Software
Houzz Logo Print
valereee_gw

Canning safety post -- draft changes

18 years ago

Thanks to Carol, Dave, and Melissa, and sincere apologies that the last line of my first version seemed critical of this group here. I surely didn't intend criticism -- I just wanted to let people know that it was considered really very important to search the archives first. Answering the same question over and over again would make anyone cranky.

Here is what I currently have, and I would appreciate any further advice that will help me let food bloggers know to check the source of canning recipes. I'm really concerned that there's going to be more botulism seen as experienced cooks who are inexperienced canners tell their readers with apparent authority that a particular recipe is safe to can.

Thank you for any help.

Val

Here is a link that might be useful: Canning Safety/Botulism post

Comments (10)

  • 18 years ago

    First of all, I think your post is wonderful!! However here are some minor changes I would make to make it clearer.

    I would state what the low acid fruits are, to my knowledge they are bananas, figs and tomatoes. You could just say:
    In general, canned fruits are safe. Almost all fruits are high-acid, exceptins include bananas, figs and tomatoes.

    I would change this line:
    "All vegetables are low-acid foods and are safe to can in a boiling water bath ONLY if sufficient high-acid ingredients, generally in the form of vinegar, lemon juice, or citric acid, are added."

    To this one, (I just feel starting with the way people skim many readers might get to low acid vegetables are safe to can in a water bath and then stop reading):
    All vegetables are low-acid foods and are unsafe to can in a boiling water bath unless sufficient high-acid ingredients, generally in the form of vinegar, lemon juice, or citric acid, are added.

    -Robin

  • 18 years ago

    I would second that suggestion by Robin. The current wording is too easily mis-read or mis-interpreted. ;)

    I might even go further: "All vegetables are low acid foods and must be pressure canned unless sufficient high-acid ingredients such as vinegar, lemon juice, or citric acid, are added."

    Shifts their focus to the pressure canner and away from the BWB.

    Just something to consider. ;)

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Valereee

    Your article is well timed, and itÂs some good advice too; I see all sorts starkly contrary and,therefore, perhaps dicey canning practices on the Net. This makes it quite hard for the beginning canner. Ultimately, this confusion creates more mystery and engenders unreasonable fears about the whole subject too.

    ------------------

    One observation: Although making "designer" jams, jellys, and preserves seems to be all the rage (with these sort of products bring as much as 10 or more $ per half pint) canning fish and meat -- often foraged food -- is an important part of the Localvor philosophy and movement, if not a central part of our National Heritage.

    You may want to at least acknowledge this broader aspect of the endeavor. Getting the meat or seafood INTO the cans is the easy part, processing it is a much more critical operation. Or perhaps that would be another article to write? Personally, although this site has been hugely helpful to me, I do wish there were more posts and dialogue about pressure canning fish and meatsÂ.

    Not as if a lot of us donÂt eat these foods! And the more locally that food is procured/preserved, the betterÂ.at least according to the Slow Food and Localvor movement!

    Cheers, Roof

  • 18 years ago

    Valereee, I love the changes. I didn't think you were critical of the group, I just wanted to make sure we sound as friendly as we usually are.

    Robin and Dave, keen eye for how sentence structure and focus can affect the take-away message.

    Again, great work getting the message out about canning safety. Just this morning my mom told me she saw an article in the paper warning that you sometimes need a pressure canner, and she wanted to make sure I knew. I told her thanks and that I do have a PC. I thought it was a gift from my parents...my dad was in the room with my mom and he remembered exactly which Christmas they had gotten it for me.

    Maybe canning will enjoy a big trendy comeback like knitting did a few years ago. Hopefully not followed by the same big dropoff that knitting has seen lately. Doesn't matter, we'll still be here on the harvest forum. :-)

    Melissa

  • 18 years ago

    I just read your article and was very, very impressed. It is kind of you to take the time to do this. I am sure many will benefit from your effort.

  • 18 years ago

    You may want to use the term bottled lemon juice instead of lemon juice. Lemon juice may be unsafe due to the large variation in the PH of lemons.

    Zeuspaul

  • 18 years ago

    Canning may not only enjoy a big come back but may stay this time if the price of food remains so high. People may figure they're better off growing and preserving their own. I live in a semi-rural area where most women work these days. Even those with property don't grow gardens. At most you'll see a few tomato and pepper plants. Canning is becoming a thing of the past. Looked down upon as a quaint pass-time for farm women of the last century. Such a shame. As for myself I'd rather garden and spend time canning and freezing my veggies than sitting on the sofa watching TV. To each her or his own. :)

  • 18 years ago

    Thank you all so much! I'm making all these changes!

    Melissa, I'm glad I didn't come off as critical. I was actually just trying to inject humor, but that's always risky.

  • 18 years ago

    Valeree,
    Humor here? yes, maybe sometimes.. The GW forums are for those who want to learn, and for those who like to teach too. Taking risks can only bring you positive enlightement.

  • 18 years ago

    poor valereee is getting a taste of what it is like trying to write a FAQ around here. ;) Only multiply it by 200.

    Seriously Val, it is looking great. Ready to tackle Chapter 2? ;)

    Dave