Software
Houzz Logo Print
dunnn57

Most prolofic Heirlooms

19 years ago

This is my first year growing heirlooms.I've spent most of the winter perusing these boards and daydreaming of a juicy tomatoe on a BLT on a warm summer day.I've grown hybrids for years as well as growing from seed.

I realize that there are many variables involved;however over the years I have noticed certain varieties do tend to be more proloific than others.I'm NOT talking about germination rate; I'm wondering which heirlooms (in your experience)seem to never quit.Which variety survives the day you forget to water,takes the transplants easier than others,and harden-off with the best success.

A quick observation on my part:I would say the cherry varieites,(both heirloom and hybrid)are very hardy.I tried about 6 heirloom varieties and found a few to be EXTREMELY fragile.

Your thoughts?

Jay in NY

Comments (17)

  • 19 years ago

    I tried about 6 heirloom varieties and found a few to be EXTREMELY fragile.

    ******

    Jay, which OP varieties were fragile and in what way were they fragile?

    Carolyn

  • 19 years ago

    I agree with your assessment of the small, cherry types being pretty hardy and prolific generally.

    You did not mention taste, just hardy and prolific. Brandywine usually is a poor producer and finicky, but I had some last year that produced well. I guess that I would have to say that Cherokee Purple probably fits your criterion better than any other heirlooms after a disappointing performance the first year that I grew it.

    I grow a variety of hybrids as my all time favorites and "go to" reliable producers, as well as quite a few heirlooms now. I think that you can try a few different ones each year and find out what performs best in your garden as well as which ones you like the taste of best.
    Just my .02
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    I've been thrilled with the great flavor and production I've gotten from Anna Russian.

  • 19 years ago

    "Your thoughts?"
    To be honest for the most part I think a tomato plant is a tomato plant. SuperSweet 100 and Early Girl would be my examples of very hardy plants, but for the most part I think tomato plants are quite resiliant. BTW, which ones do you think are EXTREMELY fragile?

    Brandywine is finicky as far as production, but it is a robust and fairly hardy plant.

    As far as producing do you mean total fruit per plant or pound per plant? There are several varieties that produce well so you should get a lot of responses. I'll pick Eva Purple Ball as my choice.

    Randy

  • 19 years ago

    EPB did nothing for me. Robson Angolan gets my vote.

  • 19 years ago

    This year I planted 9 varieties. Bucks County, Brandy Boy, Big Zac, Goose Creek, Moskvich, Ugly, Polish (Ellis), Marianna's Peace and New Yorker. The biggest, strongest looking plants with the most fruit set are Polish (Ellis) and Marianna's Peace. New Yorker and Ugly are right behind. None of the OP varieties I planted look fragile. They are keeping up with or out performing the hybrids so far. Thanks to Carolyn for The Polish (Ellis) seeds. The plants look terrific.

  • 19 years ago

    If your looking for all around production and heartiness, uniform size, then it's hard to overlook Rutgers, but there's nothing to write home about regarding taste, it's just "OK" IMO.

    Mortgage Lifter produced well for me last year, hearty plant, very large fruit, great taste... a perfect BLT tomato.

    Brandywine does really well here. I have none of the production problems you often hear about, but I think much of that can be associated with exact region I'm growing in. If you've tried it and it didn't live up to the billing, then I wouldn't sweat it. There's lot's more to choose from that may be better suited for your region and personal criteria.

    People rave about Cherokee Purple, I didn't get any that were worth a hoot last year, but I got Brandywine, so I'm not complaining. Trying again this year.

    Someone mentioned Anna Russian...got nothing from that either. Very wispy, fragile looking, smallish fruit, very BER prone, not what I would consider hearty. You may have better luck where you are. But I'm not complaining, I got Brandywine.

  • 19 years ago

    I just remembered something... it was the Opalka I grew that was wispy, BER prone, smallish, not the Anna Russian. Sorry about that, but still, Anna Russian wasn't much of a winner for me.

    The sliced tomato on the plate was my first Mortgage Lifter of the season last year. Like I said, great BLT/sandwich/burger tomato. I believe those are Brandywine and Brandy Boy in the upper right. Not sure about the others, I'm thinking Marglobe(far left) and Better Boy.

  • 19 years ago

    A fine tasting and heavy cropper for me was Orange Banana. That plant just would'nt stop. Amazing production.

  • 19 years ago

    Red Mortgage Lifter would be my first choice, although it does have a very deep core. Ultimate Giant would be a close second, with almost no core. Hillbilly and Pineapple are vigorous, hardy and prolific for me every year too. These are my main heirlooms maters............along with a few of the great hybrids each year.

  • 19 years ago

    I've found Cherokee Purple to provide good total production.

    I prefer the taste of Brandywine, but sometimes I won't have a ripe one for a few days. I can always count on a ripe Cherokee...

