Software
Houzz Logo Print
greenhouser2

Bitter tomato sauce

18 years ago

We've started to use the tomato sauce with the citric acid. It's so bitter no one will eat it in my family. No one will drink the bitter tomato juice either. Adding sugar doesn't help. I plan to try mixing it 1/2 and 1/2 with store bought tomato sauce to dilute the bitterness and see if that helps.

I'll remove the clear liquid off the juice with a large turkey baster and try diluting that with store-bought sauce also and use it as sauce. I don't know what else to do. I'd hate to throw it all out. I don't know how anyone can eat such bitter sauce or drink such bitter juice.

Comments (24)

  • 18 years ago

    If it's that bitter, I'm guessing the citric acid is not the cause.

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Agree with Carol. Unlike lemon juice, citric acid doesn't impart that much taste to the product. It is the same thing that is added to commercial canned juice.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    In excess, citric acid will impart "sour" but not "bitter". I'm betting the tomatoes are the culprit. If the tomatoes were canned late-season, that could be the cause. Peels ground into sauce can contribute to bitterness.

    Sometimes, depending upon the source of the problem, tomato sauce will mellow in the jar. When did you can it?

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Bitterness can come from the skins and seeds. If these were used in the tomato product, you will encounter bitterness. adding salt can help improve the tomato taste,if none was added originally. As mentioned, bitter is different from sour. Cooking down a watery sauce to thick one, will also intensify some of the lesser flavors of tomatoes, and can affect bitterness.

  • 18 years ago

    Readinglady: SOUR is what I mean. Sour = bitter. To us it's the same thing. All the juice and all the sauce made over the summer is bitter/sour. All of it, from different batches and different gardens (I had three gardens this past summer.) These are jars canned in July and August.

    Digdirt: It has no "taste." It's just very bitter/sour.

    Kem: I should have used the word "sour"... my family described it more as bitter than sour. No seeds or skins were added. The Roma mill removed them all. When mixed 1/2 and 1/2 with a commercial sauce it's edible. But that's wasteful and 1/2 has to be frozen since 2 qts is too much to use at one time. Freezer space is at a premium this time of year.

  • 18 years ago

    Of the three approved acidifiers, citric acid has the least effect on flavor with lemon juice second and vinegar last and least desireable.

    You could make notes and give lemon juice a try with some of next year's tomatoes.

    However, I still think it's possible something else is going on. Citric acid in the recommended amounts shouldn't make that kind of difference.

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Sorry but I too think something else is going on. For thousands of home canners citric acid imparts no flavor change to tomato products but the mind can play funny tricks on us.

    If you will recall, you were very opposed to adding any form of the required acid to your tomatoes. You never had added it in the past and didn't understand why you had to do so now. It would be a change from what you were used to doing.

    So you expected a different taste and you very likely passed that expectation on to the rest of the family. That would be normal. All of us are hesitant and off-put when first trying something new and if we are already expecting it to be something we won't like, it usually is - something we don't like.

    Bitter and sour are 2 very different tastes, seldom used interchangeably, and you should easily be able to distinguish the two. So most likely it is just different and if given the chance the difference will disappear from the family taste buds.

    I hope you will give it the chance because you only have 2 alternatives: give up home canning tomato products or choose to risk it all by not adding the required acid.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    I've forgotten - do you have experience with home-canned juice before this? It truly is different than store-bought. DH doesn't like to just drink my home-canned juice, but will gladly cook with it and buy even the cheapie juice to drink.

    I too object to the raw tomato "bite" or bitterness of tomato sauce. I add either a dollop of grape jelly (wouldn't be good for the juice, but the sauce, and doesn't effect the canning) or a few chocolate chips (best to do AFTER opening) to the product to counteract the bite. Trust me, you'll never find these flavors in the finished product. The acidity though, is truly necessary. Sorry.

  • 18 years ago

    Greenhouser2, I completely understand your frustration with a product that you worked hard at not turning out to your expectations. Been there, believe me. That being said, you came here with a question and some of the most experienced/knowledgeable people on this site have responded with either suggestions or advice. I would make a bet that any of these people have had the same or similar problems in the past, which makes their advice worthy. Sooooooo....

    Bitter and sour are different for me as well. I love sour, as in pickles, vinegar, etc. I dislike bitter in any shape or form. Either one, I dislike in my tomato sauce. There would also be different recommendations for each. Sour, I think spoiled. Bitter, I think seeds/skins. So that is why the verbage is being questioned.

    I have had very similar results with my sauce as well. First, I thought I hadn't cooked it enough. Then I over-cooked it. Grrrrr! If I ever find a secret to a great sauce, I will be sure to share it :) I think Gran2 has some excellent suggestions as to make the best of it, though. I too put a bit of chocolate in my sauce. You can't detect it but it takes that bite off the sauce. Hope this helps and please don't take offense. We've all been there with disappointments and this is just the right place to share them at. Lori

  • 18 years ago

    Since no one is going to convince you the citric acid isn't the culprit, it's a waste of energy to discuss any other possibility.

    You can add sugar to compensate for whatever taste you perceive or you can process without acid and take the risk.

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    I'm sorry, everyone, but I have to agree with the Op. I think it must be different taste buds. I used citric acid, and I've used lemon-we cant stand the taste.
    My soloution? guess I'll freeze it now.

  • 18 years ago

    Ceresone: Exactly! What is bitter or sour or both to one person, may taste wonderful to the next person. I will probably skip the added acid next year so the sauce is edible and juice drinkable. Or I just wont make juice anymore. The sauce is always simmered for at least 10 minutes before we use it anyway. This is a personal preference. I'm not recommending others do it.

    BTW, I spent some time on Google and was unable to find any information on people dying from home canned tomato sauce and juice. Go figure.... yet people have been sickened by improperly commercially canned foods. Nothing is 100%.

