Software
Houzz Logo Print
valtorrez

Should I throw away or wait another year?

16 years ago

Last spring was my first spring in my home. The house already had hostas planted in in landscaping around the front of the house. Last spring the hosta's in front did horribly. I read on this site that hosta's are easy to grow but two of them barely made it out of the ground and were extremely small like 1/2 the size of small hostas at nurseries. When I dug them up in September to plant in back yard to see if a change in scenery would help, there was minimal roots connected to the plants. Is this a bad sign? I planted them anyway not knowing what to expect but do you guys think I should just throw them away and plant new ones this sping? I moved another hosta from the front that did come out but I believe was getting too much sun (this one had a large root ball and I was able to dig up after it rained one day). For this hosta, no matter how much I watered it the leaves still got scorched. Did I move at bad time (middle September) and will this one possibly not come up this spring?

Comments (7)

  • 16 years ago

    how deep did you plant them ....

    unless space is a premium.. there is no reason not to wait and see on those... but with little or no stored energy in fall.. meaning no roots.. then i wouldnt be surprised if they fail to appear... or struggle ...

    in july or so.. hosta grow a new set of roots.. where they store energy to pop out of the ground the following spring.... so you should see what you problem might be ...

    and ... it sounds like you may have had southern blight... might want to check the FAQ's for info about such ....

    but you ought to try again ... regardless ....

    welcome to GW... hosta are so simple.. that they are known to grow on driveways with little or no soil.. so dont give up based on this one example ...

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    It sounds like voles could have eaten the roots on the ones with the "minimal roots."
    Too much sun could have caused the burning on the other hosta, even with adequate water. It takes a while for plants to adjust after transplanting, especially in the heat of summer. I'm thinking transplant shock could have been the problem? It should be better this year, after the roots spread back out. But if there is too much middle of the day sun, then even with lots of water it may burn later in the summer. Morning sun (east side of house) is ideal.

  • 16 years ago

    For the hostas with the minimal roots, I was wondering about Voles. If voles ate some of the roots, would roots grow back? I cant say how deep the hostas originally were planted because I purchased the house in 10/08 with the plants already there. When I moved the hosta's it was the middle of September and already getting cool. I made sure not to plant too deep with what little I had to work with. I'll see what happens this spring.

  • 16 years ago

    If it is voles, and they left some part of the roots and crown, then the hosta should come back this year, although it may be MUCH smaller until it recovers (also assuming no more vole damage).

    I have an area along a very shady walkway planted with a long row of Antioch hostas. Some years they all show damage, some years a few are relatively intact. Any pieces that I move to a different location recover and grow like crazy. I have tried baiting with mouse poison, but I am unconfortable using the bait blocks, so have quit. Besides, most of the bad damage happens in the winter, under the snow cover (slugs are the problem in this area in the summer) This is the only area that I consistently have a BAD vole problem. But nothing else will grow there, so the poor Antiochs have to stay and get tortured.

  • 16 years ago

    Bunnycat, I hope that that is the issue with my hostas. I just could not believe how little root I had when I dug up my plants. How long did it take for yours to recover?

  • 16 years ago

    Depends on what you mean by recover. Sometimes I've found only a few scattered eyes with bits of roots where previously there had been a big hosta. There are about a dozen individual Antiochs along the slate walk. One year one of the crowns looked like it was slightly sunken. I touched it and it fell into a cave. I think chipmunks had dug out the area underneath for a winter hibernation spot, but voles came along and ate all of the roots and part of the crown.
    The only way a hosta has a chance to recover is to move it to a safer place. After that, it depends on how much root is left, and how nice the new home is. Steady watering is essential, plus a nice hole filled with some compost and manure, along with the soil. It also depends on the variety of hosta. Some have fast growth rates, others are slow. The year after the damage can be very disappointing. The following year most hostas will look pretty good.
    I sure hope this is true.... Last winter something ate almost all of the dormant eyes on my large Jewel of the Nile (boo hoo). It had puny growth last summer. I tell myself it was getting too big for its spot anyway. I hope this spring it looks better.

  • 16 years ago

    You could always pot some of them up for a year or two and store the pots in a vole protected fashion during the over-wintering period, just to see if that's 'what's up'.

    Throw 'em away, , , naw ;-)

    hh

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio