Software
Houzz Logo Print
ginak08

HELP! Entire garden dying

16 years ago

Hello,

I am new to this forum. I stumbled upon it while trying to figure out what to do. I have a vegetable garden (two 4x8 raised beds) with tomatoes, onions, squash, zuchini, peppers, and corn. I started my plants from seed back in March or April.

My plants have been thriving wonderfully and just this week I was SO excited to see 4 little squashes, a zucchini and several tomato blossoms. Yesterday, I fertilized everything.

This morning, my husband fertilized the lawn with Scott's turfbuilder with weed control. He accidentally got some of it in my garden. I asked him if that was ok and he said it would all be fine. We were getting ready to leave the house so I did not have time to do my research. When we came home this afternoon, I checked on my garden to find the tomatoes and squash almost completely wilted. I was devastated. I immediately hosed them off, but they were (and still are) wilted pretty bad.

I called Scott's and asked them. They said turfbuilder is designed for lawns only and *could* kill anything else. The girl I spoke with said to try thoroughly watering my plants to wash the stuff off, but the plants are damaged, and Scott's advises against eating anything from the plants.

Has anyone had any experience with anything like this? I am completely heartbroken. This is my very first garden and I have worked so hard on it and was SO close to harvest. I am thinking I should just start over from seeds but I know it is pretty late in the season. My husband thinks if I water the garden everyday they will bounce back and still be fine to eat. What do you all think? My onions and corn look fine so far. The peppers have some brown spots on the leaves, but aren't totally wilted like the tomatoes and squash.

Thank you in advance for any advice.

Comments (11)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Weed control is weed killer. I wouldn't give it a second thought. If Scott's says don't eat it, I would insist that my husband throw it all away. I would call Scotts again to see if you can grow something else in the soil. Regardless of what they say, I would discard any soil that could have been hit.

    I have a relevant story that would not interest you now, but I, too have lost everything. We learn. Someone else here will tell you what you can start growing at this time of year.

    I am sorry to hear this, but you haven't eaten it, and that is a good thing. It takes a long time to explain to husbands how to help and how not to help. Even words like "Don't ever for any reason touch my ant bait. Never never never. But he put it on his squash that he must throw away.

    Sammy

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'm sure the more experienced gardeners will be along shortly to give you more info but I would consider anything that could possibly have been hit by the weed control to be toxic. I hate to use such a strong word but do you really want to ingest (sp?) something that has been sprayed with poison... no matter what the poison was targeting.

    Get some containers, drill holes in the bottom and start with some fresh transplants. Check with a local farmers grain type store - they usually have some of the best plants over the big box types. Put your containers on your patio - not on the raised bed or on the grass where the spray has been.

    You'll still get a crop and not much later than you would have with your inground plants.

    I'm sorry this happened to you. It is very hard to give up on the plants you've babied all along to this point but it's just not worth the risk to eat anything that comes from the contaminated area. You'll need to research exactly what chemical was used and how long it will stay in your soil before you have safely plant there again.

    Best of luck.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I am sorry about your plants and it is just unfortunate that this occurred. For the record (and I am sure you understand this by now), anytime a chemical herbicide is accidently put into a bed of edible crops, the result is that a plant disaster occurs and, even worse, your soil is now contaminated with a chemical product not approved for use on edible crops.

    I agree with the others. If your spouse used Scott's Turfbuilder with Weed Control, it undoubtedly had the weedkiller 2,4-D in it and that is a very toxic weedkiller. Dogs exposed to it for a prolonged period of time have developed serious health issues. In fact, 2, 4 D was one of the major ingredients in Agent Orange and I wouldn't be comfortable using it anywhere on our property because of its toxic properties. You have to consider what such chemical products do not just to plants, but to people, pets, farm animals and wildlife.

    Luckily, 2, 4-D breaks down fairly quickly in the soil but I wouldn't eat any food from soil treated with 2, 4 D. For how long? That is a hard question. Knowing me, I'd probably write off this year's beds as too contaminated to use this year, and garden elsewhere---probably in containers as was already suggested---and maybe use those beds next year. By then, the 2, 4 D should be well through its half life and mostly or completely out of the soil. It isn't just the active ingredient 2, 4 D that you have to worry about but inert ingredients that aren't even listed on the labels (I believe a new law will change that) of such products.

    If Scott's cannot give you the half-life of the active ingredient (the weedkiller) in the product your husband used, you might be able to find it on the internet.

    There are different Scott's Turf Builder products, but the one with weed control usually contains 2, 4 D. I've linked the MSDS (Material Safety Data Sheet) for one of the Scott's Turf Builder products below, although it may not be the exact one your spouse used. Read the MSDS carefully and ask yourself if you'd eat food grown in soil contaminated by this stuff. Note too the very last line about it being a violation of federal law to use a pesticide in a manner not consistent with its label. That means they're legally off the hook for any damages resulting from the misuse of their product (allowing it to fall into an edible gardening area would be considered a misuse of it because it isn't labeled for that type of usage). Also, the dangers they mention come from routine exposure during the proper use of the product and exposure to food grown in soil contaminated with it is not a routine exposure during the proper use of the product, so it is not specifically addressed.

    It would be best to consider this an important learning experience on the risk of using herbicides around plants you don't want to kill, and just write off the veggies in those beds this year. Remember, herbicides are non-selective and kill everything in the class they're intended to kill.


    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: MSDS for Scotts Turf Builder with Weed Control

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I just wanted to say I feel sad for you. I know how disappointing it is to see all that work ruined.

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you so much for all of the advice. Dawn, I called Scott's a few minutes ago ad asked about the half life. They said it is less than 7 days. The girl there told me I should be fine to replant in a week or so, but I still don't know.

    My husband did not get a whole lot of the weedkiller in the garden, it was only some that ended up in there on accident when he was fertilizing the rest of the yard, however it was enough to kill most of my plants. As I said the onions, corn, and upon further inspection looks like the zucchini may have been spared. I am still going to pull EVERYTHING out of there and destroy it though and start with fresh plants or sees. Not sure if it makes a difference but it is the stuff that looks like kitty litter and not a liquid.

    Also, I will wait until AT LEAST next Monday to put anything in the ground to make sure it has the full 7 days. I am also thinking of taking a soil sample to our county extension office to see what they say about it... does anyone know if they can test soil there?

    I am also thinking of taking the advice from you all and maybe just container garden one or two tomato plants, a pepper plant and some onions and maybe a squash or two, depending on how cheap I can find large enough containers.

    If I can afford to go the container route (I have to get something heavy, I had a container of strawberries and the wind kept blowing it across the yard and dumping it out) I might just do that and maybe plant some other stuff in one of the garden beds in a month or so (corn, pumpkins) and use the second bed even later for things like lettuce, spinach and/or broccoli.

    What do you all think of that idea given the new information from Scott's on the half life? And also, do you have any tips for container gardening or recommendations for good tomato and pepper varieties for containers? I am really only interested in bell peppers and prefer roma tomatoes or something else suitable for canning.

    Thank you all again for all of your advice. I think I am going to stick around this forum even after my woes are resolved. You all seem so helpful here and I was up to the wee hours this morning reading a whole bunch of previous posts!

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Gina,

    I know that seven days is their standard reply to questions, but it also varies depending on what kind of soil you have. In some soils, some tests have shown it to persist for up to 50 days or longer. From what I could find via a few minutes of internet research, it seems like the weedkiller biodegrades most quickly in soil that has a high humus/compost content because soil with a high humus/compost content has microbes that help break it down. If, by chance, you have very sandy soil that is lacking in a humus/compost content, you may find it persists longer than expected.

    If you want to reuse those beds this season, I'd water them daily for 7-10 days in an effort to flush it out of the soil and to help it break down more quickly. Then, before I replanted anything there, I'd plant a dozen beans in the soil, water them and see if they sprout. Because beans sprout quickly and are fast-growing, they often are used to test herbicide-contaminated soil to see if the herbicide remains active in the soil. If the beans sprout and grow normally, the soil should be fine for planting and growing something. If the beans don't sprout, or if they sprout and then die within the first or second week, then the herbicide remains active.

    You could try calling your local OSU agriculture extension agent and ask how soon you could plant edible crops in the herbicide-contaminated soil. I'm sure this type of misdirected herbicide damage occurs frequently and they've been asked this question before.

    Even if everyone says it is safe, I still wouldn't plant any root crops in these beds until next year because root crops are more likely to absorb any sort of residue from the soil.

    Since it was the granular kind, there's a chance you could have used a shop vac to vacuum up all the tiny granules right after the stuff went into your bed. You might want to file away that idea in case anything like this happens again. My well-meaning husband kills stuff all the time, especially when he has a weedeater in his hands, so he is (nicely of course) generally banned from doing any work inside my fenced garden. He understands why, having destroyed many plants over the years....including young fruit trees. He always feels terrible about it, but that doesn't bring back whatever he just killed.

    You can get certain soil tests done through OSU and I'll link the soil test website for you. I don't know that they test for herbicide contamination though. That sort of testing is very expensive. I'm sure someone from OSU or the Extension Service could tell you, without testing, what the residual effect of that specific weedkiller would be in vegetable garden soil, if any.

    For container gardening, I used TIDY CAT cat litter buckets for peppers and for other small edible plants. I spray paint them either a very dark green or brown with Fusion paint (specifically made for plastics) and drill several large (quarter-sized) drainage holes in the bottom. My favorite containers for indeterminate tomato plants are molasses feed tubs which a local rancher gave me about 10 years ago. They hold about 20-25 gallons of soil. Lots of people grow tomato plants in large storage totes like the Rubbermaid Roughneck totes. Just drill holes in them and they're ready to go. You can use anything that will hold soil and that has holes drilled in the bottom to allow water to drain out. Any pepper plant I've ever grown in a container has done just fine, but a couple of my favorites are Blushing Beauty and Roumanian Rainbow. Both are very prolific producers. With tomatoes, any of them will do just fine if the container is large enough. Martino's Roma is a paste tomato that sets a huge load of fruit and the plant stays pretty small. Seed of it is available from Tomato Growers Supply Company.

    We're glad you found this forum and have joined our forum family. We have a lot of fun here and this is a very caring and supportive group. We have all kinds of gardeners here.....and you'll almost always find someone who has experience with whatever issue you're dealing with.

    All in all, even though it is a terrible shame that you lost your garden plants, at least the product apparently breaks down quickly. It could have been much worse if your husband had been using something that contained aminopyralid or clopyralid. That stuff can persist for years.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Soil, Water and Forage Analytical Lab at OSU

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    sending you hugs :)
    and my grocery store has a bakery and the empty five gallon containers,white are only 50 cents each,you can have your hubby drill holes in the bottom and he will feel better that he helped you recover

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "My well-meaning husband kills stuff all the time, especially when he has a weedeater in his hands, so he is (nicely of course) generally banned from doing any work inside my fenced garden."

    Dawn, this sounds like something I would do just to reduce the amount of yard work I have to do. ;)

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    We actually drill holes around the base of the sides of the pots. My husband uses a drill to do this, and when I water, if the water comes out, I know it is enough. I have had situations where the holes in the bottom get plugged.

    Whatever you do, the water needs a way out.

    Also I think tomatoes need more mulch than flowers do.

    Sammy

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Wanted to offer my condolences on your garden. Can onions be planted this late? I thought they were cool season veggies.

    I use containers for my tomatos and they are doing fine. I
    am not certain I would try to plant the raised beds again this year, but I kind of have "phobia" about toxic soil. I don't use any chemicals of any kind in my yard at all. But then I butterfly garden. If it hurts them, I certainly wouldn't risk that it could hurt me, too. There are organic ways to get around this, I'm told, but Dawn could probably tell you more about them than I could.

    Hubbies and their lawns are a pair made in heaven!

    Susan

  • 16 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Randy,

    No, say it isn't so! You wouldn't? Would you.......? lol

    My husband is a great guy and generally 110% supportive of my gardening addiction, but if you turn him loose with a weedeater, it can get pretty ugly. He doesn't mean to destroy things, but it happens. Once he was trying to weedeat around a gorgeous 'Pink Lemonade' honeysuckle growing on one side of the cedar arbor he'd built that serves as an entry to my garden. Instead, he took out about 90% of the plant. The poor plant recovered, but the arbor was only half-covered that summer until the plant had time to regrow and climb the arbor again.

    He also can be dangerous when operating the riding mower although he truly does try to go around all the wildflowers until after they've had time to set seed. Last year, I heard him telling one of our neighbors that he shouldn't mow his back pasture until the wildflowers had set seed or his family wouldn't have that gorgeous display of wildflowers the following year. It has taken me a long time to get him to come around to that mindset though.

    And, we won't even talk about how dangerous it is to put a chainsaw in his hands and turn him loose.....but I love him anyway.

    Sammy. Sometimes we drill smaller holes in the side like that too but with the last batch of buckets we didn't and I don't think we'll go back and do it now.

    Susan, You're correct that onions planted now won't bulb up, but they still could be grown, used and enjoyed as green onions.

    And, for anyone dealing with soil contaminated with toxic material of any kind, the standard organic response to cleanse the soil is to add an activated charcoal product called Zeolite to it, although it is pretty pricey in the quantity needed for a large area.

    Otherwise, the best organic option is to add tons and tons and tons of organic matter (compost, composted animal manures, chopped/shredded leaves) and then either white sugar or dry molasses. The organic matter brings in lots of helpful soil microbes (millions of them) and the sugar or molasses help encourage the kind of biological activity needed to help break down herbicide residues. MANY herbicide and pesticide residues break down very slowly and food cannot be grown safely in soils that have those residues. It just happens that the 2, 4 D in the product used is one that breaks down quickly. Even in the soil tests where it persisted over 50 days, that 50 days is nothing at all compared to the known half-life of some pesticides which can number in the hundreds of days.

    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Dirt Doctor's Description of Zeolite's Usage

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting