Software
Houzz Logo Print
sedum37

Help me identify this plant

20 years ago

Can anyone help me identify a flowering tree/shrub flowering now in Massachusetts? It is probably no taller than 8 or 10 feet tall and the flowers apper in late July into August. It is actually one of the few flowering shrubs/trees out this time of year. The flowers are kind of like hardy hibiscus but much smaller. The flower petals are single and flat (not double or full). Often the shrub is trimmed in an inverted V shape. I've seen it with white, light blue, pink shades for the flowers.

A call to a local nursery told me they thought it was a hardy hibiscus but the photos I've seen of this the flowers seem much too large.

I know this is a bad description but I have faith in this group!

Anyone identify this?

Thanks!

Sue

Comments (21)

  • 20 years ago

    Sure it's not Rose of Sharon (althea)? Sounds a lot like that and they're blooming around here (northwest-central CT) ...

  • 20 years ago

    Sue, I was thinking the same thing - sounds like Rose of Sharon. They are in bloom around here too.

    :)
    Dee

  • 20 years ago

    The genus is hibiscus ("hibiscus syriacus") so you'd be partly correct! Do these pictures look like what you're seeing? (and are there lots of butterflies/hummingbirds on them??) The "inverted V" has me a little confused -- I think of them more as having a regular "V" (vase-like) shape, narrower at the bottom than the top...

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pictures of Rose of Sharon

  • 20 years ago

    I agree that you are probably observing the Rose of Sharon. Here are some pictures of mine, a variety called Lucy. The flowers are double instead of the singles that you have been seeing but the pics should still help you positively ID the plant.

    {{gwi:238267}}

    {{gwi:238270}}

    {{gwi:238272}}

  • 20 years ago

    Tree_oracle -- what a perfectly beautiful Rose of Sharon! What's it called? (I'll have to add that to my new "bird-and-butterfly" garden!) It looks very happy (do you do anything special to get such lush foliage and blooms?)

  • 20 years ago

    oooooh! Lucy is gorgeous! I'm not a huge RoS fan, but I really like those double flowers!

    :)
    Dee

  • 20 years ago

    Sorry, Tree_Oracle -- thanks to Dee, I see that the variety is right there in your post -- I read right past it, I was so anxious to get to those gorgeous photos (maybe I should read these posts BEFORE I have that glass of wine, not AFTER... ;) I'll have to look for Lucy!!

  • 20 years ago

    I have Lucy too. It is absolutely awesome!!! The JB's love it, but I've been spraying here and there and its been fine so far.

    I prune mine to about 3' every other late winter and it grows fat and tall to about 6' and is smothered with buds right now. Mine is just starting to get going blooming.

  • PRO
    20 years ago

    I just planted a double white (of course) and it is stunning!

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks guys! I think you are right. I knew I could count on this group for an ID. Sorry about the confusion of the inverted V description, I meant to say a V shape and typed too quickly...

    Wow Tree_oracle those are really nice photos! Thanks for posting. I love the color and will look for that variety.

    Ctlady thinks for the link over at DavesGarden. I read the reviews and there are quite a few opinions, mostly positive. There are some possible negatives that it self seeds readily and that it is slow to leaf out in spring. This plant is for my MIL for her birthday and she has admired this plant for years (as it blooms around her birthday). I am only hesitant to give it to her that it could be a nuisance that self seeds? Anyone have any comments about this?

    Thanks!!
    Sue

  • 20 years ago

    The seeding nuisance is an issue with the older varieties of Rose-of-Sharon. Many of the newer varieties and I think all of the doubles tend to be sterile. My Lucy is a tree form ROS. I got it around four years ago and it has grown considerably since. It has a big thick trunk on it now. The flowers are a little darker pink than what is shown in the pictures. Also, the blooms turn purple as they fade and curl up so you get more than one color. I fertilize mine once a year with Miracle Gro Rose Food. It's not that high in nitrogen which is better for blooming plants. One note, the ROS is one of the last plants to leaf out in the spring so don't be so quick to dig it up thinking it was killed by the winter cold. They are actually one of the hardiest plants that I know. Very poor soil and drought tolerant and very winter hardy.

  • 20 years ago

    ALL new cultivars of ROS with names derived from the Greek mythology (Aphrodite, Diane, Helen etc) are guaranteed sterile. MOST, but not ALL of the doubles are sterile, too.

  • 20 years ago

    Ooohhh, isn't that great that they are sterile! I have refrained from planting any just for the reason that they reseed so prolifically. And 'guaranteed sterile, wow, didn't realize they could do that. I will be looking for one of those this fall... :-) Thanks for the info!

