Software
Houzz Logo Print
buck1173

'nother pruning question.....

18 years ago

Ok, reading Carolyn's response about pruning bordering plant abuse got me thinking....

I'm in a pickle, I planted waaaaay too much, waaaaay too close. My plants are only 3-4' high and already its a mess. (but who could blame me? with so many tempting varieties, how can one decide? : )

I can't bear to rip any out, though that'd be the only sane thing to do.

So, can I prune? I mean, prune prune? Like keep only 2-4 branches growing from the base? Is there a trick or technique?

I swear, I've learned my lesson for next year [wink] but would love some advice on how to proceed this year, already being knee deep, without loosing my mind....

thanks anyone...

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    How high can you go? In general I think you can do 6" per plant + 6" per rope, so a single rope plant is 12", a two rope plant about 18" etc. Can you find lower suckers that are getting shade? Possibly try and remove those and try to make it a little more like a vine.Also try and remove any new suckers on the lower branches. These are the shoots that stem out from the "crotches" if you will. Also if you like variety in a smaller space next year you will do fine pruning which may cut into you production per plant but not space wise and still have more variety. Just follow the varies pruning strategies with will generally be plant + ropes.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    See my post on "Does pruning stunt tomato growth."

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Buck,

    Its easier than you think to improve your situation and as much respect as Carolyn deserves, I think its plant abuse to force a plant to grow in an unhealthy environment when a simple hair cut will help :-)

    First read the article linked below, then think about the health of the plant first. As I recall, your plants grow against a solid wooden fence and you have had some foliage problems of late.

    I'd first go through the whole patch and prune anything that looked unhealthy being careful not to touch anything that wasn't going to be removed. I use my hands to snap them (seems to work better early morn) or thumb nail to cut, or hand pruners if too thick, in that order. Remove waste to the burn pile and wash hands and tools thoroughly.

    Then if your plants are large and bushy enough to no longer need the lowest leaves (proper term) prume all (or some) from the main stem to the first flower cluster. You may have already removed some of these in the previous step since usually the lower leaves show signs of ill health first. If you have lrg. lower suckers with blossoms or buds, do the same for them. Note any healthy but yellowing leaves in the middle or lower portions of the plant. Those leaves are likely being shaded too heavily and are drawing rather than contributing resources. Remove them.

    You have just improved the health aspects of your plants.

    Then I try to think about how that plant is going to look twice as big as it is now. 3 times, 4 ... Does it have room? If not then it should be an easy decision as to what to do next.

    A book I've recently read by Charles Wilber suggests leaving the bottom 6 suckers, allowing them to split once and the next sucker and the main stem to split 3 times, pruming all else. That still leaves a huge plant with 18 stems!

    If your space won't allow such a lrg. plant to stay healthy, work your way down the plant this time until you think there will be room. Wilber writes that lower on the plant is the most productive but for me, if an upper sucker is significantly more mature (to the point of being past snapping off cleanly) than a lower, maturity wins.

    Take it slow, do it in phases. Give the plant and yourself time to adjust :-) There is no cookie cutter, perfect formula for all plants and gardens.

    Disclaimer:

    This post may be freely considered as completely useless information, in whole or in part, be hazardous to you and your plants health and under no circumstances may its author/compiler be held accountable for any liabilities, past, present or future.

    Prceed at own risk :-)

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pruning

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It's a bit late to start aggressively pruning 3-4foot tall plants without doing some serious set-back damage to the plants. And you don't mention the varieties either. Are they determinates? Did you pick up on the distinction between pruning det. vs. pruning indet.? Checked out the FAQ here on pruning and browsed all the other discussions going on about it? Lots of important info including many tips and techniques are already available in them.

    IF they are indeterminates you can slowly remove a few of the most troublesome leafy branches over several days time. Cut some of them back by 1/2 rather than completely off. IF they are indeterminates you can also pinch off all the small just-developing suckers. Then give them a few days to recover a bit before doing any more.

    Be aware while doing it that you are removing protection and developmental nutrients from the plant - that should keep you from getting TOO carried away with the shears. ;)

    If they are determinate varieties, none of the above applies except that you can trim back some of the leafy branches.

    Hope this helps.

    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pruning discussions...

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Solanaceae: thank you, my trellis is 7' high. Last year my plants went 9' then over the neighbor's fence and down into his yard. Yes, I have removed any foliage touching the ground on all plants thus far. Plant 'ropes' are a neat idea, thank you!

    Gardener: it was your post that prompted me to think hard about what I was doing, especially since Carolyn's response.

    Dave #1: My gosh?!?!? you remember from last year? I'm impressed!!!

    Actually, they grow against a 7' trellis that is 3' away from the neighbor's fence. I made the mater bed twice as large this year, but also planted twice as much (they were so small when I put them in!). No real huge problems yet (touch wood) other than some early season critter damage, a droopy yet producing banana legs and some weird bronzyness on some leaves that I sprayed.... but plants are a bloomin' and looking good.... a little too good actually.

    This is basically what I've been doing.... had plenty of early branches that suffered sunburn and early old leaves that just yellowed w/ age. Those are gone. Everything touching the ground has been going too. But these babies are beginning to sprawl big time.

    Good, thank you, its the large lower suckers that I let go last year and gave me tons of trouble. Even though some are tempting to leave as they look as they might flower, I want to remove them. I have plenty of space to go up, and plenty of room for plants to grow out (forward) just not left to right, know what I mean?

    Thank you for the note to take it slow and go in phases... after my experience last year (removing practically half the plant due to disease and still having it overtake the yard) I'm tending to leap to the shears pretty quick.

    thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and thank you for the link, I'd actually just stumbled across that myself about 3 weeks ago when blossoms started happening.

    Dave #2: thank you too!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ok, so I kinda messed up re the det. vs indet and the reading you just posted for me helped me immensely.... Last year, I bought all my plants from the local home stores. I trusted what I was told on the little labels. Last year I had a gazillion romas, and they appeared to grow indet. (up like a vine, not bushy at all)

    This year, the hubby wanted 'plenty of romas, plant plenty of romas' ... soooo, having ws'd everything, I sowed a bunch o romas and planted them.

    All my det.'s went into a new bed this year, as I just wanted to let them sprawl and see what happened, and all of my heirloom indet.'s went into last year's bed.... thinking they'd grow skywards like last year ... except for romas, I planted them thinking they were indet.'s.

    Your link, and item #2 on that page just cleared a lot up for me. Romas are det.'s huh? Now this is making sense. Idiot me, I didn't read the seed packet. I'm sure it must say det. on there.

    Really I am way over crowded, but the romas are completely and utterly out of control, growing fat and bushy and low to the ground, like green octopus all over the place... not at all what the generic 'romas' I had last year do. I expected a relatively repeat performance to what I got last year, and this year its completely different.

    Well, one roma is threatening my Paul Robeson, and another one is creeping onto a Black Krim, and I just can't have that kind of nonsense, so some Roma's got to go....

    Thank you so much for the tip on slowly removing just some troublesome branches on the det's. Really, thank you for everything.... you have the patience to answer the same questions over and over, year after year... : )

    Everyone here is tremendous and I really appreciate it.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hey buck1173,
    Just to clear up what I mean by ropes is ropey stem. A crud formula to use is 6 inches per plant + 6 inches per stem . So a two stem plant would be 18 inches, a three stem 24 inches etc. Perhaps after hitting number 4 it could be reduced to 3 or four inches per stem or just call it a bush.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Buck,

    Don't be too impressed. You mentioned a hobby we sorta share when answering someone's question about a fixture in your yard and finding out that the person using a handle with "buck" in it had a husband, kinda stuck too :-)

    Shading and space issues aside, it makes sense to me that the lower suckers are the more valuable. They are closer to the roots allowing them to compete with less of the plant (I think). They are simply lower in elevation and should have the chance to make more flower clusters before they either need to be topped or droop over the side, which for me, has never gone that well.

    Also, this yr. growing many new to me, I'm noticing different habits of flowering on several varieties. Many simply have a bloom cluster coming from the side of the stem and is obvious almost immdiately as something you don't want to pinch off. Others though, have structures less obvious in placement and form and several have leaves on the same structure. At least one is exactly where a sucker should be.

    Dave's warnings about production loss are not wasted on me and I'm slow to prume anything unless I'm certain of what it is.

    I don't know enough to have a strong opinion as to what pruining does to the fruits other than the obvious sunscald, but it does make complete sense to me to have and keep your plants in a lush condition but not so lush that causes any delay in spotting or treating problems and root to plant balance in containers is essential unless you really do like puny fruits constantly suffering from BER :-)

    So ... I make no claims that pruning gives you bigger, better, fruit faster, though it may but a healthy plant will do all of the above, over one that is in poor condition.

    I try to prune for plant health and learn new things often.

  • 18 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dave, thank you again so very much... I appreciate your thoughts... I'll do my best to apply the best judgment I can. Your comments are really helpful and have calmed my nerves at bunch.

    Haha, Buck is my horse's name (all the composted manure I can stand)... its been my online handle for nearly a decade now... and yes, I can see how that can throw a person off gender-wise... frankly, that was the idea. safety first. : )

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio