Software
Houzz Logo Print
naturalstuff

BER Treated...Now Dying!! Pics!

16 years ago

HELP!! I always want to contribute here but I guess dont have the knowledge or patience you guys do.

Have not picked a ripe tomatoe yet here...(2 weeks away)

Had 2 Tomatoes with BER... I mixed 1/4 cup Lime with 1 gallon water...poured 1/2 gallon at base of plant the rest on a few other plants...

I need this Black Krim to survive! Why is it now dying!! I was just trying to treat the BER which is ALWAYS a problem here.

Comments (29)

  • 16 years ago

    I can't believe that with all the GOOD info here from those that know about BER, that any one would still try to "treat" it.

  • 16 years ago

    So you saying BER is not "treatable" or are you saying this plant is lost?

  • 16 years ago

    Just that you really don't need to do anything to treat it. It usually clears up without our help.

  • 16 years ago

    Good water management is about all you can do. It is a bad year for it every where. It should go away. Thousands of people do "what grandma used to do". So I guess if it makes them feel better I should not object. Sorry for yelling, so forgive me if I sounded off too quick.

  • 16 years ago

    naturalstuff, I am not far from you and I have never had BER on anything other than a paste type tomato. Did the black krim have BER fruits or you just "treated" it just in case? Instead of pouring lime into the soil, you should think about better water management and a well balanced fertilization program. Paste type tomatoes will have BER in most years and it is a loss we gardeners just have to take.

  • 16 years ago

    Nahhh, its not a water issue....I slow water them every day when its above 90. Twice a day when its above 97.

    I forgive you colokid...

    Im depressed because it's my only cool plant this year...the others are Romas, Best Boys, ect.

    We got a nice soaking rain 3 days ago...before that was 3 weeks without rain but like I said...I watered everyday...

    Yes...it had 2 Green tomatoes on it...I took them off the plant..

    Egg Shells dont act quick enough.

  • 16 years ago

    So you saying BER is not "treatable" or are you saying this plant is lost?

    BER is NOT "treatable". It is not a disease. It is a physical response of the plant to the growing conditions, primarily inconsistent moisture levels in the soil. We say this over and over and over again here but the message never seems to get out. If the weather cooperates, it disappears all on its own as the plant matures and adapts and 99% of the time any attempts to "treat" it only kill the plant or make the condition worse.

    In this case your plant may be dying from some totally unrelated cause. There is no way to know from the pictures except that it seems to be only on 1 side of the plant. But if I had to guess you probably burned the roots on that side - yes, alkaline solutions can burn just like acid can and your solution was VERY strong. The plant "may" recover if you leave it alone except to water normally.

    I suppose you could try flushing the area well with water first and then leave it alone if you wish because all that lime has now made the soil there very alkaline so the nutrients will not be available to the plants with a high alkaline pH.

    Remove the dead or dying branches and hope for the best. Good luck but the next time you see some BER - and you will - just ignore it, ok? ;)

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    Naturalstuff, now that we are friends, and I hope we are, I've got to hit you in the face one more time.
    You said "Egg Shells dont act quick enough."
    You miss the whole point. The problem is in the plant, not the soil. In spite of what many think, the egg shells bit is old wife's tale stuff. Same as tums, aspirin etc--- unless you take the aspirin yourself. Like Dave says its been said over and over.
    You may, may , be over watering. I all most killed a container tomato last month when I had a gallon jug of water left over and i dumped in on the one plant. Lost 2/3rd of the plant before it revived. I hope your's come out Ok.

  • 16 years ago

    Nahhh, its not a water issue....I slow water them every day when its above 90. Twice a day when its above 97.

    Yeah, sorry but it is a water issue. Watering every day doesn't insure consistent soil moisture levels. In fact it almost guarantees against it because all that does is create very shallow rooted plants and wasted water. Your plants then become totally dependent on a superficial moisture supply which evaporates quickly when there is no mulch on the plants.

