Software
Houzz Logo Print
tigerdunes

blossom end rot

18 years ago

I have already noticed blosson end rot on tomatos not even ready to pick.

any suggestions?

does "Stop Rot" work or are there better products on the market?

td

Comments (37)

  • 18 years ago

    Please read the FAQ here on BER as it will answer your questions. The FAQ link is on the forum fron page near the top.

    A search of the forum using "BER" and "blossom end rot" will pull up hundreds of discussions about it if you wish to review them.

    Thanks.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    i had BER bad last year till i got me some stop rot and i use it everytime i fertilze my tomatoes also this year i am using fish emulsion and liquid Kelp mix together and foliar feedind not one problem

  • 18 years ago

    Consistent, correct watering is the best way to prevent ber. I suggest what Dave said.

  • 18 years ago

    I have BER on one tomato that is golf ball size. The eventual size of that tomato is large. Would i be better off picking the one with ber and tossing it and let the plant direct its energy elsewhere?

  • 18 years ago

    ~~~ Would i be better off picking the one with ber and tossing it and let the plant direct its energy elsewhere? ~~~

    That is what I do and the reason for it but can't prove that it is what should be done. Some say they cut the bad out at harvest and eat the rest but I don't have the fever that bad :-)

  • 18 years ago

    I wouldn't bother with the Stop Rot - as the FAQ says foliar sprays of calcium supposedly are not translocated to the fruit.

    People who think they have had success with it may just be experiencing the natural improvement with BER that occurs as the season progresses and the roots get bigger and stronger.

    Avoid inconsistent watering and bear in mind that some varieties such as romas are more susceptible.

  • 18 years ago

    Hey ... reading the original post, it seems Tiger is simply sayin' he's observing some BER early on, and wonders if there are specific products that might prevent BER on future fruit on same plant(s).

    These are questions that county extension agents and Master Gardeners who assist county extension agents frequently respond to when asked by home gardeners.

    I cannot imagine a county extension agent or a Master Gardener responding by saying, "check out the tomato FAQ at our Web site" or "we get asked this same question all the time and it gets annoying." That would be completely counterproductive to the purpose of sitting in the office waiting for a home gardener to call with questions in the first place.

    So ... is this a tomato growing forum, or is this a site to refer folks to an FAQ?

    Now, referring to the FAQ, I don't see the answer to Tiger's question anyhow ... unless egg shells, Tums, powdered milk, etc., are "products ... better than Stop Rot."

    I think what Tiger is asking for is a product same as or better than Stop Rot that if applied mid-season will minimize BER in plants already experiencing the problem.

    Tiger, JayTee's advice is pertinent. Test your soil. Most soils have sufficient calcium. JayTee also mentioned regular irrigation to facilitate uptake. While dried out soil will inhibit calcium uptake, so will drowned roots. Also tilling around the base of the plant can sever the feeding roots and inhibit uptake sufficiently to cause BER.

    Some plants are just genetically predisposed to BER under the same conditions where other plants can produce good sound fruit. Some plants just don't have as efficient a delivery system to the developing green fruit walls.

    Epsom salts (magnesium sulfate) can assist a plant's ability to take up and distribute calcium. Some growers add a handful of Epsom salts to the planting hole. Other growers apply 1 or 2 tablespoons Epsom salts per gallon water as a foliar spray. I don't know about Stop Rot (read the label), egg shells, foo foo tea, or anything else. I use Epsom salts and try to water in such a way as to keep soil from drying out while not overwatering to the point of saturation.

    Bill

  • 18 years ago

    Good points Bill ;-) I put a couple egg shells in with each transplant but won't use Epsom salts again. I do not know what I did way back when I did use it ( 2 years in a row I think) but I killed everything (peppers too).

  • 18 years ago

    Huh. That's strange, James. What's the pH of your soil? And how much Epsom salts did you apply per square foot or in each planting hole. Or how exactly did you use it and how much per application?

  • 18 years ago

    Hmmmm...some valuable information missing from this thread. Too bad.

    Egg shells will do no immediate good for you. They take too long to break down into a usable form by the plants. In the long run they will be beneficial however.

  • 18 years ago

    Its diffucult to screw thing up with epsom salts. Unlike other fertilizer salts, magnesium sulfate can be applied at high doses without burning, and calcium ions outcompete magnesium ions (which is one reason you don't usually mix epsome salts with your regular fertilizer) so you don't usually have to worry about calcium deficiency under normal circumstances.

  • 18 years ago

    One of my the first 2 tomatoes that arrived on one of my Better Boys showed signs of blossom end rot. My father-in-law said to add some lime to the soil. His advice was that I had too much nitrogen from fertilizing with miracle grow and not enough calcium. So I have done that. I have many golf ball sized green tomatoes, none with end rot.
    I have learned my lesson with miracle grow.... what should I be fertilizing with now? Advice all? Thanks

  • 18 years ago

    While limestone will add calcium to the soil, it takes a long time for it to break down into a form that is usable by the plants. It certainly won't help you this season. Not to mention that you may be raising your soil's pH when it may already be high to begin with. Again, most soils have plenty of calcium in them. Adding limestone without knowing if you need it may be doing more harm than good. Get a soil test done if you want things done the right way.

    Also, using MG every couple of weeks is not a problem. Are your plants in containers?

    Again, BER is more often caused by either too little or too much water. Except in containers where a CA deficiency can certainly occur and may be compounded by inconsistent moisture.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with John that adding lime can be hazardous and of little benefit now anyway - it simply isn't utilized that quickly, sorry.

    There is nothing wrong with using MG for your tomatoes if you wish as long as you don't overdue it and IF your plants are in ground rather than containers, every 2 weeks is overkill in most instances.

    BER "cures" itself, it disappears 99% of the time, as soil moisture levels are stabilized and the plant matures. That coincidence often misleads the gardener into believing they have "found the cause" and "found the cure". ;)

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Do you not recommend using MG in containers? I usually use a scoop and disolve it in a gallon or so of H2O every 2 weeks. As you can see from my pics i am not having any problem (plants are growing nicely) Am i going to see BER because of this?

  • 18 years ago

    Do you not recommend using MG in containers? I usually use a scoop and disolve it in a gallon or so of H2O every 2 weeks. As you can see from my pics i am not having any problem (plants are growing nicely) Am i going to see BER because of this?

    Some who use Earthboxes as containers, advocate adding a specific amount of dolomite lime (don't recall the exact amount) in a band 1 time prior to planting in the container. Why? I can't say except that the manufacturer of EB's recommends it.

    Otherwise, I have never seen any recommendation for adding lime to a container, certainly not on a regular basis. And have never done it myself, even in my EB's, despite years of successful container growing. The problems it can cause simply outweigh any possible gains IMO.

    Not any kind of lime in any of these containers and no BER either.

    {{gwi:1342610}}

    Will using it or not using it cause BER? No. BER is not caused by a lack of calcium in the soil. That was scientifically established years ago. It is caused by inconsistent moisture levels which prevent the plant from properly mobilizing calcium to the fruit at the proper time.

    So honestly, if you maintain consistent soil moisture levels as much as possible, hope for and end to excess rain ;), and avoid excessive nitrogen use and BER will disappear all on its own as the plant matures.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Would you consider daily 8am watering "consistent"??? ha as you can see my plants love is so far

  • 18 years ago

    Hi rmsiegel - looks good - real good. And a very attractive arrangement too for the patio. ;)

    Would you consider daily 8am watering "consistent"???

    If they need it daily, yes, if they don't, no. ;) But it isn't really a question of you being consistent as it is the moisture level in the soil being consistent. Right now down here, mine only need water every second or third day. But come August when the temps are regularly 100 degrees plus, I will be watering twice a day on many days. Are the tops of the containers mulched? That helps a great deal.

    Keep up the good work!

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Mixture of Potassium Chloride and water in a pump sprayer will stop BER in its tracks

    Here is a link that might be useful: Article From bestofthehome.com

  • 18 years ago

    I read the article you linked dmje but the author talks like blossom end rot is a disease that can spread to all your other plants. It isn't a disease and it isn't contagious so I am having difficulty understanding the author's reasoning. Can you explain in more details how or why this has worked for you? What is the potassium chloride supposed to do?

    He says "If you see the end of your tomatoes beginning to rot as they grow, then it is surely a case of blossom end rot, which can be easily stopped from overtaking your entire tomato crop. Go to your local pharmacy and get some potassium chloride, then place two heaping tablespoons into a garden sprayer and fill with water, shake to mix then spray your plants well. Do this weekly until no new end rot appears."

    I would be curious to know what the experts here think of his suggestions, especially in the light of all the other comments about BER I have read here?

    Thank you.

  • 18 years ago

    "Mixture of Potassium Chloride and water in a pump sprayer will stop BER in its tracks"

    No it wont.

  • 18 years ago

    Here is a link for those who have the time to read it and who enjoy scientific stuff. Also for those who think inconsistent watering is the ONLY cause of BER ...

    Click Here for Link to BER Article

  • 18 years ago

    Great article Bill, thanks.

    There is a reason they call it a hypothesis rather than proofs but very interesting.

    Here is a link that might be useful: The bottom line for this study.

  • 18 years ago

    I've been growing a garden for many years, and learned from my ancestors, before the time of computers,and they always used hydrated lime for BER. When it occurs, ph in soil is too high, and the lime worked in around the plant will neutralize the acidity in the soil, and future fruit will be void of BER. At the first sign of BER, early in the planting season, I treat plants with this, and pick off fruit already contaminated with BER, since it will rot from the inside and very little of it will be edible. Just my two cents worth!

  • 18 years ago

    Most EVERY potting mix formula for containers I have ever seen contain dolomite (lime).

    And most commercial mixes would have lime added to moderate pH.

    Many mixes are based on Cornell Formula (see link /scroll down) Dolomite is always added.

    Pro-mix adds it:
    http://www.premierhort.com/eProMix/Horticulture/Products/GrowingMediumTM/ProMixBX/BXRegular/fProMixBX.htm

    Lamberts adds it:
    http://www.lambertpeatmoss.com/english/pages/product/productdroite.htm

    Earthbox recommends mixing in 2 cups of dolomite when growing tomatoes (for the added calcium) above and beyond the fertilizer strip.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cornell Container mix + lime

  • 18 years ago

    Bill, that is a new one as I have read that calcium sprays are not effective as it is not translocated to the fruit in that manner.

    Now that study is saying spray the FRUIT early on. WOuld be worth a try on some really bad candidates that get BER.

    ((I find on the scientific articles that go way over my head if I read the first paragraph and then the last paragraph (that always sums everything up) I really get the gist and most important part of the article without torturing myself on every nitty gritty technical aspect of the experiment. ))

  • 18 years ago

    The Best of the Home article has some other points in it that make me dubious of the expertise of the author. 1) Sand and saw dust ammendment. 2) Plant deep leaving only 1-2 inches above ground. 3) Tomato hornworm is confused with cutworms. 4) Only plants one type of tomato.

  • 18 years ago

    I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer, but are there
    incidences of BER occurring for the entire
    growing/harvesting season for tomatoes?? I mean, my
    experience has been - you watch the toms grow, develop,
    they get BER or they don't, you pick off the ones with BER,
    and move on...?? No?? I've never used lime or eggshells
    or calcium sprays or epsom salt or watering (unless it's
    not rained in weeks) from anything other than from the sky
    and I still get lovely tomatoes... Is this really a
    problem for people throughout the entire season? I guess
    is my question...

  • 18 years ago

    OK - I'm going to jump in to try to be sure that I understand what I have read.

    This years tomato garden is the biggest, most beautiful garden I've ever had (thanks to what I've learned here). Lately, just as my tomatoes start to turn, the bottom turns black. Was about to go out and diligently search for some type of spray to put on them. But we have had terrible evening storms the past two weeks which dump inches of rain at a time (not to mention the wind and lightening), then sweltering heat during the day. From what I've read, if the weather calms down, my tomatoes will most likely be fine? No need to rush out for miracle spray?

    Just looking for some reassurance. Thanks!

  • 18 years ago

    I have 3 Viva Italia romas that are 4-5ft growing in 10gal containers. I estimate that 90-95% of the tomatoes have succumb to BER in the last 2 months. I've only eaten about 8 and on some days tossed as many as 12. They recv about 1/2-3/4 gallon of water every morning and by the afternoon the top 1/2 inch of soil is dry but still damp underneath. Typical daily temp is 86-90F. I have 4 brandywines in the same soil, containers, w/same amt of water and they're doing ok. So sad :(

    Considering adding mulch to 2 romas and then cutting back on the water for the third since people have provided their input that moisture levels and consistency are a possible factor.

  • 18 years ago

    I have nowhere near as much experience as many on this forum, but have grown approx. 40-50 varieties over the last 4 years. I have had blossom end rot on 3 varieties consistently in the 2 years that each were grown, as follows:

    Purple Russian (a plum-shaped tomato)
    Green Zebra
    Wapsipinicon Peach

    All of the above were consistently affected by BER throughout each of the season in which they were grown. Consistency of watering and age/development of plant had absolutely no effect on BER. I did not make any attempts to manipulate the soil/spray the fruits to correct BER.

    Of the 37 or so other varieties that I have grown over the last 4 years, I have had perhaps a total of 3 or 4 tomatoes (not plants, 3 or 4 tomatoes in total in 4 years, besides the 3 mentioned above) that have been effected by BER.

  • 18 years ago

    are there incidences of BER occurring for the entire
    growing/harvesting season for tomatoes??

    I have seen some "claim" that it has but there is no way to know what other factors may have been contributing. All I can say is that I've never seen it in 40+ years of growing tomatoes and from what I have read, I don't think Carolyn has either. It goes away as the plant matures sure as the sun comes up in the morning. ;)

    Was about to go out and diligently search for some type of spray to put on them. But we have had terrible evening storms the past two weeks which dump inches of rain at a time (not to mention the wind and lightening), then sweltering heat during the day. From what I've read, if the weather calms down, my tomatoes will most likely be fine? No need to rush out for miracle spray?

    There is no miracle spray although all sorts of claims are made to the contrary. And the damage has already occurred long before you can see it on the tomato so spraying when you see it would be a "closing the barn door after the cow got out" response. Too late. Pick and pitch to reduce stress and demands on the plant or if ripe already when discovered - your choice to eat part or pitch all. Your weather of late is your primary cause, as it is for many of us. So unless we can all get together to do a give-me-normal-weather dance all we can do is stabilize our water contributions, mulch, insure good drainage, twiddle our thumbs, and wait. ;)

    They recv about 1/2-3/4 gallon of water every morning and by the afternoon the top 1/2 inch of soil is dry but still damp underneath.

    Unfortunately romas are very prone to BER and growing them in containers only adds to the problem. But it will pass with them as well and you will get healthy fruit. But why are you watering daily when the soil is still damp down at root level?

    What I find works best for my container plants is to either (a) water deeply till water drains out the bottom. Then do not water again until the soil hand-deep (use those long fingers ;) is dry. Or (b) bottom water. Switch to bottom watering by setting the containers on small spacers in a larger saucer or container and let them wick up from the bottom. Just don't leave them sitting constantly in water as that leads to root rot. Give them a couple of hours to suck it up, then dump the rest.

    And mulch works well on containers too. Consistent soil moisture levels is vital but it is the moisture at the root level, not the surface that must be consistent. Switch to bottom watering by setting the containers on small spacers in a larger saucer or container and let them wick up from the bottom.

    Honest - for whatever comfort it is worth, every year there is a panic discussion of BER here and every year, it goes away.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    You're not giving them enough water. In containers I can put in a gallon on cool days, but on warm days I'll add more, and if the day is windy too I'll add a lot more.

    Mulching is good, you can use grass clippings and maybe be able to only add a gallon of water a day, but that may be too little--you have to judge it and see if you need more water. Still, mulching only covers the soil surface--the water is mostly wicking away through the leaves. Mulching may halp to prevent moisture loss through the soil surface and it can help keep the soil more consitant in temperature, but mulching will do nothing to deter moistire loss through the leaves.

    If you can set up a soaker hose to go acorss the pots and set it on a spigot timer you will solve a lot of your problems.

