Software
Houzz Logo Print
lorikaye_gw

Direct Buy?

18 years ago

My husband and I are in the process of seperating land on the farm he shares with his two brothers. We are plotting out 2.5 acres on which to build our home. We are about 9-12 months away from starting construction due to the county planning department being so far behind. We have our chosen our floor plan and general contractor.

Like most people we would like to cut costs where possible. We are debating on whether or not to take a tour of Direct Buy. It sounds like a family can save quite a bit of money buying their cabinets, countertops, flooring, furnishings, etc, thru them. Has anyone gone the Direct Buy route? And if so were you pleased with the results? Were the savings substantial?

We have also seen some really beautiful dark hard wood flooring at Costco recently. Is cheaper to buy yourself instead of allowing a contractor to buy everything?

Thanks in advance for your input,

Lori

Comments (21)

  • 18 years ago

    do a search on this site. there are many comments about direct buy. most arent too good. i would avoid it.

  • 18 years ago

    Some contractors are fine with you buying some things, others aren't: it's probably specified in your contract. Never hurts to ask, though.

    As to Direct Buy, some people like them, but the membership fee is [IIRC] $3500. Common consensus seems to be that they exist more to sell memberships than merchandise.

  • 18 years ago

    Memory also tells me there are fees for shipping, handling and no delivery. Pick up was at the site. Fine for that gorgeous faucet perhaps, but not so great for cabinets.
    Steer clear seemed to be the not so subtle messages from most posters.
    Jo

  • 18 years ago

    I am one of the people that actually love DB. I didnt build a new house, just remodeled an old one and saved thousands and thousands of dollars. My membership was in the $4000 range (NY) and was good for 3 years, then I pay $150 per year after that if I still want it. My membership is up in April and I plan on re siging. I wouldnt recommend it if you arent doing big projects such as building a home or remodeling. The cost isnt worth the discount if you're simply doing "regular shopping" and occasional furniture shopping. But for someone building their home, the savings is substantial.

  • 18 years ago

    I've given a link to previous threads on Direct Buy. Maybe they will help.

    Stumpy

    Here is a link that might be useful: Direct Buy links

  • 18 years ago

    We took the tour before we starting building. I was floored at the membership price. It was around the $4,000 range and I was not please that they would not allow us to look at their prices UNLESS we signed up. Also, some builders prefer you to buy from their suppliers. Delivery is not an option so you would have to try to figure out how to pick up your items.

    I wasn't impressed but then that was just me. It would pay off if you like to catalog buy everything and that was their pitch. Christmas shopping, birthday shopping etc. I am not a big catalog shopper so it was really not for us. That was just me though :-) You might want to take the tour but plan on both spouses attending that is a must and NO kids.

    Good luck

  • 18 years ago

    I punted when we got to the sign today or go away forever part. They did let me look through some of their price books there and I was COMPLETLEY UNIMPRESSED. Nearly the same deals are out there for those willing to hunt without the membership gouge and all the "pile on" fees Direct Buy adds on. You need to compare the savings NOT to the MSRP but to the price that you can get things for on the "pseudo wholesale" market.

  • 18 years ago

    A HUGE warning for me is the "sign up today or you can NEVER sign up" part. Anyone salesman who is that high-pressure has something to hide.

  • 18 years ago

    We are not members, but our friends are. They built a year before us. As an example, they spent as much, if not more, than we did on appliances, and what we have is of much higher quality
    And NO--I am not saying this because I think certain brand names are "better quality". We went with Northland for our fridge and freezer, a name that is certainly not as familiar as SubZero to many.

    Anyways, Direct Buy is simply a business that runs off of it's membership dues and fees for shipping, etc. that it always tacks on. You can get much better deals elsewhere if you are willing to spend the time looking.
    Direct Buy compares it's great prices to MSRP, as ronnatalie stated. When was the last time you ever considered MSRP as a true price for anything? Not me!

  • 18 years ago

    A HUGE warning for me is the "sign up today or you can NEVER sign up" part. Anyone salesman who is that high-pressure has something to hide.

  • 18 years ago

    DW called them once about six months ago. I hit the roof. And she never called them back. However, they still call several times a week. (We never answer--the same treatment we afford all 800, unknown, blocked and spoofed numbers.)

  • 18 years ago

    When they told me I "had" to bring my DH, I knew then they were crooked. That kind of pressure is crazy. I'm tempted to call back and play like I'm single. I wonder if they'd let me come in. LOL

  • 18 years ago

    We are DB members. I've had some moments where I wondered if it was worth it and I have purchased some things that were truly good deals. I shop on the internet and feel like I'm a pretty savvy buyer and I have found some very good deals through DB. Some things, like appliances, are marginal savings. Other things like area rugs, blinds, hardwood and furniture, I've saved a ton on. Their KD is $300 for as many visits as you wish. I didn't buy my cabinets through DB and bought them with an internet provider who lied to me and I thought I was going to save on the handling fee and sales tax. In the long run, I should've paid the handling fee and sales tax, because it was a miserable experience.
    I almost didn't join because of not being able to go on my own. I thought it was cheesy and an out-dated rule to have to take my husband. I didn't like their sales show either. I was armed with certain items I wanted to buy and I checked their catalogs. That's why I joined.
    I will say it has been a pretty good experience. Buying products takes longer and if I had've had more time, I could have saved a bunch on my red windows and doors too, but I didn't have time to wait on the quotes. I could've bought a nicer brand of windows and doors for significantly less than what I spent even including their handling fee.
    Lastly, they do deliver in my area. I've had hardwood, carpet and furniture delivered and it was a fine experience.

