Software
Houzz Logo Print
ptilda

Making a list...

17 years ago

I had a list of top "must-get" hostas for the year, and have gotten 4 of the 8! So, I need to build my list again, or I don't have an excuse to buy a hosta I see, 'cause I HAVE to have it! lol

Any suggestions are appreciated. Below is the list, with those I now have, indicated after the name. This gives you an idea of what I'm interested in:

Sagae (have it)

Earth Angel (have it)

Liberty

Rainforest Sunrise

Blue Mouse Ears (have it)

Spilt Milk

Guardian Angel

Krossa Regal (have it)

So, besides the 4 remaining, what do you recommend I get this year?

Comments (22)

  • 17 years ago

    How many were you thinking? LOL I think you need all of these for the bones of your garden: June, Touch of Class, Blue Mouse Ears, Regal Splendor, Fragrant Bouquet, Olive Bailey Langdon, elegans, Guacomole, Halcyon, Sum and Substance, Gold Standard, Blue Angel, Guardian Angel, Abiqua Drinking Gourd or Love Pat, Summer Breeze, Jewel of the Nile, Niagra Falls, Striptease or Kiwi Full Monty, montana Aureomarginata, ventricosa, Sunpower and of course Liberty to honor Papou and because it is a great hosta. I am sure I have left off several, but any of these are good hostas.

  • 17 years ago

    guardian angel

    sum and substance or an edged version ... winter snow is incredible ....

    aw heck.. and about 1000 more ...

    we are enablers.. and you have an illness ... lol

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    I've only been into this for the past year but based on so many suggestions here, one that I have is Paul's Glory . . . really impressive! I also like Fried Bananas, August Moon, and Captain Kirk.
    I'm like you. There are so many on my wish list. I was happy that I had most of the ones Mary & Ken had suggested, but not ALL! Just more that I need to add to my list!

  • 17 years ago

    I ADORE St. Paul!
    I'm into the dark margined ones right now!

  • 17 years ago

    IMO, Liberty is a must have. Another very nice one to add to your list is Paradigm.

  • 17 years ago

    I like what mary52 says. There are basics that make up the bones of your garden, and her list is excellent. In fact, everything mentioned here falls in that category. I would add Whirlwind, one of my very favorites, although not everyone has success with it. Halcyon is also a must. It's my all-time best blue.

    And, as Ken says, there are at least another 1000. Hah, hah!

  • 17 years ago

    Spring Fling
    Frosted Jade
    Nigrescens
    Sagae
    Ventricosa'Variegated Aureomarginata'
    Abba Dabba Do
    Blue Angel
    How many do you want us to list,ha ha
    cAROL

  • 17 years ago

    'Summer Breeze' will very quickly give you a good return for your money and effort!!

    'August Moons' are wonderful for dividing and placing in dark areas to draw attention to other hosta!

  • 17 years ago

    pair-a-dig-um ... to die for .... paradigm ... oops.. don got that one.. and liberty as he suggests ..

    skip jewel of the nile.. i have to dig it up every 2 years to take deee's golden jewel off it ... i officially declared i give up on trying to maintain it... as numerous others have the same problem ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    plantaginea for sure...

    6 inch pure white flowers that remind one of gardenias...

    and it will grow in near full sun anywhere ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    Maybe---making a list of what NOT to get, will be easier and shorter! LOL

  • 17 years ago

    Ok you guys! Everytime one of you mentions a hosta, I have to look it up and then add it to my list!

    I have to have Grand Canyon after looking at that thread and now Ken......Winter Snow....beautiful! I love the rippled edges.

    I give up. I agree hey_j.......a list of what not to get.....are there really any of those??

    I would have to say Liberty is my favorite, bought one last year and loved it so much I bought another this year.

    June Fever
    Paradise Power
    Pauls Glory

    I could go on and on...........

    LOL!

    Ms Jo

  • 17 years ago

    So, after going through your recommendations, eliminating what I already have, and adding some others that I had towards the top of the list, here's the new list:

    (number of [#] indicates how much I want it!)

    1. Liberty##########
    2. Rainforest Sunrise#####
    3. Guardian Angel#####
    4. Paradigm####
    5. Spilt Milk###
    6. Olive Bailey Langdon###
    7. Summer Breeze##
    8. Tattoo##
    9. Montana 'Aureomarginata'##

    1. Dream Queen##
    2. Touch of Class##
    3. Dream Weaver##
    4. Maui Buttercups##
    5. Ventricosa Areomarginata##
    6. Fair Maiden##
    7. Old Glory##
    8. First Frost##
    9. Grand Tiara##

    Any input? Anything on this list that you DON'T recommend?

  • 17 years ago

    Hmmmm...you don't need both Dream Queen and Dream Weaver since you can't tell 'em apart. I'm not sure about Fair Maiden, Zilis says it gets a drawstring edge...maybe El Nino would be better, but you're getting First Frost which is similar to El Nino. Summer Breeze can get beat up by slugs so if you like this one, I'd recommend Summer Lovin' which is a tetraploid of Summer Breeze with thicker leaves. Grand Tiara is nice, but Grand Prize is nicer. And finally, don't you want any large puckered blues or golds like Abiqua Drinking Gourd/Love Pat/Big Daddy (blues) and Aspen Gold/Midas Touch/Fat Cat (golds)?

  • 17 years ago

    Good points, Don. I'll make a note that it's Dream Queen OR Dream Weaver.

    I think El Nino looks different enough from Fair Maiden, that I'd like Fair Maiden. I love the edge from the photos that I've seen. Anyone else had this Hosta who can give some input?

    As far as Summer Breeze goes, I love the look of that hosta, and I seldom have issues with slugs. I think they freeze out here in the great white north & just have a hard time coming back or something. I've seen them a couple of times, but they don't manage a lot of damage to the plants.

    As far as the big puckered blues, I already have Love Pat, and ADG and Big Daddy are both on my "someday" list, just not on my "top"/"must-have" list.

    For the golds, I have Aspen Gold and Fat Cat on my "someday" list. If I were to move one of those three to my "must-have" list, which would you recommend?

  • 17 years ago

    I discovered your forum recently and am hooked. I have always loved hostas, but haven't paid attention to what I've planted. Guess I need to start keeping track of the names! Also, plan to buy a lottery ticket now that I have so many recommendations from all of you! Thanks for all your marvelous ideas!!

  • 17 years ago

    I purchased Earth Angel 2 years ago and this year the slugs had a feast.

    These put on a show for me:

    Warwick Comet a true round leaf
    Dawns Early Light best yellow from early spring to now
    June and I agree with Ms Jo on June Fever too
    St. Paul for sure great substance
    Catherdral Windows what a good grower and upright

    Every year's a new choice pick - feeds the habit.

    Deb

  • 17 years ago

    and if you have a decent great expects.. you dont need either dream weaver or queen ...

    and 8 tattoos have died in my yard ... skip it IMHO ...

    and get teh streaked SS from which i keep getting more and more winter snow ...

    blizzard i think ... in other words.. buy one.. and end up with two.. if you keep dividing off the reversions ...

    ken

    Here is a link that might be useful: link

  • 17 years ago

    Here is one of my Fair Maidens, the better looking one of course. I highly recommend it. I love the silvery-green color in the leaf. It almost looks artificial!

    Tanya

  • 17 years ago

    I really like Fair Maiden, too. I have read several complaints about its habit of drawstringing, but I haven't really noticed that on my plant. The margins can tear, especially later in the summer, but it's lovely in the spring and pretty darn good the rest of the summer too.

    {{gwi:1029924}}

  • 17 years ago

    Tanya and Lois, thanks SO much for sharing! Those photos certainly make me want to give it a try! Any suggestions as to why some drawstring & others don't? For example, what kind of water/sun situations do you have for those in the photos? I would think that ample water would benefit, as would maybe more shade?

    Thanks to everyone helping me shorten my list, and to those helping it get longer! Like you, I'm torn. But I'm not worried about it at this point, 'cause I have some time before I can afford to buy more anyhow.

  • 17 years ago

    "Thanks to everyone helping me shorten my list, and to those helping it get longer!" Yeh, we can make it a lot longer...afterall, what are enablers for??? LOL