  • 20 years ago

    I like the sterile idea too. Last thing I want is to have to worry about ripping out seedlings. Like I said, I'm not a huge RoS fan, but I think I may look into one of these newer ones. I can always use the blooms at this time of year.

    :)
    Dee

  • 20 years ago

    Yes Dee, I agree, a lot is winding down in my garden too and I just never have enough starting to bloom this time of year. BUT, I have a question for anyone that can answer it...I was over on the Seed Exchange, and saw someone post their tradelist offering seed from Rose of Sharon and listed the exact varieities George mentioned..Aphroditie, Diane and Helen. So, is it that they produce NO seed, or no viable seed? I posted a link to the tradelist.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Tradelist with Rose of Sharon seed offered

  • 20 years ago

    All you need to know about triploids ROS is in a link from originator, US National Arboretum.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Aphrodite, Helen, Minerva

  • 20 years ago

    Lucy definitely does not reseed here. I have never seen a seedling from my Lucy in several years.

    I am suprised that tree_oracle states drought tolerant. I always thought all hibiscus family were very thirsty. I water mine a lot. Mine is in extremely well drained soil on a slight slope.

    I would also emphasis that these need very good sun. I had to move mine to this sunnier location from its previous spot that was not as sunny as I thought. It bloomed very poorly there, but does great here. I also feed and water it better in this new location that is closer to the house so that might be part of it also. Too many variables ...

  • 20 years ago

    The reseeds are really easy to rip out. Most that do reseed come true. It's more a matter of remembering to do it (she says after pulling no fewer than 100 dogwood seedlings out this afternoon :-)

    A girlfriend collects ROS with an emphasis on the older varieties. She swears by full sun, and if the shrubs get 1" of water a month after they're established she thinks that's enough.

    And as for seeds ... IMHE most everything produces some type of seed-looking organism. Folks sometimes don't know that the seeds they're offering won't do a thing. I don't think this is intentional, just not-yet-educated.

    Who could live without these beauties?

    Martie

  • 20 years ago

    So, how do we tell now which ones are sterile (besides the double flowered kinds), and which are fertile? I've driven by a mature RoS in my area for years. It is a gorgeous mauvy purple, and is growing on the remote end of a double lot that doesn't get tended or mowed. I have never seen any offspring overtaking the property. It has to be at least 20 years old.

    Personally, I wouldn't mind seedlings. Especially if they breed true, as Martie mentions. I'd love to pot them up and share them at swaps, pot them as outdoor container plants, and try RoS bonsai. :)

    Now, if only the weed Norway maple in my side garden were sterile!

    Confidential to Martie: I went foraging through my viburnums last week, and the darned things were sending up whips like crazy. You're right - they aren't caners. I thought that the V. opulum/triloba was caning, but it was in fact sending a whip from the very base of the main trunk. Looks like I'm going to be spending the winter reviewing my Michael Dirr books. I guess I always thought of them as caning because the whips are long and prominent greenwood, and you can prune them back hard like canes. Anyway, I retract my grouping of viburnums! Sub in Nikko Blue hydrangeas instead. I spent last spring lopping back zillions of dead canes.lol

  • 20 years ago

    Cady, I was going to mention the exact same thing earlier in this thread - I've driven by RoS for years in not only my current neighborhood, but in past neighborhoods, where the yards were obviously not tended, and the RoS never changed! Either that one RoS never got any buddies, or the row of them along a boundary line never got any new ones. I would always think to myself that this perplexed me, as I'd always heard they reseed, and yet these particular yards were never well-tended.

    Well, no matter to me, because I like that double-flowered Lucy. I think I'll start with her. You notice I said "start"... I'm honest enough to admit that while I'm not a big RoS fan, I know enough about myself to know that one will probably lead to a love affair, and therefore more RoS will follow...

    :)
    Dee

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks for everyone's help. I was able to get 'Ardens' at Lake Street Garden Center in Salem. This one is a double and is sterile so no seeding problem. Here is a photo:

    {{gwi:1088544}}

    MIL loved the plant. Always good to be on the good side of one's MIL!

    They had a great selection at Lake Street Garden Center. They had the 'Aphrodite' and 'Helena' mentioned by ego45 and 'Lucy' from tree_oracle. They had others from the Chiffon series but I could not find info on whether or not the seeds were sterile. MIL wanted a double so this seemed like a good fit. Unfortunately 'Lucy' was to big to fit in the car I had at my last minute purchase there 30 minutes before they were closing!