Probably an Anaheim/New Mexican, but I'll defer to the true identifiers.

Thank you for your response. I didn't have any Anaheim plants yet, so if that is what this is, at least it's not a duplicate with anything else I am growing.

If scale helps in determining the pepper type, the pepper in the picture I posted is about 3.5 inches long.

I feel your pain. those 'bonnie' plants need a label on the pot itself. the only label is on the tray, and there's nothing preventing a shopper from picking up a plant and putting it back in the wrong place. frankly I'm still not 100% that my habanero from lowes is actually a habanero. though I'll certainly know when I bite into it.

The only long sweet pepper that Bonnies sells is Carmen. They are usually more tapered than you photo.

Just based on the pic (not the source) I agree, it looks like a NuMex/Anaheim of some sort. There are a variety of them ranging from sweet to low heat.

edit: Also, I am not familiar with the Carmen that farmerdill mentions is. For all I know, it may be the same type, just more specific.

This post was edited by tsheets on Tue, Jun 4, 13 at 23:07

If it's one of the first couple of peppers, then it's probably a runt and therefore hard to ID.

I'm also guessing Pepper Carmen since it's a Bonnie plant and that it tasted sweet.

Thank you everyone. I will keep an eye on the plant as it gets bigger to see if there is any change in pepper development. I have a "Carmen" plant from Bonnie Plants as well (assuming it's what it is supposed to be" so when it starts producing I can compare.

I'm really not confident that anything I got from them (aside from a banana pepper that is obviously correct) is what it was labeled as (and I bought 6 varieties of peppers when Home Depot was having a sale).