Software
Houzz Logo Print
giz25

Emerald Ruff cut

15 years ago

I ordered emeral ruff cut from hallson's earlier this year and received an email from Chris that although his plants are 5 years old they are still a single eye. He also says he does not find it very vigerous. for those of you that have emerald ruff cut what are your thoughts on it? it looks like a striking hosta but is it worth the wait. what others are similar to emerald ruff cut?

Comments (26)

  • 15 years ago

    it should grow about the same as emerald island ....

    it is not that slow in my garden.. 20 miles from chris .... though i would not call it fast ....

    i have no clue why his are so slow ... maybe they hate him personally ...

    IMHO .... nothing like it ...

    depending on price.. i would go for it.. and see if ripping it from mother earth.. and mailing it to you will make a difference..

    then there would be the 'threaten it to within an inch of its life' theory .... when you get it.. literally throw it on the driveway.. scratch the roots around.. then plant it ... it has been suggested that it will release growth hormones to stimulate it to growth ...

    i mean .. we arent talking a hundred bucks are we????

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    Well, this will be the deciding year for me on that one. First time I got it in the mail, it soon died- the only one to ever do that for me. The next year I bought it from Hallson's and that one was a much better plant. But my issue with ERC is that for me, it gets terrible dessication and the leaves get super ugly- like Frances William, or worse- like Supernova. I am hoping this year it is more settled and won't do that anymore. If it does, I'm moving it to the back of the garden or getting rid of it.

    I am curious what other peoples experience with it is.

  • 15 years ago

    Here is a picture from last year, which was the second year, and in it's defense, I did move it in early Spring. It looked marginally better once the hail came. ;)

    http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y251/colleenseamus/garden/erc2.jpg

  • 15 years ago

    i have had mine so long.. it might be OS .... rather than tc ...

    perhaps it is a TC issue???

    the last pic above.. has frost/freeze damage.. yes???

    looks like my last pic is 2008.. whats that all about???

    ken
    {{gwi:956575}}
    {{gwi:956576}}
    {{gwi:956577}}

  • 15 years ago

    That looks awesome, Ken! I too have it coming from Hallson's but Chris hasn't said anything about it being a problem/slow grower to me, and he's scheduled to ship next week.

    Do you have yours in a really shady location?
    Karen

  • 15 years ago

    col_123...I'm with Ken, that looks more like frost damage. Definitely not spring dessication like FW gets.

    ERC has been fairly slow for me, but as Ken's pics show, it is a beautiful plant!

  • 15 years ago

    Hi Ken, There are no OS of it, as it was a TC sport and the only plants that have ever been produced were from TC.

    In the email I sent, I actually mentioned that the 3 year old plants that I'm shipping are single eyes, not 5 year old plants, and it was prompted by someone emailing and mentioning that the Grenfell book says it is vigorous. I simply haven't found that to be the case so emailed people to clarify it.

    That does appear to be frost damage, but I've seen some spring desiccation burn from time to time also. Yes, it can be a striking plant, and Ken's is really beautiful, but it can be a little touchy.

    Hope that helps to clarify some more.

    Chris

  • 15 years ago

    sorry chris, I misread your email. i need some new eyes.

  • 15 years ago

    Nope, not freeze damage. I keep all my hosta well protected from frost and freezes once they start to break dormancy. It also looked like that the previous year, shortly after I received it and planted it well after frosts or freezes. I'm hoping it's something it does when it's stressed and now wont do it again now that it isin its permanent place. I just counted five eyes coming up, which is probably three more than last year.

  • 15 years ago

    coll must live by that river ... what is it called.. da nile???

    lol ... whatever ... its an early spring problem .. whatever it may be ... can we agree there is an issue with the water in the cell tissue??? ... that either frost/froze .. or it transpired out of the cell [dessication] ... whichever causing damage to the cell wall ... BTW .. i have had frost damage on light colored hosta.. with no evidence of a frost ... its all about some magic temp the hurt that plant ...

    anyway my ERC is in full bright shade ...

    and how come nobody got the joke that it grows like emerald island ...

    chris... can there be a difference between TC labs and what comes out of them ????? can there really be TC lab retards ??? ... i never really believed that they could screw up the hormone use so bad .. that it would have along term effect ... but i am sure weirder things have happened ... not that yours are such ....

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    I got mine in 2009 from Hallson Gardens. One eye in 2009, two eyes in 2010, and I just checked to see 3 eyes beginning to unfurl this morning. A simply stunning plant.

    No frosts here, but I'll agree with Ken that cold (in the 30's) can affect some hostas in Spring. Here too.

    -Babka

  • 15 years ago

    Hi,
    E.R.C. is a sport of 'Sea Angel Wings' a notorious slow grower. The green edge on ERC makes it grow better and faster.

    As the plant matures the green margin will increase in size. There should be no problen w/ a three year old. Especially from Hallson's. The margin has had time to mature and increase.

    I would suspect you would have more than a single eye in 2011.

    It is a favorite here.

    Yes, there is a few mixed reviews. H. 'Journeys End' is very similar and grows like a weed.

    Rick

  • 15 years ago

    Not sure why I would be in denial- when this time of year rolls around I spend the next month being fantically obsessed with the weather forecast. I'm sure my neighbors think I'm insane with the sheets and boxes all over the place....no one else covers anything. If ERC is so delicate that it gets frost damage at say 37-40 degrees, then so be it...that makes it fussier than I would like for my garden. None of the other hosta in my collection get the Spring uglies or suffer any noticeable frost damage unless you count Frances Williams, and possibly Parhelion which gets white dessication areas pretty often, but not enough to detract from it's overall appearance. I'm also pretty certain that I got ERC in the mail after the frosts were over....more like late Spring. It looked great when it got here, then the leaves started going all transparent when I potted it. Pretty much the same show it put on last year.

  • 15 years ago

    i am just kidding around with you coll ... don't take it any other way ...

    have fun in your garden.. ignore the neighbors .... they really need a hobby if all they do is sit around and watch you ... lol ...

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    Ok, just wanted to say that Emerald Ruff Cut is once again showing signs of what I'm calling "dessication". Transparent areas that will just get uglier every day, ala Frances Williams. It's been a cool, gray Spring, yet without any frosts or freezes whatsover for probably a month now if not more, which is unusual. Until a few days ago, ERC was looking nice. So it's absolutely not frost damgage, is all I'm saying. All I can conclude is that Emerald Ruff Cut hates me, and the feeling is fast becoming mutual.

  • 15 years ago

    I received a single eyed Emerald Ruff Cut at a lower price from Hallsons after I was told that this year no 2-eyed were available. I like that plant and have it in a larger plastic pot until I decide where to plant it. No damage to leaves here in zone 5a. But thanks mentioning your experience, coll.
    Bernd

  • 15 years ago

    Coll, I have the exact same experience with mine! Every year it comes up and looks ratty! It's acting like Frances Williams
    all over again, and btw so does LINDA SUE that we all got so excited about! I'm disgusted with them both. My ERC is
    very full and I hate being DONE with any hosta but I'm just about there.

    Our local nursery is going to try and get me another 'Journey's End' as the ones they've gotten have been very awesome
    and of course they're gone now that I've decided to kick ERC to another less prominent position in my garden and
    put JE in it's place!! hmmph

    Another thing, Coll--don't let ken get to you--he's really a nice guy with a kind of cryptic sense of humor, that doesn't always translate well
    through this mode of communication! I came to that conclusion while hubby and I were in his area at a bed and breakfast and we spent a
    couple of days with him! He was very hospitable and went out of his way to make it a fun couple of days for us! I think he just likes to mess with us!! ;^)

  • 15 years ago

    Oh, I certainly don't take offense to Ken...it's just that the original poster wanted people's thoughts on ERC and when I gave mine, several people assumed mine pictured was frost damaged. I knew that not to be the case, as I do this year. So as far I'm concerned, my experience with this hosta is that it is flawed in the same way Frances Williams is and if mine croaks, I will not be replacing it. I don't know what makes it ugly in my garden- it just is...and I feel validated that it's perpetually ugly for someone else, too, lol. ;)

    Take FW, some places online will call those brown patches it gets "sunburn", yet one Spring I had mine in pots behind a screen of landscape fabric- totally safe from wind and ALL sunlight. Still got the brown uglies. In fact I know someone with FW in full sun and hers don't get any of that. (and yes, I'm sure her's were FW). So this year it looks like ERC will be joining FW in the Corner of Shame and I'll put something reliably pretty in it's place. Maui Buttercups also has some transparent leaves happening- I think that one is related to FW, isn't it?

  • 15 years ago

    Here I write in defense of Frances Williams. Two are doing well in shadier spots in my zone 5a. Another one has its crown, roots, stems shaded by a low growing juniper with leaves exposed to sun = no sunburn, is one of the last standing. Two new Olive Bailey Langdons in place of one of the FW got burned, probably did not have enough roots established to take up sufficient water.
    Bernd

  • 15 years ago

    Oh no--that explains a lot, Coll--I have 'Maui Buttercups' and mine did the same thing this year! Sigh! (frustrated)
    I didn't realize it was of the FW heritage! I think I need to look into those 'genes' more closely when I consider a newer hosta!!

    Someone--has suggested that it's actually a 'virus' that is doing the browning in FW's! Makes one wonder, or at least this one!!
    I mean, doesn't 'Spritzer' have it's own virus!

  • 15 years ago

    my erc has issues too. i have two and both look like they have dessication/nematodes (they dont lol)

    It does remind me of FW dessication but I think it looks different b/c of the substance (or lack thereof) of the leaf. Another one that comes to mind is Great Expectations. Here is one of mine half reverted but you can see the "normal" leaf on the bottom:

  • 15 years ago

    Ack, my eyes, my eyes! I guess what gets me the most is that this is the time of year that everything should look pristine and fresh. I don't want to see late August looking leaves on a Spring hosta.

    Im really not happy with Maui Buttercups - I moved it last year to a spot right up front and I hate looking at those ugly leaves. I also have Rainforest Sunrise and Tropical Storm and I guess I can expect more of the same from them. Boo.

  • 15 years ago

    now that you mention it, my maui buttercups can get the naRsties, also. LOL

    janice...what's the deal w/ spritzer...?

    here is mine...seems ok...(besides a few hail holes)?

  • 15 years ago

    Andrea, Spitzer has it's own virus, named after itself as the 'Spitzer Virus'!
    I guess not all of them get it--I have a small one, too, that so far looks fine!

    Funny thing, I just googled it and came up with a thread where I was asking about it,
    when I was contemplating getting one. It was discussed, that many have ones that are fine
    and one that had theirs for 8 years (?) and suddenly it showed up! I think it was finally
    decided that it had pretty much been eradicated these days! I sure hope so!

  • 15 years ago

    Not to hijack this thread (but I'm gonna)... hey_j what is the name of the hosta directly behind the fern, and the one to the right of ERC in your photo? Gorgeous!!!

    I bought a single-eye ERC last year from Idiothe's plant sale, and this year it has come up still single. I'll give it time. It looked decent even late into the fall... maybe it likes its spot. :-)

  • 15 years ago

    Hi Candice!! The one directly behind the fern is the AWESOME 'Kiwi Full Monty' that was gifted to me by
    a lovely person (BluePoppy in '08) who use to post more frequently here (hope she's doing okay)! She has
    an amazing garden and I loved her pix! She knew I was trying to grow a healthy 'Striptease' and decided I
    needed to try the KFM, instead. She is right--it is a totally awesome plant--softer and bluer than 'Striptease'.
    It has done AMAZINGLY well in my garden! I need to email her and let her know--in fact, was just thinking
    I should the other day! Thank you for the nudge!

    The other one, is another 'gift' from 'DavemidOhio' who also posts from time to time, and he knew I had loved/lusted after his 'June' for
    years, (due to my high praise of it as one of the best looking I had ever seen). About 2 wks ago, he showed up at my door,
    literally mins. after I returned from the nursery with a 'June'! He lives about 50 mins. away from me and due to a great loss of trees
    he's abandoning the growing of most of his hosta! SOB!! He had so many absolutely stunning specimens! I'll always refer to that one
    as 'Dave's June'!

    He also gave me his 'Abiqua Moonbeam' years ago that I dearly love!

    In case I've not targeted the one 'next to ERC' the other one with the creamy margins is 'First Frost'! :o) I love them ALL!!

    Some of the best hosta I have, are gifts!!!

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert