Software
Houzz Logo Print
all_bout_flowers

Building a New house Disaster

15 years ago

Not to bore you with all the details, but I am in desperate need of advise. Building new house with what turned out to be a terrible contractor. Not only ethically but his subs do extremely crappy work. We have tried to get help from the inspectors but they seem to be very laxed with him. My husband knows a lot about building he worked various positions before and through this whole thing nothing has been up to par. The loan officer we have was here on the final walk through (which didn't pass) and she was busy whispering with our builder she seems to think his work is fine and we are being "unreasonable," to make him fix things. We are so confused were not sure why she would have any input. What are your experience with shotty work and the bank?

Comments (22)

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The word is "shoddy". Not being there, I do not know if you are being realistic. On my house, no bank was involved. I told those doing shoddy work not to return to my job site.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Was it a construction loan? If so, can you hold off on signing the last draw until it is corrected?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Without specifics on the "shoddy" work, it's hard to say. "Shoddiness" is a very subjective term--what's shoddy to you may not be shoddy to me. The bottom line is that the work passed code according to the inspectors and that's all that matters to the city/county/state as well as the bank.

    DH & I have seen alot of "shoddy" work done in homes that we wouldn't want to see in ours--but that work still passes code, the builder is proud of it, and people buy those houses. When we selected our builder, we chose one whose build quality had very little "shoddiness" in our opinion.

    So my questions in your situation would be this: Have you seen other homes your builder has built in your price range? How does your house stack up in comparison? What does your contract with the builder state as far as materials, quality and finish levels? Was anything specced in the contract either by him or you that was not carried out as described? Were you clear with the builder on your expectations/preferences? Did the contractor's bid/price seem too good to be true compared to other builders--did you think/were led to believe you were getting "champagne" finishes & quality for the price of "beer" finishes & quality? What didn't pass on the final walk through--are these simple fixes or is the whole kitchen and all baths getting torn out & redone? You mentioned the lender--is this the builder's preferred lender that you were referred to or is this a lender that you found on your own? Who is carrying the building loan: you or the builder? Who was in charge of the draws: you or the builder? Did the lender tell you directly that she thought you were being unreasonable and that the house should pass final walk through?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes, "shoddy" sorry for the mis-spelling. Yes, we did look at two houses, his model home/office and another built for a customer and both did not have the workmanship ours has (we are still researching but he may not of been the "Builder," of these houses his ex-partner was). My husband went back yesterday to look at the model home exterior and take pictures and it does not look like ours it was done like we remember and expected our to turn out. One major thing that was done to our house is that our TJI was cut completely out by the plumbers. My husband was under the house four weeks ago, keep in mind our house was 90% done at that point and found that our joist was 100% cut out in the guest bath for the drain and in the master bath the whole top part to the bottom of the joist was cut out. We asked our builder about it and he said that alway happens in this floor model, but our question is why wasn't it fixed before the house was almost complete? Our answer was he was hoping that it would get caught because our inspectors don't crawl under houses and I'm not just saying that he is not a very ethical builder-there's not enough space to tell all it took us 2 1/2 hours just to go over 3/4 of it with an attorney. Our inspector said, "just because it passes inspection doesn't mean it's right."

    The bank was chosen by us but, for some reason our loan officer has fallen spell to our builder and believes everything that comes out of his mouth and I'm not sure why. I have had two local builders at my house to do other work for me and said that there is no way they would do that quality of work on their houses. And I believe them I have been to see their houses and that is what we saw when we went to see the model home, of course we didn't crawl under the house to see if the TJI was cut out.

    Also, the inspector told me he didn't like the builder and one of the local builders I refered to met our builder when he was at my house. He had come over due to my request because my builder was accusing us of "tampering with our house", he also called my loan officer and told her that, this is one of the reasons the inspector doesn't like him. It was actually his subs that caused the problem.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Take lots of pictures and get your communication with the builder and inspector in writing. Write in detail everything that you believe to be wrong and why, and include pictures with the write up. Bring these to your banker and request a meeting with your loan officer and her manager. Also present these to the builder. Make sure everything is documented (without emotion.) You may need to consult a lawyer with expertise in this area.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "We have tried to get help from the inspectors but they seem to be very laxed with him."

    The inspectors are there for code enforcement only.

    If what the builder put up meets the minimum requirements of the building code the inspector has done his job.

    They are not there to help you enforce a contract beyond the code minimum.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    A GOOD builder looks at the plans and places framing members so that no major framing members must be cut to accommodate toilet drain piping and similar mechanicals. It may involve an extra joist with the joists placed on each side of the toilet drain location.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Out here you can header off the tji, but not out more than 30" from the sill plate, so it's dependent on the location of the toilet. Otherwise as bus driver states, you run an extra joist.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes, we have taken tons of pictures. My worry is that if the bank finds the house is not done to a certain standard ( the one in which we believe he was going to build) they may not give us the conventional loan at the end of the construction loan. I'm not sure if that is an issue since I have never built a house before.

    Ya, a GOOD builder would have move the floor joist you would think if this happens on every one of these floor models.

    Yes, inspector is just making sure the house meets code.

    So I believe on the work not being as good as the models we looked at I'm not sure if there is anything we can do. What recourse do we have?

    We also paid for all the upgrades like example our hemlock doors have runs in the varnish and finger prints. His response is "that's going to happen."

    I'd like to show everyone pictures of what he has done.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    1. As mentioned by others, inspectors not there for quality control just code enforcement. Really they are a joke. Permits are not to protect the citizen just a scam to get money out of you. They do not care about you or your families safety just want you get a couple grand out of you. They should have caught the butchered TJI though.
    2. Of course loan officer is going to side with builder. She wants to get this mess off of her hands and off the books. She doesnt want a botched custom.
    3. If your husband is so construction savvy he should have generaled himself. Its not as easy as it looks. Babysitting ex convicts and high school drop outs for 6-9 months is worth every penny a general makes.
    4. Just close on the house and sue the guy if he doesn't fix your punch list.

    I dont miss home building one bit. What a pain.

  • PRO
    15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    wow, now there is a bit of sunshine on a cloudy day...

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Your right about the inspectors my friend put me in contact with a really good friend of hers that is a builder in the big city he ranked 197 on the list of Engineering News Record and was also past president of our states Builders Association. He gave us some steps to do and an attorney that if anyone can help it would be him so I'm calling today. He also said you have no recourse against inspectors your house could fall down and kill you and you can't sue them. As of right now the inspector has not called us back since Thursday (when the inspection took place), and the builder has disappeard but has emailed the bank asking for his last draw to be paid. So here we are TJI still not fixed the garage/rec room just has R10 rigid board glued to the foundation and is not sheetrocked (needed to be done according to inspector since it will be living space), and the multitude of other things that were on the punch list. Wish us luck.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The only complaint you have been specific about has been the I-Joist installation. Building codes normally require these joists to be installed according to the manufacturer's instructions. Limitations to penetrations and modifications to the joists are carefully described. It is easy to get a copy of those instructions so do that and hire a knowledgeable person to evaluate the work. There's nothing subjective about it; the work either meets the standards or it doesn't. If it doesn't, it's a code violation.

    Here is a link that might be useful: see limits for

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I can't begin to tell you what a disaster today turned out to be. I got a call from our loan officer that she was told there was some "tampering" done at our house. My builder showed up today (he's been gone since Thursday, we thought he quit because he has not returned any calls) and called her to say that we were tampering with our house. All my husband did was take down two $180 track lights in the garage/rec room so they would get sheetrock dust on the while they sheetrocked the r-10 rigid board. He also called his friend at the heating company to come take a look at our A/C that the builders heating company had tried to level with rocks and scrap pieces of washers, and wood they found lying around( you would love to see a picture of this). So his friend being a license and trained TRANE technician disconnected the unit to keep in sound until it could be leveled properly. Well, after talking with our new attorney over the phone for 2 hours, he then got my loan officer on the phone for a three way call and she told him because of all the "TAMPERING" they might call the loan. Oh, I forgot that our builder told her to lock us out of our house until the CCB could come and do a walk through of his work which could take 30 days. That's when she ( and the banks attorney)decided since they cannot legal lock us out of the house they would 'Call the loan.' What a mess this sociapath builder has turned out to be I hope the next sucker that has him build a house is an attorney and sues the pants off of him.
    Oh, the other inspector approve the TJI cut out, I don't think he even went under the house to look, just took the guys word for it. We are still going through with our complaint to the CCB because there is no way he fixed it correctly.
    Light at the end of the tunnel we will put this house up for sale (it has too many bad memories) when the loan closes and never look back.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you modified the contractor's work without giving him sufficient notice and justification then you have probably made a serious mistake. The most serious aspect of it is that you have now muddied the water and will probably never be able to hold the contractor accountable for his errors.

    You need to stop thinking that two wrongs make a right and recognize that your actions can cause you serious harm. Bankers and contractors are professionals in the field of project delivery and to do battle with them you need a professional on your side. At this point it would have to be a lawyer but earlier it could have been an architect (a cheaper and better negotiator).

    This is your home and you should be able to exercise a certain amount of control but that is properly done with a provision in the contract for quality control and assurance (usually missing in a typical builder written contract so you need to add it). Without such a clause be very careful to not interfere with the contractor's right to manage and control the the Work of the contract.

    Read your contract carefully; I doubt it gives you the right to correct work unless the contractor has been notified and has failed to respond within a reasonable amount of time, like a month. It's time to pull back and try to salvage as much as you can with the advice of a professional.

    Advice here can only be general since we can't know the full extent of the problem or the history of it.

    I hate to see homeowners taken advantage of by building professionals. Asking a bank and contractor to act in your best interests is foolish but I realize it happens on most home construction projects since few homeowners want to pay for professional representation.

    In this case I would advise you to find an architect to advise your lawyer. I wish you luck.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It is important to understand that when serious disputes arise on a construction project, you should not communicate directly with the other parties since they can use what you say against you. Also, your surrogates should have some kind of legal standing in the community so it is best to use an architect, engineer or lawyer.

    The other side knows that they cannot use the statements of these representatives against you and that they might very well have to rebut their opinions in court at some later date.

    Bringing in a lawyer too early can also be a mistake since the other parties will then only communicate through their lawyers and endless letters written by lawyers to other lawyers is a very expensive game of chicken and you will break and settle before they will.

    In what state is the project located?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    It is important to understand that when serious disputes arise on a construction project, you should not communicate directly with the other parties since they can use what you say against you. Also, your surrogates should have some kind of legal standing in the community so it is best to use an architect, engineer or lawyer.

    The other side knows that they cannot use the statements of these representatives against you and that they might very well have to rebut their opinions in court at some later date.

    Bringing in a lawyer too early can also be a mistake since the other parties will then only communicate through their lawyers and endless letters written by lawyers to other lawyers is a very expensive game of chicken and you will break and settle before they will.

    In what state is the project located?

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Regarding the HVAC system, if this is in NC, a complaint to the licensing board in Raleigh will bring a field representative to the site. He will inspect and the contractor WILL correct any problems. The board will bring any court actions necessary to insure compliance. Other states may have similar provisions. But if the contractor did the job properly, the board will take no further action.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Your bank just wants to see the house finished (regardless of condition) so that they can get the construction loan off the books. They they'll probably sell the mortgage to someone else and you'll be history as far as the bank is concerned. Meanshile, your builder - no matter how bad he is - just might bring them in more business someday.

    In a similar situation, where I had chosen the banker and then my builder turned out to be terrible (like yours), my banker kept telling me that I couldn't fire my builder because then my house would never get done. And that was even after we got hit with liens from subs and materialmen that my builder had not paid and I was able to show the banker that builder was skimming money off of my build and was supplying the bank with false documents!

    After I finally decided I'd been screwed with long enough by the builder and fired him, I then had to go thru a long drawn out fight with my banker to get banker to FINALLY agree to allow me and DH to take down the rest of our loan so we could GC to finish our half-completed house ourselves.

    And, after the house was finally completed and we'd moved in, in the midst of litigation with my builder I learn that builder and banker had apparently become great buddies after we introduced them!!!! Banker had invited builder to play golf with him at banker's country club several times and builder had loaned banker the use of one of his "hunting leases." I do understand that the "boys" only invite other boys to play so I could understand why banker never invited me to play golf. I can live with the "good ole boys network" but DH, who can "good-ole-boy" with the best of em if need be, NEVER got an invite to play golf either! WE WERE THE BANK'S LONG TIME CUSTOMERS with a nice big personal account at bank that was NEVER overdrawn while builder opened a building account there after he started on our house and then bounced checks on it on a regular basis! GRRRR!!! Worst of all was that all the time banker kept telling me that I couldn't fire my builder, I kept believing that banker was a NEUTRAL party and his interests were at least aligned with mine to the extent of wanting to see my house get built and built reasonably decently. HAH! I'd have fired my builder months before I did - and saved myself at least $50K in damages - if banker had just kept his nose out of it!

    I do feel for you. Based on what you've said so far, it sounds like you're probably headed for litigation.
    I know you've said you've taken a "ton of pictures" but you need to document the current state of the entire house in a very systematic way. If you don't already own one, go invest a couple of hundred buck in a GOOD digital camera that will also take decent videos. Get several memory cards and one of those things that will let you quickly download your digital pictures instantly to a laptop. If you don't own a laptop, borrow one. Also get a some notepaper and a heavy duty marker pen and some blue painters tape.

    Go out to the house and post signs showing what room and where (north wall, east wall, etc.) each of the signs is located. Pictures of one wall of an empty house look much like pictures of another wall. The writing should be big enough that it is clearly visible when you videotape and there should be enough signs so that any picture you take has at least one sign in it. Then, in each room, start by taking a video starting in one corner of the and moving systematically and SLOWLY around the room, panning the camera up and down SLOWLY as you go so that every part of every wall, all parts of the floor, the entire ceiling, EVERYTHING winds up in the video. There should be enough signs posted around the room so that at least one of them is in view of the camera at all times. If a wall is not straight or a window is installed crooked or a door doesn't line up right, include a level and plumb bob in the video. When you finish videoing a room, repeat by taking still shots, one after another following the samy systematic plan of going around the room. Take still shots so that each image overlaps the previous one... and again make sure at least one of your signs is visible in every shot.

    Do the same thing in the basement, the attic, the exterior of the house, and - if you can possibly get a decent light under the house - do that as well.

    Pay particular care to get extra shots (from all angles) of any work that you have any reason to believe is substandard. But, just because you don't think there is a problem with something, don't skip over it entirely.

    From looking at my pictures, I discovered that after the plumbing inspection, my builder had cut and never repaired a waste drainage pipe running across my dining room ceiling (he had to put in some extra joists because he'd cut the stringers on some and the second floor was caving in!) Amazingly, until I saw it in the pictures, I never even NOTICED the cut drainage pipe running across the ceiling! Fortunately I reviewed all the pics before I hired a sheetrocker so we were able to fix the pipe before it got hidden behind sheetrock. Imagine the mess that would have been!

    Anyway, you want to document EVERYTHING about the current state of the house. You also want to hang onto all the previous pictures you've taken - regardless of how out of focus they might be - and try to get them organized by date and by room.

    The nice thing about digital photos is that you can see instantly if they're in focus or not.

    When a memory card gets full - or you finish with a room, download the images to the laptop. You can download literally thousands of digital photos to a laptop. Depending on the size of your house, it may take you four or five hours or even longer to do a really good job.

    Also, because it looks like you may very well wind up in litigation, hang onto every scrap of paper, every email, etc., every note you've taken, etc. that is in any way related to the house or to your relationship with this builder or your relationship with the banker... whether you think it paints you in a bad light or not. You have a legal obligation to do so once litigation appears probable.

    Other than taking pictures tho, do NOT do anything to the house so long as builder is still on the job. If builder quits, let the house sit until you either hear in writing from him that he has quit OR you and your lawyer notify him that the contract between you has been breached, he has been fired, and he is not to return to the property.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I know big mistake thinking my bank was my friend. I know they want to get the loan off their books she told me. My attorney says in no way pay them the rest of the $$ I owe them because of quality issues and the damage TJI that we won't know more about until the CCB comes out to investigate. We did not realize the amount of grief a few things would cause by the way the A/C is in OR. I did tell my builder today that any communication has to be in writing from now on so my attorney can look at it also (not that he will). I just discovered the guy that framed, roofed and sided my house is a Sole Prop. and has been fined for having employees, plus he has a few other fines on his license no wonder our house is out of square and the siding is aweful. I'm calling the CCB tomorrow to find out more specifics on his license. House is going to have it's second final inspection tomorrow I am told. If it passes then we will close the loan and put the house up for sale and move away from this aweful memory. Thank you for sharing your wisdom and your experience I know that we are not over with this headache but hopeful he'll want to go away and never come back. Luckily I did do some video taping along with a huge amount of pictures. The builder was always taking pictures to I'm not sure what of and why he would want to take pictures of that inadequate work. Our house will never look like the model homes we saw and I am very sad about that. I just hope we can get someone that knows what they are doing with the TJI's, that really scares me.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Be very careful documenting anything on site here. Unless you own the lot outright, the bank and/or the builder technically hold title to the property and can charge you with tresspassing and vandalism. You don't own anything until the loan closes.

  • 15 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Also, be aware - you will likely have to disclose any deficiencies in the building to any potential buyers...