    Also, as a suggestion, don't grow Viva Italias next year. Try a few other Roma types. Some Romas seem more prone to BER than others and when you grow a few different types side-by-side you'll be able to see which perform best for you.

    T

  • 17 years ago

    Hi all,

    First time tomato grower here... I have BER also. The issue though, is that my set-up is hydroponics. I am using rockwool as my medium and I am using advanced nutrients line of products "micro, grow, bloom." The plants are great - huge monsters with tons of blooms - most of which dry up (another issue altogether related to the fact that I'm indoors and humidity, and too much nitrogen I suppose).

    What do you all suggest I do to cure this issue? Should I yank the 4 toms that have BER?

    How can I ensure that my future fruit dont have BER in my set-up, and how can I ensure that my blooms turn to fruit?

    Thank you.

  • 17 years ago

    I have had numerous severe problems with BER in the past. I have lost more tomatoes from it than I care to admitt. One year after researching ways to prevent it, I come upon an article about the use of gypsum for this problem. The first year using it I had no problems with BER, but I also mulched to keep constant moisture in the soil for my plants as well. I wasn't sure which helped more the mulching or the gypsum. The next year I just mulched and didn't use the gypsum, plants were affected but not as badly as unmulched plants were. Next following year I decided to do an experiment by adding gypsum to the planting hole of every other tomato plant leaving the one beside it without gypsum and mulched all of the plants. The plants with gypsum did fine, no BER. Plants without it did suffer from BER, but not badly like before mulching. I am convinced that the gypsum does have prevenative attributes and will never be without it again. Works well for peppers too.

  • 17 years ago

    We have very little calcium in our soil in southern Louisiana, and blossom end rot is a big problem if we are not careful. Lack of calcium definitely causes BER, and the simple solution is to lay a band of dolomite lime rather thickly before planting the tomatoes. Dolomite lime is a little slower to dissolve away so you won't have a high pH problem with your soil like you might with the white powdered lime. It also contains magnesium, which may help tomatoes absorb calcium.

    I've also sprinkled dolomite lime on top of the soil later in the season when I saw some rot. The rot stopped on new tomatoes, but I'm not sure if it was because of the lime.

    -If you have newly transplanted plants with tomatoes already on them, do not use Miracle Grow on them. Wait at least a month or you'll likely get rot. The reason is that the type of nitrogen delivered by Miracle Grow (ammonium, or NH4) promotes blossom end rot. The problem goes away once the roots have a chance to establish themselves and suck the calcium out of the ground.

    -Lastly, if you get 15" of rain in 2 weeks like we just did, and you have new tomato plants, you're going to get rot, also like we just did :(.

  • 17 years ago

    I think in some locations or environments, some tomato varieties get BER no matter what you do.

    For two or three years, I was using up my Park's Whopper tomato seeds after we moved to Georgia, and every single year, those plants had BER all season long, around an 85% rate, and none of the other varieties of tomatoes did. The Whoppers had grown great on the northeastern sandy coast of NC, no BER at all. I threw the rest of the seeds away.

    I used to wonder, since many Romas are prone to this affliction, if there was a sneaky genetic component that is responsible for this affliction under certain conditions and did some internet hunting.

    Actually, it's the other way around. There is a gene, aptly named "BER", that has been found to decrease or even erase the occurrence of BER in tomato plant experiments.

    Most research in this area shows that one or two genes are responsible for a resistance to BER. Below is one report.

    Here is their conclusionary statement:

    =====
    The resistance is caused by one pair of high effective dominant genes which may be designated as Ber (Ber-1).
    =====

    You can do some searching of your own by Googling "tomato resistance BER" for more information, though many of the science sites give only a summary of the relevant research.

    Anyway, I've just stopped trying to grow tomato varieties that show a strong tendency to develop and continue BER through the season. (I discount a few in the spring.) It has sure eased my frustration levels.

    FWIW, this Cornell Tomato Disease Resistance Table may be useful in some cases. A few, very few, varieties are listed as being resistant to BER, so I suppose that means that the rest can develop it under certain conditions.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Monogenic resistance of tomato to blossom-end rot