Software
Houzz Logo Print
ronald123_gw

dorsett golden

16 years ago

Anybody in the Florida area who grow the semi tropical apples like Dorsett golden or any of the other Israeli cultivars? Comments and pictures would be apreciated.

Comments (29)

  • 16 years ago

    Ronald:

    I tried them all. Got two apples (not very good either) one year out of about 10 and got rid of them all. Much better apples to be bought in the store than can be grown here in Florida.

    Harry

  • 16 years ago

    Harry and Ronald,
    LOL! It cracks me up that people in Florida try to plant stone fruits and apples and think they will be good! I guess it is the same as me trying to grow tropicals here. My parents have an orchard with several apples, plums, pears, blueberries, strawberries, rhubarb, black and red raspberries. The raspberries are my personal favorite, but the sour baking apples are also a fav! Transparents, Northern spies yummy! I also think the strawberries are superior here. I have had many Florida strawberies and they are too sour and even the sweets are not like ours just my opinion. Can you grow asparagus in FL?
    Andrew

  • 16 years ago

    I have asparagus, this is my 2nd year, they grow into huge 8' plants. Harvested a bit last year, will harvest more this year.

    The peaches I grew were to die for good, super juicy and sweet. My Scarlet beauty plum is good. I have a 42' blueberry bed which is thriving so far, this will be the 2nd year coming up, some plants are up to 6' tall. Apples I have not yet harvested, will try it some this year.

    Gary

  • 16 years ago

    Andrew, I guess it's just the novelty of growing your own, I'm sure some of you would still try with lychee even if it wasn't quite the same as fruit from florida.

    However I thought the quality would have been closer to store bought fruit.

  • 16 years ago

    I second Gary's opinion on the peaches and nectarines we can grow here if we get enough chill. He's north of me and so does much better with chill accumulation. At my house it was just not worth it. When I did get some peaches, they were every bit as good as the fruits I have bought in the store and better than most.

  • 16 years ago

    asparagus? i dont think so, at least not down here.

    i grow alot of tomatoes and cabbage in the winter. i put everything in containers because the nematodes in my yard are crazy.

    i never bothered with stone fruits down here, especially apples. they have some exciting new cultivars of peaches and plums that look promising. someone told me there tropic beauty gave them excellent small peaches, but we had an unusually cold winter last year. nothing can beat a Georgia peach in season at the market.

    i had red delicious, golden delicious and two cherry trees in my home growing up on Long Island. I always admired them.

    im not sure if its something in my blood (i am Indian) or if its because they are not commercially available and exciting but no other fruit in my life made me as obsessive as mangos have recently.

  • 16 years ago

    Mango crush,
    I agree about the mango. I have become obsessed with the fruit. I have stopped at three but will probobly end up with another once I know that the ones I have will grow and fruit.
    Ronald,
    You are absolutley right about the lychee. I havbe never had one but if I really like it I might have to buy a tree. I agree 100% about what you said. There is the whole novelty of growing your own fruit and having oride in doing it. I also think that the fruit are so much better when you can harvest it fresh. I would trade a whole bushel of fresh apples for a bushel of tree ripened citrus. Even when they are in season they are not cheap here. At least to me.
    Harry,
    The fact that you can grow peaches with success does not surprise me. We can grow peaches here because Lake Erie gives us extra protection from the cold in the spring when the buds are opening but there have been years when the peach crop has been destoyed from severe freezes when the trees are blooming. That happened this year with the grape crop. Several areas had little to know grapes. Entire vinyards had there crops destoyed and the farmers had to apply for emergency aid. I am glad you guys can grow asparagus. Strange topic for tropical fruit forum but I love this vegetable and I know the crop is reliant here on a good winter freeze. I wish we had the acess to the citrus like you guys do but I guess the trade off is the apples and other stone fruits we have here. This year most people had bumper crops and the cider was excellent. I am going to try to google citrus farmers and see if anyone does shipping. I have been very dissapointed with what the stores have had this year. I bought four oranges that were just called Florida juice oranges and they were dry, and not very sweet. Four fruits for 2.00 but not worth it IMO.

  • 16 years ago

    I have never in my life had a decent peach from the supermarket. I think peaches are one of those fruit that you can only get good ones if you grow them yourself or live in a peach producing area. Down here we even get Georgia peaches and they are rarely decent. They just pick them too early. I even go to a big farmers market down here and they are still usually mealy and sour or tasteless. I tried a tropic beauty peach last season and it blew any peach I have ever bought away. Lisa on this forum recommended them and I bought a Tropic beauty and a tropic snow. They grew like crazy and I think I will get a nice little crop this year.

  • 16 years ago

    John:

    I generally agree with you. However, I have found great peaches at Costco.....but it isn't all the time. I have bought white fleshed and regular where they were not very good. But sometimes, they are ecxcellent....as good as any I have had....including buying from Harry and David.....or being in the great Northwest during season, or being in Georgia during season. I have not had good luck with Georgia peaches purchased here in South Florida. I generally find the northwest fruit much bigger and a whole lot better. Both Tropic beauty and snow are really good.

    Harry

  • 16 years ago

    Maybe I'll just have to keep looking in the stores. We don't have Costco in my area. Honestly I usually try to buy a few and get so disappointed I don't buy anymore for the rest of the season. I am sure I could probably find better ones if I kept trying but they are not really that cheap so I hate buying them and then find out they are crap when I try them. At the farmers market they even put samples out which taste pretty good, but they must search through and only serve up the best ones because invariably I buy some from that table and they are still crap when I get home.

  • 16 years ago

    John:

    I know the feeling....nothing worse than paying good money for good looking but lousy tasting fruit. I might also suggest the Saturn Peach. Have you seen this. We have had it in our Publix stores. Its a flat shaped peach marketed under several names. Be on the look out....is very fragrant and most often very good despite their wierd shape and pricey cost.

    Here's a shot of what they look like.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 16 years ago

    i have had long island grown peaches, they were good. best peach i ever had was a Georgia in prime season, they are flown in at a premium price.

    i never liked California peaches, maybe it was the variety but most likely they were picked too early. they werent as melting and succulent. we will have to keep tabs this season on what chains are carrying good ones this year.

    theres nothing like a good peach, wish they werent so finicky about temps.

  • 16 years ago

    jsvand5,
    I know what you mean about the store bought fruit. Some years back my sister and I were walking through a Kingston (our capital city) supermarket and my eyes were drawn to this beautiful asian pear. Now I had never heard of them and the price was outlandish, but I just had to try it. It was fantastic, crunchy and sweet, we raved for days and told all our friends about it. For years now I have been looking for something of that quality. Till I have now just reseined myself that we were just lucky that one time and I no longer even try them when I see them available. All I try are simply tasteless, good only if you are thirsty.
    Ronald

  • 16 years ago

    Mangokush: UF has had great low-chill stonefruits out for years. TropicBeauty can give normal sized peaches, you just have to properly thin the tree, which I do. My peaches are tennis ball sized, I get about 40 or 50 now if I protect them against CFF. The first few years CFF didn't bother them.

    I absolutely do have asparagus here in Brevard, grown from a bag of roots from walmart no less. They grew huge, and fast, in lots of organic matter. I expect them to have a short life span, but new plants pop up so that might not matter.

    Ronald, I also had an asian pear a couple years ago and loved it. I think they only grow down to zone 8 unfortunately.

  • 16 years ago

    asian pears do not grow down here, a book i have says they are sub-tropical, but every source says they wont grow below Northern, Florida.

    i guess i will have to just stick with my malay apple, im interested in tasting one.

  • 16 years ago

    Gary i didnt know you were growing asparagus, i read your post after i wrote mine.

    how many chill hours would you say you get on average? i am a little South of you so i think the peaches i hear of maybe didnt get as much chill, or maybe like you say it wasnt thinned. your trees sound pretty large.

    is CFF a problem on all varieties or only the softer ones? i bet the heat makes them sweeten up nice.

  • 16 years ago

    mangokush,
    Never had a malay apple? Do you have a tree?

    Gary,
    How large were your blueberries when you planted them? I made a blueberry bed last year and my blueberries have barely grown. Any tips besides acidifying the soil and using acid-loving plant fertilizer?

  • 16 years ago

    Murahilin:

    I have a malay apple tree. You call it pomerac or something like that, don't you? It has flowered the last two years, but hasn't set any fruit yet. My Trinidadian neighbors also have one and they have gotten fruit from theirs.....but only a couple and I did not get to taste it. My tree has gorgeous huge leaves....which will probably all drop with the coming cold wave.

