I can't seem to post more than one photo, but here is a larger view of the front of the house so you can see the context of the paint. Thanks for your help.

one more photo of the back

There's already a lot of materials going on. You don't need another choice/color. Match the stucco.

Wanted to do that initially, but when we put the same color on the B&B, it looked different but not enough to be a contrast. The color in the middle is one shade darker. Would that work?