Software
Houzz Logo Print
luchiaan

If you could pick the trees.....

18 years ago

If you could pick the trees someone would have planted 20 yrs ago to provide shade for your hostas, bleeding hearts, ferns, etc, what would you pick?

I'm in need of a few lg. shade trees, but want to be careful what I plant because they'll eventually be part of a larger woodland garden which will include varied hostas. I hear maples suck moisture and oaks will eventually create acorns. Any other trees better suited?

Thanks! (z4b/5a IA)

Comments (26)

  • 18 years ago

    hey... a newbie.. welcome. ...

    when i was in the situation you are...

    i planted oaks ... and once established.. they are growing 3 to 5 feet per year .... the 6 foot bare roots planted in 2001 are now going on 20 to 30 feet ...

    you have a lot of great hosta gardens in IA .... with little or no effort.. you should be able to track a few down.. and ask them.. in your area.. what is their favorite.. where is josh????

    ken

  • 18 years ago

    Ahhh,,, the Chinese proverb applicable to hosta collectors:

    The best time to plant a great tree is 20 years ago, the second best is now!

    I agree with Ken; I have a 1930's landscaping book I inherited from my mother's father, who had the greenhouse business. They suggested for ageless landscaping oaks, walnuts, elms, ash, nut trees. Carpathian walnuts are interesting trees for shade - they spit the seeds out of their shells. The squirrels will get them before you!

    I thought sycamores would be good until Alex Summers pointed out while visiting me in DE they were quite heavy water hogs. Elms and beech can behave the same when they get older.

    Any tree that grows well in moist soils or likes moist ground will present root growth problems eventually. Their roots will kill hosta and other plants grown under them as they look for moisture - part of their survival mechanism.

    I have tried slow growing Japanese maples, which offer the seasonal beauty and controlled root growth. So far so good but haven't had them for 20+ years yet.

    You also can look for special hybrid trees with tap roots only, that grow fast but must be checked often once they reach their max growth, as they start to die back. Hybrid poplars and pines come to mind, as have successfully used both.

    Bruce

  • 18 years ago

    We have several very old oaks (maybe 60-70 years old) under which I have successfully planted my hosta. Last year, we had a banner year for acorns, and I was picking oak seedlings out of my beds all summer. But they are wonderful trees, and looking back from the current vantage point of several feet of snow, I didn't even mind picking the seedlings. I am consoled by the fact that my hostas are sleeping soundly, insulated by the fluffy white stuff from the current one below zero temps.

  • 18 years ago

    My pick would be oaks. Sure, there will be acorns, but they have never cause any problems for me. I don't really see a lot of oak seedlings, either, for some reason.

    One of the most amazing hosta collections I've seen (in Iowa!) is grown entirely under huge walnuts. Walnuts are several times bigger than acorns and the "nothing will grow under walnuts" thing is really not an issue with most plants.

    Avoid at all cost:

    Maples
    Honey Locust
    Birch
    ...others can list more.

    In an ideal world, I'd grow my hostas under shade houses. Not "picture perfect," but completely eliminates root competition, too heavy of shade, and the umbrella effect.

  • 18 years ago

    I second what Josh posted. Shade structures grow the best hosta. We had a large green ash get lots of damage in the ice storm, we are contemplating a large shade structure......

    Red Oaks have been very nice growing for us. Thought the Pin Oak was going to be good, but we did have a top break off during the last ice storm. White pines are fast growing, but as they grow older, their roots are taking over the hostas.

    Ice storm was not good for the Birches or Maples either.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Ken! Yup... newbie to the forums. But I've been digging in dirt since I was eye level to mom's spade handle. Thanks for the welcome! 3-5 ft per year is pretty impressive. Do you do total weed control at least 2 ft out, and mulch? What kind of oaks are they? My hostas do grow effortlessly, as long as they get supplimental water. We're up on a hill with few trees (so far) and it's hard to keep moisture. Mulch is like shredded gold at my house.

    Bruce, I *wish* someone had planted more trees 20 yrs ago. It'd make my life a lot easier. We have a large oak/elm/maple timber a half mile out that draws squirrels away from our property. Not sure Jap Maple would work with our winter winds. Have you seen the Black Lace Elderberry? They say it's similar to the JM, but a lot hardier (if smaller). I might try that. Elderberrys grow like weeds here.

    Lois, I know what you mean about sleeping soundly. And a few oaks just may be the answer. I've already planted 2 Bur and 1 White out in the pasture. Considering a few Red or Scarlet.

    Josh, thanks. Oaks are sounding better, as long as experienced shade gardeners don't consider acorns a problem. Sometimes the vast amounts our Bur oak drops is enough to bury my smaller hostas. Never considered Walnut because of the myths about toxic soil. Thanks for the avoid list.

    Trudy... the ice storm was very hard on our Elms. Many lost the top most branches. A silver maple lost a bunch too (no surprise). At least these are way out in the pasture. Red oak is one I am now considering. I've already got 2 baby Ginkgo for yellow color and an Autumn Blaze Maple for red in other parts of the farm. The bronze oaks would fit in pretty well for the shade garden.

    Thanks for all the feedback, any other ideas would be greatly appreciated.

  • 18 years ago

    of mine.. shingle seem to be the fastest .... but i also put in black, white, red and scarlet .... sorry .. dont have the latin names handy ...

    drove from adrian MI to mansfield OH to see van wade.. 3 to 3.5 hours each way ..... and he sold them to me bare root .. from his cool houses the first week of april .... they were planted within 2 weeks ... and took off like rockets the following year..

    in my sand ... soil matters ...

    i put a 6 foot ring of wood chips.. with a moat so that i could lay down a few gallons of water and walk away ...

    water deeply and infrequently ... never fertilize ... i use roundup on weeds ....

    and 6 years later.. the chips are thinning.. and will not be replaced ... the trees are free range at this time ...

    i think i hit all your followup questions .... ken

  • 18 years ago

    Here is something I found on the Iowa State web site about the Red Oak.

    The red oak is one of the largest and most important timber trees in Iowa. One of the fastest growing of the oaks, it attains a height of 70 to 80 feet and a diameter of two to three feet. It has a wide, spreading headwith fewfar reaching branches.

    We purchased ours bareroot from a seed catalog.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Iowa State

  • 18 years ago

    Welcome Trudy ! Don't know much about trees , but many here do. I checked out your link, thanks now I learned the difference between the male & female ,oaks.. very interesting. My son & DIl gave me a young Black Oak sapling last spring. Hopefully it will be big enough to make nice shade for my hostas some day :) ~Dot

  • 18 years ago

    The other trees I would use for short term shade are crab apples - get them started and they take off. They will grow surface roots but you can chop them out easily. They will tolerate some dryness/drought also.

    The blooms, fruit and leaf colors are easy to take: what I would do is look for fire-blight resistant cultivars.

    Another old fashioned approach is to start peach pits - in 2-3 years I have had 10 ft trees, espcially if you water them regularly and have them in good soil. I get about 3 ft the first year, then start to prune for a good leader. Pruning all the lower suckers enhances the growth. Currently have about 10-15 in the lowest terraces for fast shade while waiting for oaks to grow.

    One last tree that is problematical but worth discussing here: the infamous buckeye (yes I am a Michigan graduate).They are somewhat fickle, but if you can find good seedlings, I space them 15-20 feet apart and take out the weakest ones after 2-3 years. If they find the soil to their liking, they will grow 3-6 ft a year.

    Blooms: white, yellow, pink, red, slight green.

    Problems: that fast growth rates will shoot up a tender central leader, which until it hardens off is quite susceptible to breakage in wind. I have lost many beautiful trees to broken central leaders, which deforms the overall tree growth. Other problem is like acorns, once the female trees start to fruit, you will have seeds/seedlings everywhere. Make good gift trees. Tap roots, exquisite huge compound leaves, blooms make it worth the effort.

    Bruce

  • 18 years ago

    Don't overlook evergreens; pines, hemlock, arborvitae, etc. It doesn't have to be a tall tree to give shade, hedges work, too. My yard is dominated by gigantic white pines and works just fine for hosta, as long as you don't plant too close to the trunk. One side has maples though and my attempts there have failed. We have power lines behind our yard, and the utility company just came through and took out many young maples on their side of the fence, so that will help.

  • 18 years ago

    I have 3 squirel planted oaks that need to be moved to a better location. The trees are around 8 to 12 ft. tall now. My neighbor who has a mature grove of oaks has the fungal desease in her trees and they are slowly dying.

    I read somewhere that if the roots of the trees touch that is how the fungus is spread. If this is true would it be safe to move my trees closer to hers but not in their root area? I let the trees grow for future shade for my hostas and don't want to loose them. How deep is their tap root at their height and could one of those spade planters get enough roots so they won't die in the move?

    I had 2 spruse trees rescued from road work a few years ago and transplanted them into my yard. They are doing fine. At that time I paid $100 a tree to move them and I'm sure the price has not gone down! My H thought I was crazy to do it! Wait till I tell him I want to move the oaks!!!

    What we won't do for our hosta!!!

    Connie

  • 18 years ago

    What about catalpa trees? Just curious cuz I have a young one about 15 ft. tall and thought about planting hostas under it. What are opinions on them?

    Karen

  • 18 years ago

    I had a catalpa tree in Delaware that hosta grew well under - and its blooms were quite striking - fragrant as I recall.

    Bruce

  • 18 years ago

    rickmontana - I already have 4 Austrian Pines along the southern border of this shade garden, and it will be bordered on the E and W by intermittent Techny's and boxwood. This is mainly to cut down on the wind factor. The shade trees are for the 'middle' of the garden. I have a few catalpa's out in the timber, they're lovely in bloom and attract lots of bees. And they're hard to kill. We burned a stump/brushpile near one and singed most of the branches off one side. It's still going strong.

    Bruce, never considered the peach. Did consider the crabapple, and various cherries and dogwoods. Redbud and Hawthorne too. Smaller trees to get me started, with the red oak planted in the middle to eventually supply most of the shade. ?

  • 18 years ago

    I recomment these two specimen trees:
    First is Locust Sunburst:

    {{gwi:925843}}

    The second is Little Leaf Linden:

    {{gwi:925844}}

    They will not grow as big and tall as maples and oaks.
    Little Leaf Linden grows in a pyradimal natural form but I trim the top to get a global form.

    The new growth on Sunburst Locus comes out yellow and will eventually turn green as the summer progresses.

    Papou

  • 18 years ago

    In a few more years, I think you'll find the Locust difficult to grow under Papou. The one I have has surface roots nearly as bad as a maple.

    Red buds are good, as are dog woods. I especially like the Pagoda Dog Wood. Look into Hackberries, too.

  • 18 years ago

    Josh, my folks planted a Sunburst locust in our front yard in Madison Heights MI years ago. I do recall it really pulled soil moisture as you note but my mother planted lots of her hosta seedlings in that bed and they did well with adequate hand watering.

    I have planted a 6 ft Sunburst locust on my hillside for seasonal color and shade - it is 1 inch caliper now.

    Bruce

  • 18 years ago

    Bruce, I planted a bunch of new hostas under my locust last summer. Not by choice...I'm running out of space! I did water regularly, so I'll be anxious to see how things look in the spring. I hope the tree roots are just a minor inconvenience. This tree has been here for about 18 years.

  • 18 years ago

    Pine groves can be pruned up 5ft or 50ft to deal with shade. There are pines suited for many zones so choice may depend on where you live, in zone 5 white pines grow well for me.

    I don't know about dawn redwood or bald cypress roots then give shade. The late leaf emergence allows early spring growth and sun in the winter if they are in a south location where they give summer shade and allow the sun through in the winter.

  • 18 years ago

    My neighbors have large Maples that shade the afternoon sun behind my house. They are much more useful then the ones in my yard. The shade from our white birches is the most useful, and they do not seem to be difficult to grown under and around.
    I also am drawn to the Japanese Maple but will be using the black-lace elderberry because of my zone. There are so many weeping type trees and shrubs available that I would love to incorporate... and everything seems slow growing. I do wish for a double weeping rosebud cherry that had been planted 20 years ago.

  • 18 years ago

    We got our Henry Fields catalog over the weekend. They still have bareroot red oaks. I think we ordered the taller ones.
    If you order a catalog, ours had a coupon: order $50 and get $25 free, of course, thats probably how much shipping is now days.

    Here's the link

    Here is a link that might be useful: Red Oaks

  • 18 years ago

    Why avoid maples, jspece? That's the prominent tree in our deciduous forest and hostas do just fine underneath them. Is there something I don't know?

  • 18 years ago

    Japanese Maples and sugar maples are the only ones I have found to be tolerable for hosta after 2-3 years - the rest have too many surface roots that compete for available soil moisture.

    Bruce

  • 18 years ago

    In Larry Hodgson's Making the Most of Shade he lists trees and shrubs that are generally considered gardener friendly. Here are a few in addition to some of the ones already mentioned. Red horse chestnut, Shagbark hickory, Fringetree, Yellowwood, Franklinia, Thornless honeylocust,Crabapples,Ironwood,Japanese tree lilac, Lacebark elm, as well as some shrubs and small trees,..Pagoda dogwood, Smokebush, European Elder,& Viburnum. All of the ones I've named are hardy to at least zone 4. Some may have other issues that you may want to check out. Also for a quick of shade some tall annuals, Love-lies-bleeding, sunflower, Nicotiana, or castor bean

  • 18 years ago

    Exactly what Bruce said, ninamarie.

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals