Software
Houzz Logo Print
dottyinduncan

I want BIG hostas

21 years ago

I visit other gardens and see these magnificent huge hostas with enormous leaves. Mine are puny in comparison and get smaller as time goes on. Is it the variety, or the fertilizing that makes them big? The one I have in a pot right now is Elegans and it is flowering, but not the lush attractiveness that you want in a hosta. What about soil? I would appreciate tips from super hosta growers.

Comments (13)

  • 21 years ago

    The important point is why yours are getting smaller. You must describe your situation and methods in more detail to get useful help with this.

  • 21 years ago

    I have them planted in three places -- a perennial garden (about 7 years), a shade garden - 2 years -- these are almost gone and one in a pot on my patio. The Perennial ones are small, sorry I don't know what kind they are, I've given up on the shade garden ones -- it is awful, clay soil and quite dark, but the one on the patio is planted in a combo of aged chicken manure and potting soil, has been fertilized and watered regularly, although I think I am under fertilizing. It is stalled in size and isn't sort of "settling into" the pot like it should. I was mainly wondering if it is the variety vs growing conditions.

  • 21 years ago

    I've read lots about hostas in the hosta forum. Some reasons they've mentioned for hostas decreasing in size or failing to thrive are lack of water due to root competition or planting the hosta too deep. The crown of the hosta should be just below the soil. If you dig around them and see lots of white petioles before you find the crown you may have them planted too deep. My understanding is that hostas don't need lots of fertilizer... just lots of water during the growing season. Some people have really good luck fertilizing them with alfalfa, though.

  • 21 years ago

    Oh -- and they'll tell you that hostas are shade tolerant, not shade loving. They grow much faster in some sun... just make sure they get enough water so the leaves don't burn.

  • 21 years ago

    Thanks Kitten. I didn't realize there was a hosta forum. I'll lurk there for a while. I think you are right.Everywhere I try to plant things there are roots. We have huge firs on the property and do have a lot of shade. It is likely competition from everything else.

  • 21 years ago

    Dear Dotty,

    You mean like this :)? These are grown in part shade. Each winter, each crown gets a wheelbarrow full of well rotted compost.

    Sum and Substance foreground, Sagae in pot.

  • 21 years ago

    OOOOOHHHHH! You are just teasing me! That's exactly what I want. Cute little girl too. Thanks for the neat pic.

  • 21 years ago

    Ooooooooooooooooooooooh from me too!
    And, yes, that is a darling young lady! Sum and Substance is going on my 'want' list. I already have a darling young lady.

  • 21 years ago

    I would suspect competing roots and too dry conditions too. I know I planted some hosta near a hedge in dry soil full of hedge roots and they stunted and didn't grow at all. I think we have this misconception that hostas can grow in any shady spot.

  • 21 years ago

    I recently moved a hosta that I thought was doing quite well under a fir tree (limbed up the tree and the poor thing was getting sunburned) I'd had it several years and it always made a lovely lush mound. Well - surprise! Moved it to moister soil and no fir tree competition...thing has taken off like mad! Obviously, while it 'grew' under the fir in the shade, it did not thrive!

  • 21 years ago

    Beautiful hostas. I also am having the same problem as DottyinDuncan. Thank you all so much for giving me all these ideas as to why my hostas are so small. I have been moving them out from under the fir trees this summer and they seem to be much happier. Thanks again.

  • 21 years ago

    I plan to divide my 'Sum and Substance' hostas for the Fall Eastside Green Elephant Plant Swap.

    FYI

    FireVicar

    Here is a link that might be useful: Green Elephant Plant Swap