  • 18 years ago

    The membership fee is too high; you can only consider you are saving money after you have computed your $4,000 membership fee in TRUE savings, which is hard to prove, specially with all the price matching stores will do with internet sites.

  • 18 years ago

    I am a direct buy member and have been for several years. Until this year, I have not been happy dealing with direct buy and had in fact made only one purchase, a treadmill. We are now in the process of building a house and I was determined to get my membership ($3000.00) fee back. I am ordering my cabinets (Omega Custom - supposedly a good cabinet line) from Direct Buy. My cabinets retail are over $52,000.00. I am paying approx. (don't have exact number yet) $17,500.00. I have shopped cabinets for many months now and have 3 other estimates for comparable cabinets and they are all over $30,000.00. I am also saving 50-55% off plumbing fixtures. My granite a top grade #5 is 60.00 sf installed and templated. I am thrilled that I have the direct buy membership at this point, as I said it wasn't always the way...it depends on what you are using it for. Good luck...

  • 18 years ago

    50-55% off list price, yes. But list price is not what you'll pay at HD or Lowes. You're better off shopping the net for plumbing fixtures.

  • 18 years ago

    For example, on plumbing Home Depot special orders about 20% off list price. If you go to Faucets.com you can get about 40%. 50% is pretty much the wholesale price given to the best contractors dealing with the large wholesale houses, do DB is probably comparable with the latter, but without the screwage of the membership and the extra fees.

  • 18 years ago

    Make sure that your GC will allow you to direct purchase items for your project, then contact your insurance agent to confirm that you have a "builders risk" policy and over 1 mill in liability and 2 mill aggregate insurance. The practice of direct purchasing is being battled out in the courts right now and the home owners are losing every time. You are completely liable for any and all effect of your direct purchases. If you were to purchase a light fixture that was faulty and the electrician that was installing it got a nasty shock and was injured....you better hope you have a workmans compensation policy or be prepared to take the consequences. So is it really worth it so save a few bucks buying direct?

  • 18 years ago

    Run, run, run away from Direct Buy! Joining was definitely the most stupid mistake that my husband and I have made in the house building process. In fact, I can't believe we were so hoodwinked.

    I have tried my darndest to get my money's worth, but it's a fool's errand unless you resign yourself to believing their msrp and not really shopping around. EVERY time I spend all this effort and time trying to find a good deal at Direct Buy (searching through their books or on the internet, trying to figure out the real cost after all the added-on fees and then comparing that to purchasing elsewhere) and it ends up just being the same, worse, or only marginally better than elsewhere.

    Faucets is just one example. I went to all the trouble, actually ordered them from Direct Buy. I wasn't even picky. Just looking for a good deal. I've even asked the sales staff before, "Please tell me what I can save money on. We need practically everything." (Because they always give me the line, "Well, we don't have the best prices on everything . . . .") Then when I got home, I just randomly went on the internet to see how much the exact same Delta faucets cost elsewhere (so I could enter the savings into my little spreadsheet where I'm desperately trying to recoup our membership fee). Wouldn't you know it? They were almost the exact same price at efaucets. Except at efaucets, they deliver within one week (instead of 4-6) and at my house (instead of at the Direct Buy site 30 miles away). So I cancelled my Direct Buy order even after all that trouble, and ordered online.

    That's just one example. I could give you lots. If someone could tell me something I could REALLY save money on at Direct Buy, please do! I'd still love to recoup some of that huge membership fee ($4500). But so far, I've only found one item that's even close to being a good deal (Jetta whirlpool tubs because they are located here in Oklahoma so I don't have to pay their ridiculous extra shipping charges (that they don't tell you about) -- I've bought two of those now, but that hardly makes up for everything else).

    I take the time to post this in hopes that I can help someone else from making the same mistake we did.

  • 18 years ago

    As previously stated, do a search on this forum, and then google direct buy, I know people who belong and I would never belong even if they paid me to join If you save anything on any product, be prepared to do alot of running around picking stuff up and having a handling surcharge added to the cost by direct buy. But since you did ask for opinions....Just say no ... you can get better prices and service by shopping around. I got better prices (my friends compared them to direct buy) on my bathroom and kitchen fixtures from a local mom and pop plumber, and they were delivered for free and any problems were serviced immediately. My friends have had problems with missing pieces for their tub and have been fighting the return policies of direct buy for over a year.

  • 18 years ago

    We saved $13,000 on windows alone compared to other local, comparable brands. We went with Pella. We estimate we have saved in the neighborhood of $25000 overall. Sure, you ahve to be diligent, you have to be a prudent shopper, you have homework to do, but you can save money. We recently purchased 13 ceiling fans. Some are very high end montecarlo. We saved approximately $600 over the very best internet priciing. A lot of companies have MAO, which is min advertised price. If an authorized online retailer sells for below that, they can lose representation of that company. I sent a listing of the fans we were buying to an online guy, then when I told him what we were buying for he said that is almot wholesae that they pay.

    So, DB is hard work. It pays off if building new or a major remodel. If you join to buy a tv, a tredmill, an occasional item, you will not recoup your money. One reader mentioned Omega Cabinets above. A superior brand. Retail price was +/- 195,000.00. DB quote was $92,000.

    We went with our builders custom guy because we didn't have that budgeted in our cabinet build.

    One caveat to DB. You may not save any money at all because it allows you to upgrade to items that based on your contractors budget would not have been available. So for that 10k lighting budget, you can buy nicer lights for teh 10k than you would have otherwise bought at your local Ligthing Emporium.