    From the pics, these plants are in the ground, not containers so there is absolutely no need to water in-ground tomato plants daily. You live in CT not Arizona or South Texas. ;)

    Deep watering once a week for a total of 1-1 1/2 inches if no rain so you get deep root development - this too is often discussed here in great detail.

    And no mulch? That just guarantees your soil will dry out 3x as fast between waterings.

    Sorry but your watering regime and no mulch are classic signs of a very inconsistent soil moisture problem and that = BER, stressed plants and other problems.

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    Dave -- Guess you dont follow the weather for this area... Without getting into details...

    Hit 105 degrees 3 times, felt like 110 once.
    Staying above 95 9 times.
    Above 90 13 times.
    ALL IN PAST 30 DAYS. The rest were above 85.
    Got less than 2 inches of rain in past 30 days.
    Grass is all brown everywhere.

    it is almost like a desert here.

    With that said.... watering is a must otherwise my sandy soil will dry out completly.

    And you contradict yourself by saying I dont need to water in ground tomatoes then you say without mulch the soil dry too fast between waterings.

    Either way... I'm going to let up on watering a little more but BER is calcium deficiency not totally watering issue.

  • 16 years ago

    The above comments seem useful, but I'll reiterate one of them.....MULCH. This will seriously help your plants with several potential "issues." Including BER.

  • 16 years ago

    Reason why adding Ca++ to the soil in any form,with two exceptions, does NOT work:

    With BER there is NO problem with absorption of Ca++ though the roots. The problem is maldistribution within the plant that can be induced by a number of stresses which include uneven delivery of water, too much N, growing in too rich soil, too hot, too cold, too wet, too dry you name it.

    As the plants mature they can better handle the streses that can induce BER so usually it goes away.

    The two exceptions are first, if the soil has NO Ca++ as confirmed with a soil test, and that's a rare condition, and second, if the soil is too acidic in which Case Ca++ is bound in the soil.

    Again, adding lime, egg shells and on and on can not and will not prevent BER b'c absorption of Ca++ thru the roots is OK.

    Paste tomatoes are especially susceptible to BER and I think someone in a post above mentioned that.

    If you go to the top of this first page and click on the FAQ link and scroll down you'll also find an article about BER in case some of you have never looked at the FAQ's And there';s some darn good articles there as well, but I wouldn't pay any attention to the variety list b'c it's way out of date.

    The old information about BER being caused solely by lack of soil Ca++ has been shown to be wrong with research that's been done in the last 20 years or so, but it's going to take another generation before the real story gets into books, websites, magazines, etc. Most of the better websites already have the correct information.

    BER affects not only tomatoes, but peppers, squash, cabbage, cauliflower, etc., and it's a huge multimillion dollar problem for the industry, which is WHY all that reasearch was done. For instance, when tissues were taken from a plant that has BER fruits and was assayed for Ca++, the normal level of Ca++ was found, it just wasn't getting to the blossom end of fruits. And there's also a condition called internal BER where the fruits look fine, no evidence of BER externally, but when you cut open the fruit the inside is black

    Hope that helps

    Carolyn

  • 16 years ago

    I would try to do a pH test near that plant now that the lime was added... there's a chance it burned the roots but also your pH can be over 7 or even 8 in that area...

  • 16 years ago

    naturalstuff, like I said I live not far from you and yes the weather has been unreasonably hot and dry this year. But there is no reason to water every day or twice daily. I deep water once or twice a week, like Dave said. If your beefsteak tomatoes are getting BER, it is very very unusual and it could very well be way too much water. In fact, I think my paste tomatoes get BER after it rains heavily here.

  • 16 years ago

    Dave -- Guess you dont follow the weather for this area... Without getting into details...

    Hit 105 degrees 3 times, felt like 110 once.
    Staying above 95 9 times.
    Above 90 13 times.
    ALL IN PAST 30 DAYS. The rest were above 85.
    Got less than 2 inches of rain in past 30 days.
    Grass is all brown everywhere.

    That may be unusual for your location but such a weather pattern common for many of us in other parts of the country every year and we still don't water in ground plants every day. As I said, doing so only results in very shallow rooted plants that are prone to all sorts of problems.

    And you contradict yourself by saying I dont need to water in ground tomatoes then you say without mulch the soil dry too fast between waterings.

    No, you misunderstood what I said. I said you don't need to water in ground plants everyday. And you don't. And if you mulch your plants, which is also common practice, then you have to water even less - regardless of soil type - as it keeps the soil and the roots cooler and retards the evaporation from the soil.

    I didn't just make all this info up. It is common knowledge to many. Nor has anyone else said anything that isn't well documented. Yet you seem to want to dispute it, to downplay the value of everything we try to offer in the way of assistance. If you are convinced, as apparently you are, that none of the offered information is of any value or for some reason doesn't apply to your garden then by all means, feel free to ignore it.

    But then one has to wonder why you are having the problems you report and why you asked in the first place?

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    Going to buy mulch tomorrow and give updated pics. Gonna be extremely hot again here hitting 95...I dont want the flowers to start dropping which they havent yet!

  • 16 years ago

    Those of us who have gardened for 50 years and, have encountered almost every possible problem, occasionally forget how frustrating it can be for someone who is reasonably new to both the "art and science" of gardening. Experience is a pretty good teacher and, as long as you don't get too discouraged but keep on trying, you will be fine.

    Around these parts I'm known as a "pretty darn good gardener". However, I bet my friends, neighbors and family would be surprised at how much I constantly learn from this Forum from fellow gardeners.

  • 16 years ago

    Plants too crowded. Soil poor quality and exposed to sun. Roots exposed at surface. Plant and its unprotected, poorly developed and shallow roots not capable of operating effeciently due to heat stress, etc. Result, this plant forced to over-compete, struggle; therefore, BER.

  • 16 years ago

    Plant in second picture seems to be holding up now...I covered the roots better after soil washed away...

  • 16 years ago

    Sounds like you are "over-gardening."

    Try changing your growing practices next year and you can probably avoid BER. Amend your soil this Fall with organic matter, preferably with mature compost(this will help with nutrients and water holding capacity of the soil). Collect leaves this fall and shred them if you have a mulching lawnmower. Put the shredded leaves in a pile or open enclosure and you can use them for mulch along with grass clippings next year.
    I've found that a lot of problems can be avoided with healthy soil and mulch.
    When planting next year bury them fairly deep, so the roots become established in an area that doesn't dry out so quickly. Don't add mulch in the beginning, because it will keep the soil from warming up. In your area, you can probably add a couple inches of mulch in mid or late May. If you have a rainy Spring you may not need to water any until early Summer(that would be better than watering everyday). As it's often stated in here, water deep once a week. Always think about what's going on in the ground. Overwatering not only encourages shallow roots but also washes out nutrients and fertilizer goodies.

    Good Luck,

    Pete

  • 16 years ago

    For future reference, when most gardeners are talking about mulch they don't mean wood chip mulch. They are usually also recommending it be applied several inches thick for best results - like 6-8" thick. Many different discussions about various mulch types and their uses all over the forum including this one but most of the detailed info is available on the Soil, Compost & Mulch forum.

    The problem with wood chip mulch is once it is mixed into the soil it binds up soil nitrogen as it decomposes. So that N isn't available to the plants and extra N has to be supplied to the plants to compensate. It also can leach nitrogen from plants it comes into direct contact with. So it is recommended that it be kept back from the stems of the plants by at least 3-4 inches. Wood chip mulches also pose some pest problems.

    Given these problems, organic garden mulches such as compost, straw, hay, rotted leaves, grass clippings, even shredded paper and cardboard, etc. are more frequently used in the food garden.

    Don't get me wrong, wood mulches are better than no mulch at all but they do have associated problems that can be avoided by using other, cheaper, organic materials. The thicker the better.

    Just something to keep in mind for next season.

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    Dave.... Had great success in past with Red Mulch like the one I used... While I "know" other mulches work better, this is all I had available at the time....

    P.S - Start following the weather more around the continent..... 94 here humidity 35%...ITS BONE DRY HEAT... Has been past month and will be all summer. But I am stopping myself from watering in ground plants...Peppers in pots wilting every 6 hrs in this heat...Its insane...

    I planted my Tomato seedlings 6 inches deep to second set of leaves...I know roots grow from stem... Haven't posted here in a while but will try to contribute little more now since you helped me through this plant situation.

  • 16 years ago

    If I got two inches of rain in the past 30 days I probably wouldn't even water my garden. You east coast gardeners panic too much. Where I live the last good rain usually comes in February, maybe another inch or two in March, maybe a quarter inch in April, and then no more measurable rain until November. It was over a hundred here the past three days in a row, and I went from watering once a week to watering every four days because of the high temps. The only water my garden gets is what I put on it myself because we haven't had any rain since the end of February because this year the rains stopped early. I have no disease and almost all my plants are looking healthy. Even the big tomatoes are doing well since I switched to this deep watering only once or twice a week regimen.

  • 16 years ago

    Wow. Shoulda Called this thread "Can You Believe This Weather Here?"

    It hit 95 today here AGAIN. Humidity 35%. Californian - You're watering every 4 days...sounds like thats what I need. But 2 inches of rain in now past 35 days is nothing around here. Thats all evaporated already...

    THIS IS THE TEMP AT 5:00PM!! IT AINT GOING TO 72. TRUST ME.

  • 16 years ago

    MY MISTAKE........ WE DID NOT GET 2 INCHES FROM LAST RAIN STORM 4 DAYS AGO...

    LAST 47 DAYS WE HAVE RECIEVED .... 3 INCHES AND IT'S BEEN IN 90'S 40 OF THE 47 DAYS. 100'S A FEW TIMES.

  • 16 years ago

    Big deal. If you had soil that was richly amended with organic matter and a nice layer of straw mulch or mulch made from rotted leaves and grass clippings, you'd not have to water at all in those weather conditions you display. Well, except in the tubs and buckets. Weather down here is at least that hot, humid and rainfall about the same or less for the past 40 days and I haven't watered at all this year ... except for the tubs and buckets once ever two or three days.

    Build up some raised beds this fall and fill them with lots of rotted organic matter ... compost and such ... and then lay on a heavy layer of straw mulch. Next spring, plant your vines about 3 apart, cage them and let'r rip. Oh, in each planting hole, put a handful of bone meal, a handful of Epsom salts and a handful of granulated plant food.

  • 16 years ago

    LOL! I'm really tempted to say "oh you poor baby".

    It was 104 here today and is supposed to be 106 tomorrow with a heat index of 110. We have been under a heat warning, not an advisory but a warning, for most of the past 3 weeks.

    As of now 9:10 pm it is almost same as you were at 5 pm - 90. We haven't seen a night below 75 in weeks. Big deal. That is normal for us and it is nothing compared to other south and SW parts of the country.

    Right now - 9:10pm in Laredo, TX it is 91 and in Phoenix it is 108.

    It's July after all. Everyone is in the same boat unless maybe - the folks in the UP of Mich.

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    Not to let you think your the only one's with high temps we have been running in the mid 90's here in Germany and Western Europe for the last 3 weeks. Had a few pastes come down with BER and some flower drop but on a whole the containers have been hanging in there. Used a new aggregate mix this year consisting of Peat, barkfines and perlite which seems to retain moisture longer than my old mix so I have been able to keep my watering to once a day in my 5-10 gal containers even in the high heat. Ami

  • 16 years ago

    naturalstuff, I see you are in CT - not far from me and we're having the same crazy hot summer. Just wanted to say my brother in CT gave me buckets of Sweet Peat - a mulch that I can't get down here in NJ - and I just love the stuff. I don't know what's in it but my tomatoes are doing very well. It seems to keep the moisture in the soil and funny thing, no critters are digging holes in that part of the garden. I plan on digging it in the soil this fall. I highly recommend it if you can find some.