  • 18 years ago

    gardengalrn: I'm going to take my elderly Aunt's advice and treat tomatoes as a low-acid food. I wont water bathe them. She's been canning since 1948 and never once had a problem with botulism in her tomatoes. She pressure canned them as per her day as did I in the 1980s without one problem. This is a personal preference so the sauce is edible for us. I'm not recommending it to others. I'll try the suggestions for all I made this year, when the jars are opened for use, but the sourness or bitterness from the added acid will not work for my family.

    I think what helps the flavor of canned sauce is not adding the onions and garlic until ready to use. I brown them in olive oil then add the sauce and simmer it 10 to 15 minutes. I also add more oregano and basil at that time. It's just not as good adding the garlic and onions before canning.

  • 18 years ago

    FYI:

    "Friday, February 15, 2008
    Home-Canned Tomatoes Linked to Botulism
    The International Society for Infectious Diseases reported today that 14 people were hospitalized due to botulism recently in the Yugra district of Russia after participating in a "feast" on February 3rd. One of the victims died. Preliminary investigation results are pointing to home-canned tomatoes as the source of the illness.

    This is a reminder that even relatively acid canned foods, such as tomatoes, can be a source of botulism. Boiling temperatures will inactivate the toxins produced by Clostridium botulinum. If you home-can, please reheat the canned food to the boiling point and allow it to simmer for at least 10 minutes before tasting even a tiny amount of the food."

    We each have to decide what we're comfortable with. There's no canning police watching what you do in your own kitchen.

    Carol

    Here is a link that might be useful: International Society for Infectious Diseases

  • 18 years ago

    Fresh garlic will impart a bitter tase after time, I only use dried garlic powder in my tomatoe products, actually I use all dried herbs.

    I use lemon juice with no off taste, the 14 year olds that opened jars last week loved the sauce. I got a "really good" mark for that batch of spagh sauce from them, lol.

    I also use the skins, this year I wizzed the whole tomatoes in the food processor, then thru the Foley Mill to remove seeds. I noted that I had a far less watery product, then using a Squeezo and higher volume when I started cooking down, but I cook mine down to 1/2 for thicker sauce.
    Had some red wine in the refrigerator when making the last batch and added that also.

    I would have to say if I had a product that was not unedible, plus not being able to identify the cause as simply as a added acid, I would not consume it.

  • 18 years ago

    greenhouser2,

    Just curious, What did your sauce and juice taste like before you canned/processed it? Did you notice if it was bitter or sour?

    I always taste our sauce to make sure there is enough seasoning in it before it gets processed. Never had a problem or complaint about the added acid to our sauce.

    Lynn :)

  • 18 years ago

    It was fine before putting it into the jars with the Citric Acid. I didn't add the acid to the pot of sauce. I measured it and put it in the jars, then filled the jars with sauce or juice and canned it. The few jars that went into the fridge for immediate use, without the CA, were fine.

  • 18 years ago

    Size/capacity of the jars? How much citric did you add to each jar? What about the amount of salt added to each jar?

  • 18 years ago

    BusyLizzy: Those that didn't contain the added Citric Acid that were refrigerated, were not bitter/sour like those jars that contained it. As I mentioned before, I add very little garlic and onion powder before canning. When I want to use the sauce I brown fresh garlic and onions in olive oil - then add the sauce and simmer (slow boil) it somewhere between 10 and 15 minutes.

    To everyone else: I don't recommend anything to anyone. If anyone finds the site listing the % of people who have died from home canned tomato sauce sans added acid, please let me know. I searched Google and Yahoo and came up empty handed.

  • 18 years ago

    This isn't plain sauce and juice? This is sauce and juice to which garlic and onion powder have been added PRIOR to canning? You didn't indicate that before. And you're blaming the off-taste on the citric acid?

    How much garlic and how much onion powder - specifically? Unless used in very small amounts, both ingredients are notorious for flavor changing in canned goods, especially after a bit of time has passed. They intensify in the processing and over time into taste that wouldn't be noted while fresh.

    As mentioned before, commercially canned sauces and juice do not contain either garlic or onion powder (unless so indicated on the cans and so taste very different) but they all contain citric acid.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Ok, how' bout.......

    What metal type pot did you use for cooking?

    I only use enamel, unless I have more than 12 quarts at a time, then I use a stainless steel pot.
    If you used aluminium to cook tomatoes that can make them bitter.

    Have you tried using baking soda instead of sugar to reduce the acid? Baking soda is a great acid reducer.

  • 18 years ago

    Still need the answers to my questions that have gon ignored (above). Add to that the same pot material.

    Size/capacity of the jars? How much citric did you add to each jar? What about the amount of salt added to each jar? Did you add any sugar??

  • 18 years ago

    I will try adding Baking Soda when I open the next jar. I use enamil pots for canning. I have two large enamil pots. After buying the second one I found the first one in the outbuilding. :-/

    Dave: I always added a few shakes of dry onions, basil and garlic to the sauce before canning or freezing it. A few shakes in what would usually amount to 6 to 7 qts. My deceased husband added everything before he canned it and no off flavors or sourness. I'll try the Baking Soda busylizzy suggested when we're ready to use these sauces. I can use the turkey baster to remove the liquid from the juice and make sauce of it on the days I have the time.

    Thanks for the suggestions.

  • 18 years ago

    Depends on how good your enamel is and take care of it, Ken.

    Some of my pieces are from 2 generations ago that I use now and not a scratch, chip or crack on em.
    My favorite canning funnel is my great grammies Graniteware.

    Besides, it is pretty easy to see rust on enamelware, like when I stupidly left out a water pitcher in the winter, froze, expanded , cracked...but now a planter or plant watering can.