Software
Houzz Logo Print
narcnh

Showy Goldenrod

20 years ago

Included in my order of heathers from Rock Spray was a 'Showy Goldenrod'. Checking it out in the web it appears to be very pretty in bloom (but I think all Goldenrods are pretty, when in bloom, as long as they are 'out there' and not 'in here'). So, I planted it in the back of my main garden.

Am I making a mistake? Does anyone grow it or know if it is very invasive?

narcnh

Comments (9)

  • 20 years ago

    narcnh,
    I have goldenrods in my garden...when I remember not to rip them out in the spring. My thought is that they aren't that invasive...I always wished I hadn't removed so many, especially this time of year! Wonderful cut flower.

    I don't think you have made a mistake at all. They "rip out" very easily if you think you don't like where they have traveled.

    Emily

  • 20 years ago

    I have always loved goldenrod. I am sure we would all want it for our gardens if it weren't so common in the fields and by roadsides. They grow our goldenrods in gardens in England and elsewhere. I did grow a named cultivar from seed years ago and planted them in my garden but they got very bad mildew--not enough sun. So I have to enjoy the wildflowers--and I do.

  • 20 years ago

    I have three or four species growing naturally in various spots, and just leave them be because they are lovely when in flower, and unintrusive when their not. In the winter, the dried stalks and seedheads are attractive additions to the landscape.

    As was noted, they aren't truly invasive, although they are vigorous. But their roots are shallow and it's easy to pull up any that are out of bounds. I occasionally yank a few (not without feelings of guilt) and thin clumps that are crowding out other plants. All it takes is one thinning a year, and they are well behaved.

  • 20 years ago

    I just brought home Solidago 'Fireworks' from the NEWFS and was wondering the same thing. I have never grown it before. I saw it used in PAllenSmith's garden and thought it didn't even look like a goldenrod, it was so showy. He used it in a border backed by a huge old fashioned rose.

    So I have the pot sitting there waiting to be planted and I am on the fence about where to put it. I am very happy to hear that it is shallow rooted and easy to pull out. I was actually thinking of growing it in an area that I planned on putting sunflowers next year, since they seem to be in bloom at the same time.

    I really haven't noticed goldenrod in the landscape or what it is growing with that much I guess. I have read they grow with asters a lot. I only have one aster so far, so I really want to add more of those and maybe put those two together. Guess I will be experimenting with it for awhile.

    Thanks :-)

  • 20 years ago

    The on-line description and photos of Showy Goldenrod indicate that it has pyramidal flower heads that donÂt bend over, unlike most of the other goldenrods. When walking around the cornfields yesterday evening I noticed several stands of goldenrod with pyramidal heads that were upright. So, maybe I already have some out there. Guess I'll know when this one blooms next year.

    Thanks for the assurances about growing it. My last house was occupied by renters before me, who did not maintain anything in the yard, and the main garden was completely covered in goldenrod. I had to use a blade on a weed whacker to cut them down and the remains were like punji sticks in the ground. Took over two years to eliminate all the survivors, runners, etc. Once I removed the goldenrod, I found several evergreen shrubs that had somehow managed to survive being completely overgrown. So, as I said, while I really like goldenrod Âout there I am kind of paranoid about having it Âin hereÂ. IÂll keep an eye on it.

    Right now, all the unmaintained fields in the area are in full goldenrod bloom. It is really very beautiful en masse and to me one of the signatures of late summer/early fall in New England, as are the asters. Clumps of wild Black-Eyed Susans are also still blooming out there. Like the observations made on another thread about weeds and ÂdesirablesÂ, itÂs all in the eye of the beholder (and the spade of the gardener).

    narcnh

  • 20 years ago

    I don't know what variety of goldenrod I've got, but it is distinctly NOT showy! It's not one with glossy leaves - maybe if I get an id on it I'll like it better or know how to deal with it more effectively. It seems to be everywhere, presumably bird-sown. If it wasn't so prolific, I wouldn't mind, but I also find it hard to remove - by which I mean that pulling it up by hand just seems to produce more shoots.

    A sweet little old lady at a plant sale told me that I could not have a garden without solidago, and I believed her. So much for SLOLs. It's a great plant for wild places, but my yard is just too small and crowded for it to fit in.

  • 20 years ago

    Funny, I have been thinking off and on of adding goldenrod to my garden for awhile now, and just have not decided not only whether or not to do it, but also which one to get.

    After reading this thread yesterday, I began thinking about it again. Today I walk out to a far corner of my yard, near my raised beds, and what's in bloom but a few stands of goldenrod! Never saw it before, but there it was! Lots of wild stuff in the area so it must have come from the neighborhood. I guess I'll leave it and see how it does.

    Down the street there was a field where they had sheep, and adjoining this was another field which was absolutely massed with goldenrod, and just ablaze in the fall. It was the most gorgeous spot on the street, IMO, at least at this time of the year. Sadly, the sheep are gone, the shed is razed, and a large house now sits on that spot. I did take a few photos before they built the house, to remind me of that glorous sight, but unfortunately it was a combination of a cloudy day and a broken light meter on the camera, so a lot of imagination is needed, lol!

    :)
    Dee

  • 20 years ago

    Hi dtd,

    Thanks very much for sharing your experience. I am rethinking whether I am going to put mine in. I also have a small property and I would be concerned about anything that sprouts more as you pull it. I just finally got something under control that has been driving me crazy for a long time that was just like that, so I am gunshy. [g]

    I may take it back and exchange it for something else.

    Thanks :-)

  • 20 years ago

    It has appeared uninvited in my garden too but I had no trouble pulling it out. Of course, as I mentioned, I have a lot of shade so sun-lovers don't really get a foothold here, wanted or not.