Software
Houzz Logo Print
juant81

making changes to a load bearing wall

13 years ago

We are building a new house. Its a 2 story house. There is a half wall on the first floor which comes out about 6' out. It was only supposed to be 4'. The house is framed and sheet rock is up.

When I told the builder to fix it, they said its a load bearing wall and that it cannot be fixed at this point.

I know nothing about construction, so I need some help from any contractors that might be reading this.

I don't understand why they can't just fix it, if it was listed in the plans as 4', not 6'. I am sure when they did the engineering and came up with the 4' wall everything must have checked out. Thats why they put it in the plans as 4'.

I kind of get the feeling that the builder will say anything at this point to avoid doing extra work, even if it is to fix their mistake.

Comments (6)

  • 13 years ago

    It can't be a "half wall" (not full height) and be load bearing so I assume you mean it is a partial wall that extends 6 ft instead of 4 ft from another wall.

    If it supports the end of a beam over an interior opening, shortening it would require removing and installing a longer header beam over the opening.

    Only the structural drawings will tell you what was originaly required and what can be done now unless you want to contact the structural designer (if that person isn't the contractor).

  • 13 years ago

    Sometimes things are missed and field changes have to occur in order to keep the home structurally sound. Did you ask him why the wall was now longer than it was on the original plan?

    The fix will require that jacks be used to support the ceiling and floors above, tearing down the wall, re-engineering the footing supporter underneath the new point load location, the installation of a new header or potentially a steel beam, and also install jack studs or columns, and then re-drywalling everything.

    It's not an "easy" fix at all. And it will most likely need a sign off by a structural engineer for the city's inspector to approve the change.

    This is an area that I'd suggest that rather than insisting on a change at this stage, you should potentially negotiate some other form of compensation for the error such as upgraded cabinets or more paint colors. It will cost the builder a lot to correct, so he should be willing to offer you something substantial so he doesn't have to do all of the work involved to correct it. He'll appreciate the flexibility on your part, especially if something unforseen, like a change in the floor plan of the room below, dictated that the length of the wall be changed or steel purchased to make the original design actually work.

  • 13 years ago

    If the 4 ft wall was shown on the plans and the beam was sized for that opening there should be no structural engineering or building official approval required to correct the mistake. It is therefore important to quickly find out what the contract/permit drawings specified before discussing this issue with the contractor.

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks everyone.

    Renovator8, yes its a partial wall.

    As to the question of why this change was made on site: We had originally opted for an upgraded optional feature in the home (during our initial builders meetings). Part of that upgrade we chose was to shorten this partial wall.

    When the framing started, they forgot all about the upgrade option we had selected and started to proceed with the "standard" layout. After the framing was done I noticed that they did the "standard" instead of the "upgraded" option we had selected. I notified the builder. They fixed everything else except for this wall. In the standard layout this wall goes out 6' and in the upgraded optional layout this wall only goes out 4'.

    I wonder if I can call up the city and see what was in the permit. I will try that.

  • 13 years ago

    The city's role is to make sure the home is built to code. As long as the open span was done with the correct sized beam for the opening, they don't care about if the wall was 4' or 6'.

    But, if it was framed from the beginning with a 6' wall, then it's highly doubtful that the support beam is long enough, or large enough to be able to take that wall back to 4' without a LOT of reconstruction. Expensive reconstruction. I'm sure that the builder would much rather refund you the upgrade cost than to have to tear everything out and redo it. It will be cheaper. If he's like most production builders, it will likely be a struggle on your part to get him to do what he agreed to.

  • 13 years ago

    The only protection you have is your contract and it should reference the design drawing. If instead of a set of final drawings, the contract is based on a standard plan with upgrades that were not properly documented, you are probably at their mercy. However, they were willing to make the part of the upgrade that did not involve changing a beam so they have essentially admitted their error. What you need now is a lawyer.