Software
Houzz Logo Print
thisismelissa

Would this be a feasible plan?

17 years ago

Ok, I like a more "full" look to my garden. I generally tend to plant about 24" apart for that reason.

But, at the same time, I recognize that the large/giants are going to want way more than the 24" I'm allowing them.

So, I had an idea and wanna run it past my hosta buds.

Say I was to plant every-other large/giant potted into the ground. So, I take a 1g nursery plant, pot it up into a 2-3 gallon pot and put hosta, in the pot, into the ground.

Then, in a few years when the neighboring plants (which were planted directly into the ground) start to get bigger, I could then pull out the potted plants without disturbing the roots of either set of plants. Then, I could take that plant out of the pot and find it a permanent home.

Has anyone ever done this? Does it seem feasible? Give me the pros and cons of doing it this way. I have a few under-performing giants that I need to replace and am considering replacing them potted plants.

Thanks!

Melissa

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Melissa! I'm with you, I like the 'full' look to my garden, as well. But, I'm thinking
    you might be better off planting the *big 'uns* in the ground so that they will reach a full size
    more quickly and the others in the pots that would not have the HUGE potential of the others.
    That way, it would be easier to move them, with roots not becoming nearly as possibly 'bound'
    as what could be the case of those 'big guys' in their pots!

    I've planted plenty in pots in the ground and in barrels and it just seems that even in those
    big barrels, the ones in the ground, directly planted, just get bigger!! I think it has something
    to do with the way the micro-organisms interact with the roots of a particular plant and it seems
    to need the larger playing field to pull it off effectively! I read that somewhere, not long ago!

    Hope this helps and doesn't confuse things for you!!!

    Just a thought! :o)

  • 17 years ago

    Melissa, I'd plant them in the ground without pots. Time comes to move them, water the day before and when you dig them out use a garden fork - moved a couple today to make room for some new ones - couldn't have been easier.

    Sometimes we over think things.

    Paul

  • 17 years ago

    Hosta planted in pots in the ground here are in danger of getting root rot int he winter because of the drainage issues.
    I just interplant with "ordinary" hosta....small starts of those which I have a lot of, undulata, antioch, krossa regal, August moon, gold edger etc...chosen to complement the "star". Then dig out the ordinary and move it along when the star gets big enough to shine.
    Linda C

  • 17 years ago

    I guess I should have shared that my thoughts for potting was to not disturb the big roots of the neighbors, therefore reducing their size/leaf size.

    In light of that, what do you think?

  • 17 years ago

    It's a great plan. Hostas grow plenty big in pots and it's easier to keep moisture and nutrients closer to the root zone. Popping out a containerized hosta is far less damaging to the roots than digging it out of the soil.

  • 17 years ago

    you are overthinking it..

    insert in soil.. mother earth ...

    roots down.. proper height ....

    move smaller ones when necessary ...

    its really the giants.. that need 5 to 10 years to giant up .... that should never be dug.. most others bounce back with little or no impact ...

    WHY ADD VARIABLES.. SUCH AS POTS.. TO MAKE YOUR LIFE MISERABLE ...

    can it be done.. sure.. why not

    should it be done.. WHY?????

    ken

    ps: refer to the post on moving fully leafed out hosta ...

    PPS: ALWAYS!!!!! ALWAYS .... go for the simple solution.. once you dream up variables .. all you are dreaming up .... is options on failure ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    The variables must apply here. While Ken has acres to space out into, no maple issues, and sandy soil, many of us do not, which by using containers makes it possible for us to grow hosta at all. What works in rural Michigan may not be the best solution for suburban subdivisions elsewhere.

    When soil is inhospitable compacted clay,
    when maple roots abound,
    when beds aren't ready for permanent plantings,
    when there is no more room for another hosta,
    when a young plant needs to grow on,
    Pots give us time and flexibility. Just saying.

  • 17 years ago

    Excellent points, Maryann and I might add, when elevation of hosta makes them more viewable
    (is that a word?) pots and barrels do help make them, as a mass sea of hosta, more pleasing
    to the eye!!

    Unless you're planting on a hillside, the hosta can virtually disappear in tight plantings,
    where you want to be able to have and enjoy many hosta, but, as Maryann pointed out,
    but don't have acres to play with!! Kinda jealous of ken's acreage--but then--I'd have to
    walk so far to see them all!LOL NOT--that I can't use the excuse for more exercise! Ahem!!