Software
Houzz Logo Print
magic_scott

Home Extension/Re-Build Advice

19 years ago

My basic question is, when is it worth it to just tear your entire house down and re-build from scratch, vs. adding an extension?

Here's the scenerio (in-law's house):

- single story house built in 1970

- single wall T&G red wood

- open ceiling

- on slab

- living room & bedroom addition in 1985 (double wall, drywall).

They are currently in the process of adding a 2nd story to the house primarily for brother-in-law. I'm wondering what will happen to the integrity of the 1st floor (original) of the house in the next 10+ years or so.

Money shouldn't be an issue because my wife and I were willing to split the cost for us to live there as well.

What do you think?

Thanks!

Comments (6)

  • 19 years ago

    It would be worth the fee of a structural engineer to check the existing foundation/footings, structural elements of the existing framing,even run soil compaction tests to see if the current structure is up to the task, befrore considering the remodel.

  • 19 years ago

    Let's look at this from the standpoint of a buyer. Who wants a partially-new, mostly-old house with "whats this?" architecture? Who wants an entirely new, mechanically up-to-date, well insulated, all-of-one-piece house?

    We faced this when we bought an old ranch "to remodel". It became obvious that the best use of the money was to tear down and start over.

    Former neighbors did the remodel bit and now cannot get back the money they spent. The house is oversized for the neighborhood and has too many BRs for the small kitchen, LR, etc. The space for stairs further reduced the first floor "public" areas. Buyers can spend the same dollars and get a brand new, architecturally pleasing home.

    The only place I see logic in big remodeling is in California, because of its weird RE tax laws.

  • 19 years ago

    This is another "it depends". I'm just not smart enough to make an honest judgement by the info you've given. I do know that I have abandoned the remodel of our old farmhouse when it became obvious that we couldn't effectively remodel without great expense. On the other hand, I've seen others marry a $100k remodel and addition to a $250k house to make a $500k house.

  • 19 years ago

    Designed and done right, a remodel will match the existing as if it were an integral part of the original house. I dont subscribe to chisue's biased opinion of part new, part old and "what's this" point of view based solely on their bad experience.It is area dependent on market value how the finished product will appraise, and more times than none will end up being more costly over a projected return, but what price tag do you put on a project that you will enjoy and is fine tuned to your likes and lifestyle. If simply an investment for a quick buck, join the ranks of house flippers who put out shabby remodels, subpar materials, and usually have less than skilled labor turning out projects that look shiny, nice and new, but lack quality and longevity.

  • 19 years ago

    To my eye, most single-story homes look odd when a second floor is added. It can be done, but takes quite a bit of artistry to get right.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the great responses.

    Forgot to mention the most important thing, we live in Hawaii. My in-laws are not looking to sell anytime soon, if at all. And besides, the home costs are practically insignificant when buying a home in hawaii, we're paying for land. Good point to bring up about re-sale but that never popped into my mind.