    Granted, I usually only have 4 tomato plants (I've expanded to 6 this year), so the availability is more a function of the number of plants.

  • 19 years ago

    Last season was a supreme test of hardiness in my area. April through July was daily and unrelenting fog, cold temps, thick clouds and record-breaking monsoon rains. We didn't get good sun until August. Frost date here is early September.

    Almost everything in my garden succumbed to one disease or another. I was told that last year was the worst gardening season Maine has ever seen. What a year for a Newbie to try to learn how to garden.

    All of my tomato plants lost at least half their leafs and growth was very stunted. Although severely crippled and underproducing, the plants that survived were Stupice, Lemon Boy, Mr. Stripey, Brandywine (go figure) and Mortgage Lifter.

    By the time anything had ripened my nearly leafless, naked Brandywine and Mortgage Lifter only had 5-6 tomatoes each but some were almost as large as I had hoped for. One exceeded my wildest dreams.

    Convinced that no gardener in Maine, having endured the worst season on record, would believe me I placed a dime for comparison near this Mortgage lifter and took a picture.

    {{gwi:289654}}

  • 19 years ago

    FIM

    That's one handsome mater!

  • 19 years ago

    Jay - I, like Carolyn, have to question what you mean by frail. Tomatoes are a pretty rugged and reliable crop in general, and I do not note any "frailty" among heirlooms that I do not see across the board. I am referring to the problems with insects and diseases that we all face as growers. No variety is exempt. And I don't know what you mean by surviving a day without water, because I have never encountered any tomato plant, once in the garden, that could not go many times that long without water, nor would I ever water tomatoes daily. Mine were planted out on May 10 and I have watered them exactly once.

    As far as being prolific, yes, there can be marked differences, and yes, I agree that the cherry varieties can be some of the best producers. Black Cherry is one I would recommend. Going up in fruit size, I like the Jaune Flammee and Stupice, which yield lots of tomatoes about ping-pong ball size or better. For a beefsteak type, I would rely on Cherokee Purple to get a good amount of fruits.

  • 19 years ago

    There is no doubt IMO the Pale Perfect Purple aka Perfect Purple is the most productive tomato I have ever grown. Tastes very good also.

  • 19 years ago

    Polish was easily the most prolific plant in my garden last year yielding over 40#!

  • 19 years ago

    Hello all,
    Thank you for the informative replies.Without getting too deep into this as this isn't a dilemna for me,I was just rather curious since I lost an heirloom from the transplant to the garden yesterday when I wrote this.

    Some of you who answered are in my(local?)growing area,and i'm glad for your replies.Without making this a journal page,I'll give a brief synopsis of what i'm growing after the replies.

    carolyn137 - I've read many of your posts and your BIO;Verrry Impressive ! To answer you: The one I lost yesterday was called Sunsets Red Horizon,an OP from Ibsen.It was the runt of 4 that made the garden;however it didn't survive the transplant.It lived about 5 days,wilting to just the stem. the other 3 are doing well,green and vibrant,about 1ft tall now(I planted May 24th).

    barkeater - Who makes that Polish? I've read a few of your posts as well-Kudos

    gonefishin - I've read many of your posts and seen a few pics of your garden.I must say;I'm quite jealous of your garden and that warm TX growing climate.I did omit taste(on purpose),as I wanted to know which heirlooms grew best in your own opinions.I agree with your approach 100%,trial & error is best but its also good to try to hedge your odds for success.(If I knew that I'd live to be 100,I wouldn't mind trying every variety)

    tomatovator - (love the nickname!) Where are you from? I'm originally from Se. PA. Great mater weather there!Where did you get your seed? I've read about Marianna's Peace,and seen New Yorker;both consideration for next year.

    raisemybeds - I was speaking primarily about seedling to garden hardiness.That's why I mentioned the day without water.I tried San Francisco Fog, which seemed to me to be close to Stupice.It was billed as being a cloudy,cool weather climate tomatoe of medium size.Next yr,I will probably go with Stupice for that medium cold climate variety.

    fred_in_maine - WOW can I relate! What a season last yr was,ugh. I got virtually 1/2 the production I should've gotten.The entire month of July was rainy(wet),.....soaking wet actually,and August didn't get a day over 90 deg.My maters finally ripened the end of Aug with the beefsteaks not showing up until mid Sept!I also got late season blite from that wet July.Let's hope for a great season this yr !

    Garden synopsis: This yr I'm growing heirlooms & hybrids about 24 plants total.I've also taken my garden"above ground", and moved into a 5ft by 16ft garden bed.
    The hybrids are : Better boy & supersteak
    The heirlooms are: Sugar Lump(cherry),Brandywine,Sunsets Red Horizon,Gardeners Delight(lrg cherry),Beefsteak(red).
    I also tried SanFransico Fog and Wisconsin 55,but the Wisc55's germination rate was poor,and the Fog's seedlings were wanting.