    Harry

  • 16 years ago

    Harry,
    Yup I call it pommerac. It's one of my favourite fruits. Haven't had any in a few years though. My tree hasn't flowered yet. I'm hoping it will this year. How old/tall was yours before it flowered for the first time? I sprayed mine with freezepruf hoping that it won't lose the leaves or get too damaged from this cold front coming. I'll see how it does.

  • 16 years ago

    yes i have malay apple, its one of my favorite little trees so far, they have a nice growing habit. i hope one day my tree litters my front yard with its flowers like this

    are you growing Jamun as well? they are in the same family but hard to find down here.

  • 16 years ago

    Murahilin, the blueberries were mostly 3gal pots, most have grown well, some, not as much. Mostly southern highbush with 4 rabbitteyes. I built the raised bed out of mostly composted finely ground stuff from the landfill, and topped with pine park and peat moss. Gave it treatments with sulfur about 4 times. Regular irrigation is a big factor. Emerald appears to be a fantastic variety, production, taste, vigor.

    Gary

  • 16 years ago

    mangokush,
    I do not have a jamun tree. I think Excalibur might have it. It is S. cumini right? Or is it a different fruit? Are you from Trinidad or Guyana?

    Gary,
    I think I might not have been treating it with sulfur enough. I only did it once when I planted. I built the raised beds and filled it with peat and pine bark but I still lost 4 plants (out of 8). Does the ph of the water used to water the plants matter? I agree, Emerald is very good.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm sure the irrigation water PH is very important. I don't think I have to worry about it since my well naturally has tannin and such.

    Gary

  • 16 years ago

    murahlin i was born in NY but my father was from Guyana and his parents were first generation from India.

    i never heard of Jamun (S. cumini) until moving down here a little over a year ago and having my Trini neighbor explain it to me.

    in the pictures ive seen it looks to have similar flowers to the malay apple but white. i wonder if it flowers as prolific and covers the ground like malay apple?

  • 16 years ago

    Gary,
    I have city water and the pH is pretty high. I think that might of been part of my problem. I tried to use rain water as much as possible.

    mango kush,
    My wifes parents are also from Guyana. They have some very different names for fruits than we do in Trinidad. Like 'cashew' for malay apple.
    I never had it myself growing up. I am not sure how common it is in Trinidad. A lot of people in Trinidad also refer to the malay apple as jamun. That makes it confusing sometimes when talking about the fruit you have to specify which jamun.

  • 16 years ago

    i read somewhere that they call malay apple cashew in Guyana, found that interesting.

    kinda sad my old man would probably tell me all about these trees i am growing, yet i never knew about them until after he passed and i moved down here.

    my neighbor calls malay apple: pommerac, s. cumini: jamun, seeded breadfruit: chataigne or katahar, carambola: five finger, june plum: pommcythere, mamoncillo: chenet or genip, and of course hes most interested of all in my Julie mango

  • 16 years ago

    In another post I asked you about your seeded breadfruit because it is often mistaken for chataigne. Chataigne is breadnut or A. camansi. I bought one from Montoso Gardens a while back.

    Julie mango is a great mango. The ones here don't get the nice colour that they do in Trinidad. I think it has to do with the weather or something. I got some budwood from a tree in Trinidad and I have it growing here. I want to see if the one from Trinidad will be the same colour as the one here. It will interesting to find out.

  • 16 years ago

    i never realized they were distinct, a. caminsi and a. atilis, i just assumed a. atilis was regular breadfruit, but i found out now they have seeded varieties of a. atilis.

    i got seeds from Sadhu and his page says breadnut; a. atilis so i guess i got the seeded variety of breadfruit.

    a. caminsi is breadnut, i wonder if there is a big difference?

  • 16 years ago

    Well it might be either. He probably got confused with his labeling. The breadfruit is thought to be a hybrid between the breadnut and the dug dug (A. mariannensis). I never had the seeded breadfruit so I am not sure how different it is than the breadnut. If it is from a tree he found growing wild in PR it is probably a breadnut. I do not think that the seeded breadfruit has been growing that long in the caribbean compared to the regular breadfruit and the breadnut.

Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions