Software
Houzz Logo Print
robeb_kc

preventative spraying

17 years ago

I understand the importance of spraying with Daconil (chlorothalonil) as a preventive for fungus diseases. What I'd like to know is what the difference is between daconil & copper soap?

One year I thought I had early blight, so I started a daconil program because of info I'd picked up here on GW. Another season it looked like black spot or speck, so I went with the copper soap, again from reading threads here, while still spraying with daconil every 7-10 days.

I want to know if I need to start using both products from the start after planting out, or will one take care of all my maintenance needs?

Thanks for any replies.

Comments (3)

  • 17 years ago

    hi, I'm not sure if I can help but I can try. Daconil is not an organic product and copper soap is. I would suggest you try using just the copper soap it should prevent early blight as well as many other fungi. you might also want to try using just daconil it's up to you. I just wouldn't suggest using both since they do the smae things.

    I hope this info is correct if it is not someone please correct me.

  • 17 years ago

    Fungal diseases such as early blight caused by A. solani require very different treatments than do bacterial diseases such as speck and spot.

    Fungal diseases are best prevented since the fungus is also airborne rather than treated after the fact and Daconil and similar products are the most commonly recommended preventative spray. Several studies show it to be the most effective since it lays down a protective coating on the sprayed surfaces thus preventing the fungus from taking up root (so to speak ;). And many have discussed it's effectiveness here in that past as you already know.

    Copper based fungicides are more for control of fungal problems rather than prevention IMO because the copper is toxic to the existing fungi (as well as some bacteria). And because the copper can also kill the plant tissue, and thus the plant, they carry a greater risk and require more care in use than does Daconil. Plus some studies now show copper-tolerant bacteria have evolved due to its many years of use.

    So, unless one is opposed to the use of synthetic chems which I assume you aren't, the Daconil will be much more effective in preventing the fugal problems without risk to the plants (assuming proper application instructions are followed).

    Bacterial problems have alternatives to copper products for control.

    The article from Ohio State linked below breaks down the differences between several different products on the market so you might want to review it for more details.

    Hope this is of help.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Controlling Diseases

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks Dave, that does help.

    I had a pretty good understanding of Daconil & how it works, but the copper had me confused. My liquid copper container is labeled as a fungicide, but states that it controls some bacterial diseases as well. That had me scratching my head.

    Thanks for your post, it all makes sense now. I don't think I'll be spraying copper unless necessary.

Sponsored
Trish Takacs Design
Average rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars36 Reviews
Award Winning & Highly Skilled Kitchen & Bath Designer in Columbus