Software
Houzz Logo Print
gourd_friends

breaking green beans...??

17 years ago

This may be a silly question, but, I'm gonna ask it anyway.

As I break green beans for eating, or canning, I first break off the stem end, then the tip end, and then break it into bite-sized pieces. Why do we break off the tip end?? Is it because my mother always did, and her mother did the same thing, or is there another reason?

Jan

Comments (10)

  • 17 years ago

    I leave the tip end on! I remember my great grandmother used to make me and my sisters and brother break off both ends and we hated it! Maybe that's why I stop at the stem end :) It doesn't affect the taste of the bean to leave the tip end on, at least I don't think so!

  • 17 years ago

    Blossom end/tips on most all produce is removed because (1) it is the primary source of bacteria on the fruit/veggie and (2) it contains hormones and enzymes in those cells than can interfere with the preservation process.

    Blossom end removal is the standard recommendation on tomatoes, cukes, squash, beans, melons, etc. and is often stipulated in the recipe IE: "when canning snap beans, wash and trim the ends...". ;)

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    That's so funny - I can still hear my grandmother (as she handed me a large bowl of beans/peas from the garden):

    "Now, you tip 'n tail these for me."

    And now if I didn't, somehow it just wouldn't be right :-)

    Actually, the funniest part (now that I'm thinking back), she spoke very little English, but her first job here in America was working as a maid for a wonderful British couple. Her limited grasp of American English was interspersed with some veddy, veddy proper British terms (that the rest of us sometimes didn't understand). I think "tip 'n tail" was one of those.

  • 17 years ago

    "Tip 'n tail"!!! I love it! I tip and tail so I can pull the attached string off.

    Susan

  • 17 years ago

    does this only apply to string type beans, because I grow stringless beans and the ends don't have a blossom like a string bean does?!

  • 17 years ago

    All beans grow from blossoms.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    yup, I guess my post was asking for Dave's post!

    What I should have typed was that the blossom end on a stringless bean doesn't need to be broken off because it is not as "meaty" as the string bean blossom end. Nor do you need to do this to the string bean. As with so many other things our grandparents and great grandparents and so on did, we find that it was redundant, not necessary/needed, or we have improved our way of doing things. Yes it is true that all vegetables contain enzymes and bacteria that break down over time and if not preserved properly will make for a very bad winter! Think about it, if you blanch the beans, you are blanching the blossom end as well. Their are certain vegetables that need the blossom end cut off, like the cucumber, tomatoe, ect., but the beans do not.

    Experiment! Do just like any other farmer/gardener in the past and present, just like with recipes or trying a new veggie to grow, try a batch without breaking off the blossom end and see what it does after several months, than several more months and compare it to the batch that has the blossom end cut off. You may be surprised!

  • 17 years ago

    So what's the consenses here? Cut off stem & blossom end or stem end only? If I am preparing them fresh from the garden, I usually only trim the stem end, unless there is a really long tip, them I trim. So if canning,both ends?

  • 17 years ago

    gardener1908 - it isn't a matter of consensus here tho most all do "tip and tail". ;)

    Given that green beans rank quite high on the botulism index and that the tested/approved instructions for canning green beans call for removing the ends, IMO that's what you should go by. But bottom line - it's your choice.

    Personally, I'm just not into experimenting with food safety, especially if it is only done for convenience sake.

    Dave

    PS: A quick scan of this search result for 'blossom end' at NCHFP makes it pretty clear to me. ;)

    Here is a link that might be useful: NCHFP - Blossom end trimming discussions

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for all the information. I will be "tipping and tailing" again this afternoon.

    Jan

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio