanks for the clarification on the psi in the Presto manual. My Presto manual is very old, from the 1970's, and I haven't looked at it in years. I've also had the three-piece weight about the same time.

    Ladytexan, the weights are machined, so they're much more accurate and consistant than the gauge. The gauges on pressure canners are very cheap. I'm guessing the companies have decided to focus on keeping pressure canners affordable rather than upgrading the gauge.

    All-American doesn't worry about it; they're very clear in their manual that the gauge is secondary to the 3-part weight. Prestos are so inexpensive it's good value even if you do end up paying for the three-piece weight separately.

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    The booklet that comes with the canner is not correct. You cannot safely reduce the processing time and use 15 lb. pressure instead. You only use 15 lb. if you live at higher altitudes, but then, you would still process for the same amount of time someone living at sea level would.
    The people who write those books do not have food preservation safety training. I wish they would check with USDA to find out before they print those things.
    Also, any gauge that is more than 2 lb. off must be thrown away. You cannot use one that is 4 lb. off and trust it to be safe to use. Just until recently we told everyone only 1 lb. off in either direction before you needed to toss it and replace it with a new gauge.
    I see about taking the canner back and getting your $20 back. I would, too, in that case, unless you want to use both the weight and the dial gauge.
    The one that comes on the canner is not a true weight, it is called a counterweight. It is only meant to hold pressure in the canner, not to be used to regulate it by "jiggling".
    Most new canners by Presto seem to take the three piece weight set just fine.

  • 18 years ago

    I wasn't considering processing at 15 pounds, it's just that the weight is made to jiggle at 15 per the instruction booklet and it does. That's what gave me the bright idea of getting a 3 way weight and I would know if the gauge is off or not.

    I will have to trust the weights, but this canner is made in China and with all the corner cutting, and bad products we get from there - it doesn't seem beyond the pale for the weights to be off as well. So having a gauge AND weights would be better.

    If a manufacturer would put a cheap, and potentially dangerous gauge on a canner, why think they would be more scrupulous about the weights.

    I just like to worry, I guess.

    I'm concerned about the number of gauges that are off. Seriously, shouldn't something be done about that? That's very dangerous.

  • 18 years ago

    To: ladytexan

    "I'm concerned about the number of gauges that are off. Seriously, shouldn't something be done about that? That's very dangerous."

    Who can do anything? Who would care enough? The Dept of Ag? Forget about it. The FDA? Nope..... when it comes to most products out there you're on your own.

    If the gauge is off on my new Presto I plan to return it to WM for a refund and buy a Presto without a gauge. I'll go by the weight sound and jiggle of the weight and use the $20 for more canning jars. :)

  • 18 years ago

    I bought the 3-piece weight set for my new Presto 23qt. canner, and I'm glad I did; when the 10 pound weight starts to jiggle, the gauge reads 9 lbs. I realize that's not WAY off, and it errs on the side of safety, but if I relied on the gauge and canned at 11 lbs. on the gauge, I'd be canning at a higher temp than I need to. It may not hurt anything, but I would think things would tend to be a bit more "cooked" than they need be.

    The weight set was 18 bucks at my local hardware store, and I consider it money well spent. I use the gauge to know when it's time to start easing back the flame on my range, which is handy.

  • 18 years ago

    The set at Presto was $16.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the reminder on the 15 psi, Linda_Lou.

    It's been mentioned many times on the forum but for new canners it bears repeating. Do not trust the manual for canning instructions, only for maintenance and use of the canner itself. They're terribly out of date and don't get revised.

    I do think sometimes we just have to take personal responsibility. The Presto canner is $79.99 at Amazon with free shipping. At that price point it's unreasonable to expect a high-quality gauge, which would be in the $100's of dollars. The market wouldn't sustain it.

    The All-American body is U.S. manufacture, but wherever their gauge is made, it's equally cheap.

    Even if those gauges were accurate initially, it takes almost nothing to knock them off kilter. That's just the way it is. I still like having one, though, just as a visual check. I also have a 12-quart Mirro without a gauge and I hate it.

    I'm not going to expend energy worrying about the accuracy of machined weights regardless of their source.

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    The 5-10-15 pound weights just arrived from Presto. The main body of the 5 pound weight has a plastic knob on top and the two added weights are steel rings that slide over the body of the 5 pound one.